Choujin Koukousei-tachi wa Isekai demo Yoyuu de Ikinuku you desu! - Vol. 4 Ch. 24 - The Twilight Flame
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
Double-page supporter
- Joined
- Mar 4, 2018
- Messages
- 550
Jesus...What the hell was that? You can't write characters whose only trait is being a bastard. It makes absolutely no sense why he's in any position of authority or why anybody would still dare to live in this country. In Overlord, citizens were fleeing Ainz Ooal Gown's country as fast as they could because they thought they were going to get demolished. Why do none of the citizens here think in the same way?
You can't say that I'm overthinking this, or that I should "turn my brain off". Anybody that's seen actually interesting villains like the Goddess from Moon-led Journey, or even the Administrator from SAO Alicization, would be bursting out laughing at how bullshit this writing is.
I don't need every manga to be a GITS philosophical endeavor. I don't even need every manga to be a Rougo ni Sonaete Isekai level of competence. I just want to be able to read some isekai without smashing my head on my keyboard every few seconds.
You can't say that I'm overthinking this, or that I should "turn my brain off". Anybody that's seen actually interesting villains like the Goddess from Moon-led Journey, or even the Administrator from SAO Alicization, would be bursting out laughing at how bullshit this writing is.
I don't need every manga to be a GITS philosophical endeavor. I don't even need every manga to be a Rougo ni Sonaete Isekai level of competence. I just want to be able to read some isekai without smashing my head on my keyboard every few seconds.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Apr 2, 2018
- Messages
- 404
"Turn off your brain."
The only reason I read this is for a couple of minute fix of serious-sounding stupidity ?
The only reason I read this is for a couple of minute fix of serious-sounding stupidity ?
- Joined
- Apr 26, 2018
- Messages
- 10
He a Madman
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 29, 2018
- Messages
- 1,143
Excuse me?
I thought those that can escape already escaped, that's why the town under the jingoist rule is relatively empty.
And iirc, that couple hanging in the basement are their first catch in a few month, meaning travelers already distancing themselves from that town.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 20, 2018
- Messages
- 2,990
Time for a rant:
Yet again the "nobles are evil" cliche gets used to the point of stupidity in an isekai story because its needs a villain who is comically evil and edgy so the heroes can have the moral high ground.
Do isekai authors really think that a supreme idiot like this guy would last more than a week in charge before getting assassinated, facing revolution or being turned into the tool of someone more competent?
Nobles might have been dicks and some of them indeed did terrible or stupid things but no noble would be stupid enough to think peasants can be just starved to death and everything will be fine, or at least no noble who would get as far as this dude did. They were the people with access to superior education and being taught how to rule their land was probably one of the first things they learned.
Do isekai authors really think that a supreme idiot like this guy would last more than a week in charge before getting assassinated, facing revolution or being turned into the tool of someone more competent?
Nobles might have been dicks and some of them indeed did terrible or stupid things but no noble would be stupid enough to think peasants can be just starved to death and everything will be fine, or at least no noble who would get as far as this dude did. They were the people with access to superior education and being taught how to rule their land was probably one of the first things they learned.
Active member
- Joined
- Apr 21, 2018
- Messages
- 452
In Warhammer 40K this guy would be an exemplary human being.
Fed-Kun's army
- Joined
- Jan 23, 2018
- Messages
- 192
40K had 40,000 years of fluff to back the excessive use of force to subjugate rebellions.
Historically, over-taxation and brutal suppression was not uncommon.
Historically, over-taxation and brutal suppression was not uncommon.
In the Roman Republic in order to reduce the load on the central administration they would put up taxation of an area for auction to anyone to bid what they felt they could gather from the locals. The extra tax would be kept by the collectors for profits which escalated pretty quickly into the over-taxation of the population.
However, one thing to keep in mind about tax was that it was not always done through gold. People paid tax however they could, often through paying with grain. Nobility could be valued by their ability to tax the grain from their peasants to the point where the farmers only had just enough grain/rice to feed themselves. If they took too much the people would starve and the grain gained the next year would plummet. If not enough was taken it was either considered a waste and could potentially feed rebellions. During japan's '200 years of peace' the shogun made sure to tax the pants off their people by adding new ways to drain the lord's coffers, resulting in a pretty shit life for most peasants.
What we see in this chapter would inflate the value of gold to such a degree that they would have to sell off a HUGE amount of grain and other commodities to exchange for gold to make statues.
However, one thing to keep in mind about tax was that it was not always done through gold. People paid tax however they could, often through paying with grain. Nobility could be valued by their ability to tax the grain from their peasants to the point where the farmers only had just enough grain/rice to feed themselves. If they took too much the people would starve and the grain gained the next year would plummet. If not enough was taken it was either considered a waste and could potentially feed rebellions. During japan's '200 years of peace' the shogun made sure to tax the pants off their people by adding new ways to drain the lord's coffers, resulting in a pretty shit life for most peasants.
What we see in this chapter would inflate the value of gold to such a degree that they would have to sell off a HUGE amount of grain and other commodities to exchange for gold to make statues.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Apr 4, 2018
- Messages
- 6,446
@ Acolytus well history has lot of examples like maria antoniette? just add the "magic element" and you get that.
is human nature to try and suppress others given the chance...
is human nature to try and suppress others given the chance...
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 24, 2018
- Messages
- 4,551
@Acolytus: If you want stories where non-ally nobles aren't complete trash, may I suggest
Ascendance of Bookworm.
Well, right now there's barely a presence of nobles in the translated part, but they'll show up.
There's certainly plenty enough of trashy, brainless nobles, but surprisingly they're the minority.
The majority of them have their own reasons to do things they do.
Like a guy who's overbearing with his methods because that's the tradition from his region (a man who NEVER gives up not matter how many time he's rejected....the same region also have girls who propose by pinning down their target in a hold before proposing too)
Or someone who force the girl to do something only out of desperation on his side.
Well, right now there's barely a presence of nobles in the translated part, but they'll show up.
There's certainly plenty enough of trashy, brainless nobles, but surprisingly they're the minority.
The majority of them have their own reasons to do things they do.
Like a guy who's overbearing with his methods because that's the tradition from his region (a man who NEVER gives up not matter how many time he's rejected....the same region also have girls who propose by pinning down their target in a hold before proposing too)
Or someone who force the girl to do something only out of desperation on his side.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 29, 2018
- Messages
- 1,143
@Acolytus:
Not to mention that he might not be a noble in the first place since his land is given to him due to his effort in the battlefield.
Also just gonna mention that the rebelling side also have a few nobles backing them, so I guess it's not exactly the "nobles are evil" cliche.
The evil nobles are still comically evil so far though, so yeah.
Seeing his abnormal obsessiveness over loyalty to the king, I say he's already a tool of someone more competent.
Not to mention that he might not be a noble in the first place since his land is given to him due to his effort in the battlefield.
Also just gonna mention that the rebelling side also have a few nobles backing them, so I guess it's not exactly the "nobles are evil" cliche.
The evil nobles are still comically evil so far though, so yeah.
Power Uploader
- Joined
- Jan 18, 2018
- Messages
- 1,277
when nobles inbreed too much
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 18, 2018
- Messages
- 1,907
Uwa... An empire or kingdom, is nothing without the commoners to support it... If he just take all their means of survival to make gold statues, who will be left to pay those taxes after they all died/left ? This is why inbreed nobles are such a pain, they can't see something as simple as that.
@kaminomikan
Actually, Marie Antoinette only was queen and had no power over state matters, as that power was purely invested into the king's hands, thanks to policie taken by Louis the XIV.
In fact, even her statement of "let them eat cake" has been debated over, and more or less people realized she meant it as "can't we give them cakes cause we gots a butt ton in the palace?"
If you really want to know why France went to shit right before the Revolution, look into the reign of Louis XV.
That being said, do realize that nobles are first and foremost soldiers; they were awarded titles and land, as well as exemption from taxes, in return for using that income to raise a force as well as lead said force in battle. Countries with longer periods of peace have low numbers of nobility (France having around <1% of the population), while those that experience lots of warfare tend to have proportionally more.
Additionally, stories about aristocracy are either aimed at "commoners" to gain popularity, or for propaganda reasons such as the Renaissance era writers trying to make the previous Medieval period look like a shithole in history.
@adfjs
You do realize that Kim Jong Un grew up in Switzerland and attended classes there? He's been confirmed to be a basketball nerd and idolizes Michael Jordan, and was apparently a PC gamer.
Actually, Marie Antoinette only was queen and had no power over state matters, as that power was purely invested into the king's hands, thanks to policie taken by Louis the XIV.
In fact, even her statement of "let them eat cake" has been debated over, and more or less people realized she meant it as "can't we give them cakes cause we gots a butt ton in the palace?"
If you really want to know why France went to shit right before the Revolution, look into the reign of Louis XV.
That being said, do realize that nobles are first and foremost soldiers; they were awarded titles and land, as well as exemption from taxes, in return for using that income to raise a force as well as lead said force in battle. Countries with longer periods of peace have low numbers of nobility (France having around <1% of the population), while those that experience lots of warfare tend to have proportionally more.
Additionally, stories about aristocracy are either aimed at "commoners" to gain popularity, or for propaganda reasons such as the Renaissance era writers trying to make the previous Medieval period look like a shithole in history.
@adfjs
You do realize that Kim Jong Un grew up in Switzerland and attended classes there? He's been confirmed to be a basketball nerd and idolizes Michael Jordan, and was apparently a PC gamer.
Similar threads
