Gokusotsu Kraken - Vol. 3 Ch. 19.5 - Volume 3 Extras

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 23, 2024
Messages
62
weird convictions (abandonment of a corpse? like wat?), but nice background info nonetheless.
These are probably based off Japanese laws. There's no "right to self defense" over there. She probably got attacked, fought back, killed the attacker, and ran away, thus making her a guilty murderer in their eyes. It made me think, because another series pointed out the difference between Japanese and American doctors (American doctors have a right to choose their patients, Japanese doctors MUST treat a patient no matter who they are or what they did).
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 21, 2018
Messages
2,201
These are probably based off Japanese laws. There's no "right to self defense" over there. She probably got attacked, fought back, killed the attacker, and ran away, thus making her a guilty murderer in their eyes. It made me think, because another series pointed out the difference between Japanese and American doctors (American doctors have a right to choose their patients, Japanese doctors MUST treat a patient no matter who they are or what they did).
pretty sure doctors in almost every country in the have to treat people if they are in need of help - even if it's not something critical. this capitalist approach to medicine is unique to murica in my experience.

and the right to self defense didn't explain the "abandonment of a corpse." sure, they could've charged her with manslaughter or even murder, but why explicitly mention that she had to keep vigil around a corpse?! seems more like some religious thing in japan that found its way into the manga.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 31, 2018
Messages
4,340
Ok, now it is explained why Panya became a guard despite being a pushover... she is strong, but her cowardice overpowers that.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 31, 2018
Messages
4,340
and the right to self defense didn't explain the "abandonment of a corpse." sure, they could've charged her with manslaughter or even murder, but why explicitly mention that she had to keep vigil around a corpse?! seems more like some religious thing in japan that found its way into the manga.
You are probably right about it being some sort of religious reasoning.

Just an example that may explain it... the death sentence in Japan is carried by hanging, and there is a WHOLE process to do it, too long for me to say every single detail so I will focus on what is relevant... the hanging is done by a contraption that is activated by a button, the button is in a separate room that has no window to the place of hanging, but... there are three buttons in that room, so three guards enter the room, they don't know which button is the real one, so they unlock the buttons each with a key, and press it at the same time.

Why is it done like that? Because in Xintoism, the religion Japan is most adherent to, murder is a capital sin, so even if the guards are only doing their duty as government employees, they still are committing murder in the eyes of their religion.

But there is a "clause" that saves it, is that as long as they don't "know" they are the killer, they are in the safe... yeah, don't want to hate others' religion but it is a stupid reasoning.

Anyway, thing is Japan has a peculiar relation with death, that is very much present in their laws.

One more thing, as I write this comment I remembered one thing... abandonment of a corpse being an infraction may have something to do with how corpses can be hotbeds for diseases, so abandoning a corpse may be considered a form of hazard dumping, this comes to my mind as I remember a lot of little details I know about Japanese culture and how century-old customs still affect their modern laws, I can be really wrong, but I do think there is at least a thread of truth in that.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top