I came back here to reread Arthur's fight. Might as well finish it again.
I like Tamaki (heck, I drew fan art of her) yet I still think Tamaki is a missed opportunity for a badass fire catgirl.
It is funny though that pearl clutchers were losing their mind over her existence, and some of the readers here too. Somehow, when the world and the laws of nature itself are literally on fire, and Arthur deluding himself to fucking BREATH IN SPACE are less believable than Tamaki's Lucky Lecher.