I think its fine that people had differing opinions, whether it was positives or negatives.
What is not fine though, IMO, is that some of
@jak opinion are made solely on a nonexisting plot/prediction he came up on his own, and somehow irked by his own thought.
I'm definitely mostly agree with him, that cheating is a deal breaker for myself, and would love to see some kind of repercusion for it, even though i love yuri. But i'd like to see more on where would they author go with this, before judging how it MIGHT justify the cheating..
But i have trust in Shimura Takako, she had an excellent track record on creating a realistic portrayal of love, at least in my own opinion.