Centaur no Nayami - Vol. 8 Ch. 49

Double-page supporter
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
91
Christ they actually made an alternate universe holocaust
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 28, 2018
Messages
2,489
It doesn't stop being funny how a manga that keeps portraying dark-haired female characters as weak and blonde ones as strong thinks it can be this preachy about discrimination and expect people to take it seriously. :D
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 23, 2019
Messages
639
*Manga about an alternate version of our reality shows events from the alternate history*

narrowminded "vocal" readers: WHUH BUH DISCRIMINATION UHH PREACHY DURR


C'mon, get over yourselves. And that hair color obsession is still creepy, @Pachka84

Still super creepy. Hope you're doing better these days.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 23, 2019
Messages
639
Oh a positive and relevant note, great chapter!

Poignant and interesting as always ^_^ I love how these issues are tackled.
This manga is wonderful, even when it gets a bit heavy like this. Good stuff!
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 10, 2018
Messages
2,305
This isn't even particularly preachy, the messaging is utterly confused. It's never made clear exactly why Centaur-Hitler put them in the concentration camp, beyond not acting in the national interest, which is boilerplate fascism but not particularly to do with racism or other discriminatory bigotry. If we assume Centaur-Hitler had the same motives as Human-Hitler, who are the Jews? The homosexuals and academics? Gypsies and Poles? Also, how the fuck do you adapt a Sherman M4 tank for centaur use?
 
Member
Joined
Dec 9, 2023
Messages
29
This isn't even particularly preachy, the messaging is utterly confused. It's never made clear exactly why Centaur-Hitler put them in the concentration camp, beyond not acting in the national interest, which is boilerplate fascism but not particularly to do with racism or other discriminatory bigotry. If we assume Centaur-Hitler had the same motives as Human-Hitler, who are the Jews? The homosexuals and academics? Gypsies and Poles? Also, how the fuck do you adapt a Sherman M4 tank for centaur use?

My good person, the people in those camps were still Jews/Gypsies/Poles/Academics (or some equivalent "Enemies of the state" stand-in for this Manga world).
I know your comment is over 2 years old but I'm on a role so maybe others will read this some day:

On Page 2:
  • Hitler is an Angel, not a Centaur (not that it matters much)
  • On the panel before we see Hitler he talks about all the 5 races living in harmony before the "Parasites"
  • Angel-Hitler put them in the camps for no good reason at all
Pages 3-9:
  • We see the Jews/Victims are a mix of all the races (Centaur, Angel, Imp, Satyr, Long-Ears) except Mermaid.
  • The Nazis also appear to cover most of the races as well (couldn't find an Imp and Satyr in the far shots)
  • We only see a Centaur "Allied" soldier (page 14) but I assume there are other species in the Sherman M4 tank, clear Centaur discrimination
Page 9:
  • The old man talking to the kids mentions how before people were discriminating against size and shape (species) and indicates that those who are not are discriminating based on nation or race (I assume they mean akin to the Jewish race instead of "human" race)
Page 10:
  • Old man talks about "Science Fiction" where if there weren't different species (aka our world) then the world would be at peace.
  • As old man point out, there would still be war and discrimination based on nationality, race, colour of skin and so on (as there is in our world)
The general point being that even in a world where different species exist (or don't exist), people will still find ways to discriminate and spread hatred against one another.

I'll be killed before the war is over. I'll either be executed here as a prisoner, or as a traitor when we get out.
But you have to live on.
Hatred makes monsters of all men, sometimes the only choice you have is which kind of monster you will be.
 
Last edited:
Member
Joined
Jul 29, 2020
Messages
12
My good person, the people in those camps were still Jews/Gypsies/Poles/Academics (or some equivalent "Enemies of the state" stand-in for this Manga world).
I know your comment is over 2 years old but I'm on a role so maybe others will read this some day:

On Page 2:
  • Hitler is an Angel, not a Centaur (not that it matters much)
  • On the panel before we see Hitler he talks about all the 5 races living in harmony before the "Parasites"
  • Angel-Hitler put them in the camps for no good reason at all
Pages 3-9:
  • We see the Jews/Victims are a mix of all the races (Centaur, Angel, Imp, Satyr, Long-Ears) except Mermaid.
  • The Nazis also appear to cover most of the races as well (couldn't find an Imp and Satyr in the far shots)
  • We only see a Centaur "Allied" soldier (page 14) but I assume there are other species in the Sherman M4 tank, clear Centaur discrimination
Page 9:
  • The old man talking to the kids mentions how before people were discriminating against size and shape (species) and indicates that those who are not are discriminating based on nation or race (I assume they mean akin to the Jewish race instead of "human" race)
Page 10:
  • Old man talks about "Science Fiction" where if there weren't different species (aka our world) then the world would be at peace.
  • As old man point out, there would still be war and discrimination based on nationality, race, colour of skin and so on (as there is in our world)
The general point being that even in a world where different species exist (or don't exist), people will still find ways to discriminate and spread hatred against one another.


Hatred makes monsters of all men, sometimes the only choice you have is which kind of monster you will be.
Incredible how this manga really challenge some people comprehension of media huh. Alot of people just seem to not understand that this manga is a slide of life that hiding a depiction of racial discrimination, alienating differences, and generational hatred despite we all human bleeding red. Hell the author pretty much spelled everything out in this very chapter. But at the same time this manga also want to show that despite the difficulty, time will change, people will change, younger generation should be born and raised without being under influence of the hate of old.
 
Member
Joined
Jul 29, 2020
Messages
12
Some might think the author is a nationalist who tried to spread propaganda about how Japan is progressive and accepting even tho they aren't (I won't agree or deny it even if I saw this take multiple time before). But I like to hope too, I want to think that this is the hope of the author, hope that people will be better, hope that new generation won't inherit the old grudge, hope that one day we won't have to fear accidentally offend someone just because we haven't understand each other's principle.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top