Member
- Joined
- Aug 23, 2025
- Messages
- 2
I hope this won't be taken down by DMCA after it gots official translated by Viz....
I’d say see how they do, and if they sit on raws for a while/don’t keep up TL quality, then maybe pick it up then?Interesting. I didn't want to announce anything until it was more concrete, but I was also planning on picking this up. At least until the simulpub kicked in. Is that something people would still want, or should I let this guy stretch his wings a bit?
I'm conflicted. On the one hand, I appreciate this person stepping up and doing their best to carry the series forward, and want to encourage more people supporting scanlation. On the other hand: this is a popular and widely adored series, you do a fantastic job with all of your works, and I want to see this rendered in the best quality possible. Is this really a good beginner scanlation work?Interesting. I didn't want to announce anything until it was more concrete, but I was also planning on picking this up. At least until the simulpub kicked in. Is that something people would still want, or should I let this guy stretch his wings a bit?
Savior🛐
Yep, I prefer when honorifics are kept in the translations as well. Honorifics in romance manga are an indicator of how close characters are to each other and of other aspects of their relationship. While the focus is on the main couple, their relationships and honorific usage with other characters can be an important aspect in the character development of main characters.Don't forget the honorifics, please and thank!
Mods add one electron to every atom in their bodyDamn, this translation is so much better than the other one. Good thing they stopped. 👨🦼
As someone else also put it, maybe you can try waiting and see how Asinthe handles the series, or maybe coordinate with them somehow someway.Interesting. I didn't want to announce anything until it was more concrete, but I was also planning on picking this up. At least until the simulpub kicked in. Is that something people would still want, or should I let this guy stretch his wings a bit?
100% agree with this. the text outside the bubbles not being translated is the biggest issue for mePlease translate the small dialogues or text, because they sometimes serve as an important continuation of the dialogue balloons, like on pages 3 and 11-14. About the formatting, it'll be better if you increase the spacing between lines, so the text doesn't look too stacked. And if you have time, you can start learning to translate the SFXs too, like what Senko has done consistently. Overall, it's quite a good translation, and I hope you continue improving your future translations.
personally a big fan of your scanlation quality, so it would be nice. that said, current new scanlator is also doing a good job (just needs to translate the small text outside the bubbles). maybe work together?Interesting. I didn't want to announce anything until it was more concrete, but I was also planning on picking this up. At least until the simulpub kicked in. Is that something people would still want, or should I let this guy stretch his wings a bit?
The translation looks really solid, for a begginer so I think it would be kinda a dick move to compete with someone just starting, especially if it's a really good translator.Interesting. I didn't want to announce anything until it was more concrete, but I was also planning on picking this up. At least until the simulpub kicked in. Is that something people would still want, or should I let this guy stretch his wings a bit?