About Award winnng tag

[Tcof]

Not sure if this ever bring up. But you know, this tag is something you expect some kind of high quality storytelling that selected by profession people. It is a guarantee in this sea of tittle. So i think it need to be a bit more strict. I never up a manga on this so i don't know. Do the tag get checked by mangadex staff or anything ?

Because i just try it one time to days and a lot of tittle make me doubt is it really won anything ?
-Shoujo and shounen manga have won in shoujo, shounen award or of that Magazine award. Sure, make sense. they are long and usually popular. Fary tail also won something.
-Recently i see Award vote by audience (some even you can vote through internet). so yeah, it decide by the popular. I mean it still a win. And argue this is just raise another topic and a lot of work. So yeah, let this aside
-Also , i expect it was like "best picture of the year" like for movie. So i kinda confused when see ''get 4th place...''. Well yeah, whatever
-Some didn't write anything on the description, so i search it and didn't find anything say they won any award. Some are just nominated. Now, this is not ok

 

[shouldsleep]

This is some weird shitty gatekeeping you're trying to make. Who decides which "award" is up to standards? You?

For your points
1. Kodansha, where FT won, has a ton of titles, and just because you with your elitist attitude feel like it doesn't deserve an award like that doesn't mean you're right.

2. Audience vote awards tend to allow more titles than publisher specific awards. Now if public opinion isn't your cup of tea, then sucks to be you.

3. Getting a 4th place is still an award, just like getting a bronze medal in Olympics is still an award vs getting nada.

4. Don't know about that one.

 

[Tcof]

@shouldsleep
Dude, i still give them a ok. From 1 to 4 to the point i don't think it ok anymore.
So again it you get it wrong. I don't say we rip all the award tag of them away. That was just me want say random thing i want to say.
Only the last one is not ok

 

[war-ble]

I only agree in the sense that there should be an complementary tag added for nominations, since it's definitely incorrect to tag a manga that was nominated but did not win as "Award Winning".

Something like
- Award Nominated
- Award Nominee
- Nominated for an Award