You know the premise is workable. What messes it up is the insanely fast pace and the lack of any kind of personality from the girl. It would make this a lot more interesting if she was given the option to stay or not, and they had to compete for her. Not only is that a chance for hella no string smut opportunities, it would make this make more sense. That being said I'm likely still gonna read at least a few more chapters because I am a simple woman sometimes lol. Those character designs tho.