Thanks for the chapter :D
I love how this chapter implies that Ayase ordered Coke high-balls because she was thinking of Chihaya. As someone else said, we all need an Ayase in our lives.
That aside, I think I'm beginning to understand Chihaya. She's not just someone with a "woe is me" mentality; she has this mentality and is aware of how this mentality makes her struggle. She is absolutely aware that the reason why she feels stuck is because she has a mental breakdown every time a setback occurs. It is absolutely her own fault.
The issue is, she is past believing in changing this mentality: every time she tried to prove that she can make a change in her life and outlook, external circumstances have caused her to fail. If her life being a mess is her own fault, to what extent are her actions and reactions determined by her? She feels doomed to fail again and again because of herself, which is the one thing she feels she cannot change.
In this sense, she is just as rational as Mio. Common sense can't save her because she knows exactly what is wrong with herself. She knows that she wants to run, but doesn't believe life will let her.
It's hard not to relate. It feels wrong saying that without bringing up personal anecdotes – which I'm sure we all have – but I think, like Chihaya, I'm not ready to talk about past experiences of failure yet.
Really, Mio is the only way out for Chihaya. She needs an irrational urge to improve that can overcome her more rational mentality of "I can't improve because I won't improve." Being drunk helps too, I guess.
Lastly, this is a bit of a reach, but I just noticed that Chihaya's t-shirt has a very angry tanuki on it. I'm not familiar with Japanese culture at all, but Tanuki symbolize transformation and change, which is rather apt for this chapter. If this was intentional, that's pretty neat.
The fact that I can personally relate to Chihaya
should fill me with resentment and a bit of dread, but honestly it's refreshing being introduced to a protagonist that just...well, as you said, is justifiably defeatist and pissed at everyone and everything about it.
And most importantly - in a way that absolutely makes sense,
and is vindicated by the fact that it's not
quite all her fault, as you stated. I wager every human being out there has some way to relate to Chihaya on some level, and that humanness of her state of mind and being over all the shit that's happened to and around her, makes her intensely likeable, even as one might hesitate to ever try and express the
why.
And you don't see that often in manga, maybe literature at large - at least not done in a way that makes you want to root for a character, and not feel exhausted or annoyed by them. The author really did thread the needle of a down-and-out protagonist who whines and complains and despairs, and does so in a way that makes you empathize and sympathize, and want to see her come out the other end standing tall.
I agree that Mio is the way to that; though I'm curious if this will be a story purely of Chihaya's growth and redemption, having been "left behind" by everyone around her, or if others will have their own struggles and journeys that they will embark upon alongside her.
Mio's clearly got her own stuff going on, even if it seems like nothing compared to Chihaya (going off what we can see due to Chihaya's POV bias), and given the two are seemingly inextricably linked over this history between them, I daresay Mio's got her own arc to push through as well.
Excited to find out, though.