Gourmet Gaming - Vol. 1 Ch. 1

Member
Joined
Aug 16, 2019
Messages
594
I'm surprised... all the leveing by eating or walking... such and such web novels i found years before all got manga or webtoon adaptations... are people just out of ideas now
 
Joined
Dec 20, 2018
Messages
83
Idk, doesn't look like a good start in my opinion.

He ate a 1000 year ginseng that could've boosted someone.

Imagine if there was a plant that would give everyone in the world magical powers and everybody knows it, then some random person comes up to it and eats the plant and replies with, "because it looked edible" or something similar to that.

I would be pissed.

Hm, I just got done watching a hell of a lot of moral videos though, so my mindset is probs a lot different from how it usually is. But, yeah...
 
Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2020
Messages
191
"who in there right mind would make chicken soup out of a 1000 year ginseng?"
"me"
"understandable, have a great day"
 
Joined
Nov 3, 2019
Messages
3
NOT 'bulimia' he has an eating disorder where he binge eats and doesn't purge. People with bulimia binges and then purges and are usually at a normal weight. And a psychiatrist would NEVER EVER call their patient with an eating disorder a 'PIG'. And this started out so promising.
 
Joined
Aug 5, 2020
Messages
139
To new readers:
The MC’s condition in this story’s original language is a made up disease with a made up name.

“Bulimia” is the word that many translators have chosen as a stand-in for this fictional disease.

I know this was translated a long while ago, but I’m still gonna throw this out here:

I understand the translators choice here and thinking that it isn’t a big deal, or even that it is actually very appropriate. No doubt many people who lodged complaints to you about the use of “bulimia” presented their arguments with misconceptions (those bullet points make that very clear lol).

However, I must make clear that the justifications presented at the end of this chapter showed some misunderstandings on your part of the condition bulimia nervosa.

(Caveat: I want to acknowledge the possibility that the comic-form of this story COULD be rushing through or muddling some important details of the MC’s condition, struggles, and treatment. The LN might go into more detail or present some things we’ve seen in a different light, making the choice to translate the MC’s fictional disease as “bulimia” seem more appropriate.)

1) Bulimia is characterized (in a super tl;dr fashion) by bingeing and purging. However, the MC does not experience binge episodes, nor does he even constantly binge. What the story has told us so far is that the MC “constantly eats”, and that he experiences anxiety when not eating. This may not seem like much difference, but the nuances are actually very telling.

2) The Purge. At the end of this chapter you claimed that the MC’s extreme exercising mirrored the exercise-response of bulimia sufferers. However, the story has not presented the MC’s exercise as a purge in response to his overeating nor as a compulsion brought on by his disease. On the contrary, the author has presented his intense exercise as a means of treatment. When the trainer told the MC that he’d done enough and it was fine to rest, the MC happily said he could go longer and his trainer was fine with it. The personal trainer is clearly aware of his condition and concerned for the MC; if the 4 hours of exercise we were presented with was a symptom of his condition and the MC was pushing himself too far, the trainer would have INSISTED that the MC stop. In fact, a big part of the trainer’s job would actually be preventing the MC from exercising too much or in unhealthy ways.

3) Most importantly, bulimia is a VERY REAL condition that affects many people; but from what was stated at the end of this chapter, it seems the disease inflicting our dear VR foodie is ENTIRELY FICTITIOUS (and according to the plot, very rare). It’s possible the author may have taken some inspiration from the symptoms and experiences of those who suffer from bulimia, but they are NOT writing about bulimia. The exact translation of the name of this fictitious disease may not carry over well into English, but inventing your own name for it would be far better than subbing in a real-world condition that your readers, or people they know, may actually suffer from.

I’m going to be very candid here. I am 28 years old and I experience both ADHD and OCD. Growing up and entering into adulthood I had been asked on numerous occasions if I experienced autism, ADHD, or OCD. However, until two years ago I always I always denied the possibility of ADHD, and it was only a few months ago that my concurrent OCD was identified.

Many times these questions were actually asked carefully and with great love by close friends who thought I may be unaware of my condition. Turns out they were right, (lol) however we always had very good discussions outlining what these conditions entailed and how my experiences differed. On the contrary, I knew my experiences and behavior were abnormal, and had done a lot of research into mental health conditions as possible explanations. The problem was, while I could talk about these conditions in a TEXTBOOK manner, I failed to understand the nuances of ADHD and OCD symptoms and how my experiences matched with others.

—-

Uhm so, ironically I actually really did get lost in this. Explaining my history was supposed to tie into point 3 somehow about bulimia being a real condition vs the MC’s condition being something the author invented. But I don’t remember how or where I was going. I think it had to do with how mental health conditions being presented wrongly / in oversimplified manners influenced my understanding of the conditions and how to handle having/then.

This isn’t supposed to be a joke about adhd I swear, I’m just really really tired. 😰
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 19, 2020
Messages
1,669
@NonstopSong real disease but it is way different from what it means in this manga. Yeah bulimia definition means

an emotional disorder involving distortion of body image and an obsessive desire to lose weight, in which bouts of extreme overeating are followed by depression and self-induced vomiting, purging, or fasting.

an eating disorder in which a large quantity of food is consumed in a short period of time, often followed by feelings of guilt or shame.

There pretty much the same but different at the same time so yeah
 
Joined
Aug 5, 2020
Messages
139
@BusinessGL Yes? If I remember right, that’s basically what I said?

Well, except that your conclusion seems to be “it’s fine because they are the same, but different”, while my conclusion is “they may have similarities, but they are actually very different, so it’s not okay.”

Also, “this manga” doesn’t call the MC’s condition “bulimia”. The MC’s condition is a fiction created by the author, with it’s own fictional name. The translators chose “bulimia” as a stand-in name for the author’s fictional disease, because the literal translation was awkward.

Like, putting aside whether we think there’s something fundamentally wrong with it, what if the author were to introduce a character in the series who has ACTUAL bulimia? Like, meeting someone who experiences a similar but different eating disorder? Then what?? o-o;;;
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 22, 2019
Messages
1,702
it's a finder's keeper's world.
if you don't like it be faster, better or luckier...
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top