Off to save the
girl.
@WillTell : Is is showing the Guildmaster's hypocrisy. Myne broke a rule, but it was one where he was in his rights to break that rule since the GM was abusing his authority to get what he wanted. However there are numerous others who have broken more rules, and caused issues for the guild, who are still members. Those likely include individuals were reprimanded by the GM and broke more rules but a still members. Simply put the GM has no valid excuse for expelling Myne as long as the rest are still members since genuinely did nothing wrong as the GM was well out of place in his demands but the others have, and will continue to, cause issues for the guild. If anything the question just shows how crappy a Job the GM is doing, he has lost 3 adventurers in a few days largely due to his own mismanagement.
@Phillip898 : still a stupid question, because the guildmaster should have known not to make that demand, he is not royalty.
@wanfai : If I recall, the guild is pretty much filled with social outcasts and exists on the fringes of society. That the C-Rank idiot went straight to murder over a girl is a good example of that. The guild master does have a responsibility to the guild, and could use that to justify needing to know Mines skills. But what is more important is that Myne is someone who would bring positive results to the guild, and good PR. Quite frankly Mynes skill set is not what was important, but the results and the Guild master has no excuse for not realizing that.
@Kireato : yup,
@johnpoop2529 : 2 is not a harem.
@kolemetz : No, he just has morals and knows that this is the only chance to save the girl from the violations the Orcs would enforce on her.