Gimai Seikatsu - Vol. 4 Ch. 23.2

[shinshom]

of course they'll get shunned cause japanese can't keep out of others ppl's business if manga are to be believed. i just hope you don't talk about this incest/half-sibling crap irl and just look the words up cause this is fucking embarassing.

I grew up in a japanese community in Brazil... even even here... believe me.... they are THIS much of a gossip intrusive kind of ppl XD.......

So wait, are you really saying that siblings formed though marriage are not considered legally half-siblings? In your country is different or you are just in denyal?

 

[MrTurtleMan]

in almost every country in the world, siblings formed though marriage are legally called half-siblings.... what are you even talking about? Do you live in a cave?

No I live in a house, with the internet and a quick google search of the definition of half sibling and the definition of step sibling shows that you are wrong, not that I need to because unlike you I speak English as a 1st language, that is why I know the difference

 

[MrTurtleMan]

I grew up in a japanese community in Brazil... even even here... believe me.... they are THIS much of a gossip intrusive kind of ppl XD.......

So wait, are you really saying that siblings formed though marriage are not considered legally half-siblings? In your country is different or you are just in denyal?

LMAO I just guessed you were speaking English not as a 1st language based on the fact you have 0 reading comprehension of telling me that step siblings are actually half siblings (which no English speaking country has as a law) but I didn't realise English was at BEST your 3rd language behind Japanese and Portuguese.

Tip for the future don't try and correct native speakers if you don't want to appear stupid, 2 of us told you the difference between half siblings and step siblings and you told us we were wrong.

 

[shinshom]

No I live in a house, with the internet and a quick google search of the definition of half sibling and the definition of step sibling shows that you are wrong, not that I need to because unlike you I speak English as a 1st language, that is why I know the difference

Funny enough google here is saying that calling them stepsiblings is acceptable, even tho I was not calling this,m i was saying half-siblins lol (even say that you could specify if it is by blood or not if necessary).

but welp the whole world doesnt include just your own reality, and I still believe most countries goes with this logic that you usually call step-siblins kinds on this situation.

Even more funny, this is a japanese story, and they simplify even more the terms. It's the most common thing seeing in-laws claling their spouses parents "mother" or "father" making the incest tag even more real LOL.

 

[MrTurtleMan]

Funny enough google here is saying that calling them stepsiblings is acceptable, even tho I was not calling this,m i was saying half-siblins lol (even say that you could specify if it is by blood or not if necessary).

but welp the whole world doesnt include just your own reality, and I still believe most countries goes with this logic that you usually call step-siblins kinds on this situation.

Even more funny, this is a japanese story, and they simplify even more the terms. It's the most common thing seeing in-laws claling their spouses parents "mother" or "father" making the incest tag even more real LOL.

It's not my reality it's the English language, full siblings means you share both parents, half siblings means you share 1 parent, step siblings means no blood relationship, you are siblings because your parents are married, foster siblings means 1 or both of you were adopted (no blood relationship).

Why is it so hard for you to just admit you were wrong and stop clinging to them being half siblings? Maybe that's the term in Japan but we aren't speaking Japanese.

 

[shinshom]

LMAO I just guessed you were speaking English not as a 1st language based on the fact you have 0 reading comprehension of telling me that step siblings are actually half siblings (which no English speaking country has as a law) but I didn't realise English was at BEST your 3rd language behind Japanese and Portuguese.

Tip for the future don't try and correct native speakers if you don't want to appear stupid, 2 of us told you the difference between half siblings and step siblings and you told us we were wrong.

ahhh right, I didnt know there was a difference because both in japanese and portuguese those doesnt have a difference. I was talking half-siblins as if it was a generic term for both.

Eitherway still the whole topic is you guys working so hard to say that step-sibling is not a incest no? Still sounds silly and stupid even if u put this way because even if it is rly not, because thats how most ppl ends up seeing anyway.

only you guys care THIS much about this lable to begin with.

 

[shinshom]

It's not my reality it's the English language, full siblings means you share both parents, half siblings means you share 1 parent, step siblings means no blood relationship, you are siblings because your parents are married, foster siblings means 1 or both of you were adopted (no blood relationship).

Why is it so hard for you to just admit you were wrong and stop clinging to them being half siblings? Maybe that's the term in Japan but we aren't speaking Japanese.

yeah u r right, but it is still a japanese story .....

wait are you telling me that in your country, english speaker w/e, if a couple gets together, both have kids, if the kids start dating, would not cause any kind of controversy or weirdness towards the neighbors? idk about that.... I don't have much reference from outside of my social bubbles... but even if american movies/series are 10% real, at the very least shows it wouldnt be AS simple of an issue...

for godamn sure it wouldnt on what I know as a reality as well

 

[MrTurtleMan]

ahhh right, I didnt know there was a difference because both in japanese and portuguese those doesnt have a difference. I was talking half-siblins as if it was a generic term for both.

Eitherway still the whole topic is you guys working so hard to say that step-sibling is not a incest no? Still sounds silly and stupid even if u put this way because even if it is rly not, because thats how most ppl ends up seeing anyway.

only you guys care THIS much about this lable to begin with.

You were arguing with us as much as we were arguing with you so you need to include yourself in that

 

[MrTurtleMan]

yeah u r right, but it is still a japanese story .....

wait are you telling me that in your country, english speaker w/e, if a couple gets together, both have siblins, if the kids start dating, would not cause any kind of controversy or weirdness towards the neighbors? idk about that.... I don't have much reference from outside of my social bubbles... but even if american movies/series are 10% real, at the very least shows it wouldnt be AS simple of an issue...

for godamn sure it wouldnt on what I know as a reality as well

Depends if they grew up together or not, if 2 17 year olds that JUST met as step siblings started dating I don't think anyone I know would care, if they met as kids then it would be a little weird as they grew up as siblings

 

[shinshom]

You were arguing with us as much as we were arguing with you so you need to include yourself in that

My point still stands. Doesn't matter if Step-siblins is the right term, it is still silly this whole argument of "its not incest because yada yada". Like... in the end nothing changed lol...

 

[MrTurtleMan]

My point still stands. Doesn't matter if Step-siblins is the right term, it is still silly this whole argument of "its not incest because yada yada". Like... in the end nothing changed lol...

Incest in English has a pretty strict definition, uncle/aunt/grandparent or closer is considered incest, cousins is looked down upon (at least over here) but it isn't incest, step and foster siblings aren't blood related so it definitely isn't incest

 

[shinshom]

Depends if they grew up together or not, if 2 17 year olds that JUST met as step siblings started dating I don't think anyone I know would care, if they met as kids then it would be a little weird as they grew up as siblings

No one would care with context, but 80% of ppl around your social bubble doesnt have them, so usually ppl would see as incest as a first impression.... RIGHT?

thats the whole fucking point omg.... happy you got your semantics right?... Sorry if english is just my 3rd language and not enough to convey what I was saying, even tho the literal difference of half-siblings / step-siblings had literally no weight at all on the definition... but if I am trying to struggle in my third language, maybe u should try a little to do yourself in your mother language.

 

[shinshom]

Incest in English has a pretty strict definition, uncle/aunt/grandparent or closer is considered incest, cousins is looked down upon (at least over here) but it isn't incest, step and foster siblings aren't blood related so it definitely isn't incest

again, with extreme context, no?

as you said in another post, its a grey area, because if you see specifically they just met, specifically all those specific things, sure, its not incest.

but in a broad sense would be seen just fine.... I think here on mangadex is not labled as incest, but pretty sure anywhere else is because thats how it is seen....

do I agree? not rly, but its just how things are.

 

[Jambaj0e]

Noooo y'all split the two page spread :<. Could you put pages 13 and 14 together as one picture? Any way thanks for the scanlation too! Gimai seikatsu is such a great story

View attachment 12249
You have robbed us of this magnificent picture...

Legit, I think that anime did this moment better. Instead of Asamura stopping Ayase and her bringing him into her room. She goes into her room with out him. and He slowly knocks on the door. and a little bit later she knocks back.

IT IS LITERALLY THE CUTES THING EVER OMG I CANT. AAAHHHh

I totally agree, the anime brought this scene to a higher level. So enjoyable and emotionally breathtaking in the anime.

 

[ududjeisie]

in almost every country in the world, siblings formed though marriage are legally called half-siblings.... what are you even talking about? Do you live in a cave?

Are you retarded? Half siblings are siblings who are related to each other by only one of their parents. Two people becoming siblings after their parents marry would be step siblings.