Eiyuu to Majo no Tensei LoveCome - Ch. 10

Double-page supporter
Joined
Nov 13, 2018
Messages
205
So the manga goes different route from the novel (I mean they already redesign some of the characters)?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 3, 2023
Messages
1,355
damn so everyone's gonna reincarnate as someone from his old world? i kinda already liked the dynamic with just shiina
Yeah, everyone in the world's reincarnated from his fantasyland. You were some random commoner that owned six saddles & zero horses and I was some random assassin that died on their first mission by tripping over a dandelion. And the author was a snail that the hero crushed on the day of his execution.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 24, 2024
Messages
443
Is she from his former party? man everybody just reincarnated to modern japan at this point.
if that’s the case that’d be pretty disappointing since shiina said she only reincarnated both of them who died at the same time, it wouldn’t make sense if hina is also a reincarnated person.

i think it’s actually more in line to someone who knew the mc in the other world (maybe the priestess or magician of the hero party) knew that he got reincarnated and found a way to possess hina.

EDIT: now that I think about it, they showed memories of a dragon so that might be who is possessing hina rn
 
Member
Joined
Aug 24, 2019
Messages
17
Is this original scene? I forgot this scene was happen on novel or not
nope. iirc this kind of development doesn't exist in the novel.

imo this is just editorial decision. they probably thought that the original source was just too short. tbh, now that i've read chapter 11, i must say that i don't like this development.

i felt a little bit anxious about shiina's position in the story & the plot after reading chapter 10. but, chapter 11 completely resolved that anxiety in a disappointing kind of way. i feel really bad for hina. she turned into a weird character for the sake of prolonging the story. the original source, though short & predictable, is better.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 6, 2019
Messages
578
oh good.. now childhood friend have a chance to get higher ground
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 25, 2024
Messages
2,827
WHAT IN THE ACTUAL FUCK WAS THAT?
gftri6.jpg
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 7, 2019
Messages
126
Definitely a dragon. Her eyes became dragon-like for a second there.
 
Joined
Nov 28, 2020
Messages
6
nope. iirc this kind of development doesn't exist in the novel.

imo this is just editorial decision. they probably thought that the original source was just too short. tbh, now that i've read chapter 11, i must say that i don't like this development.

i felt a little bit anxious about shiina's position in the story & the plot after reading chapter 10. but, chapter 11 completely resolved that anxiety in a disappointing kind of way. i feel really bad for hina. she turned into a weird character for the sake of prolonging the story. the original source, though short & predictable, is better.
And also as long I remember there are one girl named Yuuka, she is friend of Hina and become love interest with Shinji. But we don't know she exist or not in manga version.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 20, 2023
Messages
2,151
I'm guessing she's not reincarnated, but is being used as a medium to talk to him by someone from his old world
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 27, 2018
Messages
972
Kangaroos eh? Foreshadowing that the isekai was really just central Australia the whole time?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 20, 2024
Messages
335
Foreshadowing that the isekai was really just central Australia the whole time?
An isekai story in central Australia — that looks like a familiar concept: I remember a Russian novel where the final part of the story happens in a parallel world (Earth-alike) in central Australia. “Рыцарь Ордена”.

And yes, starting from this chapter, “Eiyuu to Majo no Tensei LoveCome” manga diverts from the original story to rewrite at least one female character as a reincarnated non-human. I am relieved that they seem less destined just to suffer. On the other hand, a reincarnated non-human is a trope that rarely works good because it usually makes its story's author obsessed with playing with that character's non-human traits for a long time without advancing the rest of the plot. For example, “Boy Meets Girl, Again!”. Let's just hope that the plot of “Eiyuu to Majo no Tensei LoveCome” can be lengthened more meaningfully than that one, especially because this chapter concentrated on the human Japanese part of the character without discarding it in the favour of the reincarnated dragon part. What do we know, we might even eventually get some flashback to a full-fledged tragic interspecies romance (“I love you so much, but it breaks my heart that I won't ever bear your child, and also I am actually a huge dragon and thus we have never been meant to ever be together, and also you need me to be a dragon because the whole world is in danger and might really perish unless we risk both of our lives to do something, so let us just die together a honourable death on the battlefield”) like in DragonLance series, for example.

This comparison is not an arbitrary one. After all, one of the very first pages here seems to offer the hero almost the same¹ sad choice: “Will you choose one of them? Or will you choose the world?”

ykznr.webp


Now we know that this choice, despite not really existing in the original story (if we do not count the necessity to dispel the curse, but that was not really a matter of a choice), can nevertheless happen in the altered storyline. The most simple opportunity looks like this: if the newly presented dragon lady ever wins a favour from Hero Grey, the witch might feel abandoned and “fuck it all, I have decided to also curse this world right now” — and that is how his choice of a lover might spell doom for the whole world as we know it.

Of course, it'll never be just as simple. What'll complicate things is the matter of the cute kouhai: will she ever be revealed to be yet another reincarnated love interest? — and if so, then who is she? The most interesting it would be for her to be a female cleric (not unlike Ciel in “Tsukihime”) or a noblewoman (maybe even a princess) that quietly fell in love with Hero Grey and then had to feel some humiliation (of NTR-alike nature: “I have loved him first”)² when by siding himself with the witch he betrayed not just the cause but also that love that remained unknown³ to him. But, honestly speaking, that kouhai could be literally anyone after we have been already shown a dragoness despite the original story not mentioning any dragons even once iirc. I mean it! At this point as a reader I won't be surprised even if she is revealed to be a gender-swapped sage that says, “I had to execute you, bro, but I have always loved you homosexually and dreamt of becoming a woman for you — and thus here I am”, for example. I can only hope it's not that kind of a story.

____________

¹ To be fair I have to add a note saying that it is questionable whether Huma Dragonbane in DragonLance has ever been offered a real choice between his love and his noble death (together with his beloved dragoness) on the battlefield for the sake of the world's fate. The legends about them told by Silvara in “Dragons of Winter Night” say that the choice was very real, while the events of the alternative storyline in “The Legend of Huma” does not leave much of a conscious choice until it's too late to be real.

² The correct term for that kind of NTR-alike feelings of a female character (if she never confessed but nevertheless becomes painfully jealous when her beloved falls in love with another woman) is “WSS”, which is an abbreviation of 「私が先に好きだったのに」 (pronounced as “watashi ga saki ni suki datta no ni”) meaning “even though I loved him first”. (Source: Japanese Wikipedia.)

³ To be clear, here I hypothesize that the third female character never confessed her feelings to the hero in the original world and that was the reason behind her not appearing in any of his earlier flashbacks and regrets about the past. But, on the other hand, we have also never seen a dragoness there yet, but here she is. Hence take my reasoning with a grain of salt.
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Top