But Emi will literally call her mommy now!so emi reborn as remilia daughter. while its good, but still no yuri route.
While I understand the argument, that only makes sense if this was a story where you can't come back with your memories. In this case Emi was given the choice to retain her memories with almost no catch but chose not to anyway so she could move on. It doesn't make sense to say it's not a good ending just because she made a choice you don't agree with.As nice as it is that this got a good ending the fact that Emi who was pretty much the driving force behind this whole thing is in all functionality dead.
Call me a pessimist but I don't consider full loss of previous self with no chance of them coming back style reincarnation endings as good endings for characters.
It's not them anymore really. It's a totally new person built on an entirely new foundation that was made out of the recycled scraps of someone who once was but will never be again.
Their relationship was more sisterly.so emi reborn as remilia daughter. while its good, but still no yuri route.