Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 24, 2018
- Messages
- 4,482
But that's the thing. I'm not arguing for ingenuity to replace magic but to incorporate it. Channeling magical energy of a user into some form of converter to do mechanical work seems to be a mechanism of common-enough knowledge in the manga's world. Yet, those are nowhere to be seen. Not as drivers for millstones, not as reciprocators for sawmills (or hell, hand saws!), not as vibrators in love toys …
Supply is the issue. Why use highly limited resource for mundane task when you can use it for more useful things that do need it. Not to mention with how expensive mythril is supposed to be average household won't be able to just afford them.
On the other hand, gold is seen in the real world as such a big deal behind financial power that it is of state interest, yet it's in a vast majority of cheaply available consumer products, so, that doesn't really hold up, either.
And mythril being well-known, if rare, even before K's arrival implies mechanisms are in place for unearthing it. Which in turn means it's available to the laws of economics of scale. If people can make profit, it's inevitable to have a supply of even the most precious, rare, and difficult-to-extract materials made available, one way or another.
So, with the availability as a limiting factor pretty much ruled out, it's like mankind knowing about electricity yet foregoing (post-steam) technological advancement because they couldn't be arsed to develop and make electric motors. It just doesn't add up.
Ah yes, clearly gold have ALWAYS been easy to find that there was NEVER a period in history where people spend so much resources trying to find them, right?
You're assuming they know how to find Mythril just because they have some, when so far it seems more like they find them by chance/in ruins of past civilization (if they do have a method of finding mythril, why was Kosuke able to dig up some in that cliffside? Clearly if they would've dig those out before he arrive if they do have such option)
But you effectively never see any chores being done with magic. If it was really so ubiquitous, there'd be a lot more on display, and on casual display at that. Or rather, if artist and author thought about the implications and would want to convey that it be so ubiquitous, they'd see to displaying it.
Because using magic still have one shared aspect as doing it manually: fatigue.
So why waste extra energy to use magic if something simple can be done by hand. Save the mana for actual emergencies like fighting monsters.