Half Succubus wo Hirotta

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Messages
2,276
Real question is what monsters rating this as appalling when the series is so sweet it’s given me diabetes

I mean, it features a literal child with humongous tits, and the overbearing implication of incest, with a toddler.
What fucking reason are you missing here?

That being said, shit is cute, but with some caveats.
Definitely not for new readers lol.
 
Group Leader
Joined
Dec 29, 2023
Messages
331
please no porn in this manga , im beggign yoy. PLEASE KEEP THIS WHOLESOME PLEASE
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 21, 2023
Messages
860
I mean, it features a literal child with humongous tits, and the overbearing implication of incest, with a toddler.
What fucking reason are you missing here?

That being said, shit is cute, but with some caveats.
Definitely not for new readers lol.
and the series makes it obvious from the beginning that it's not going any sort of adult route with her. it's been adorable from the beginning so i guess all those monsters who rated it as a 1 didnt go further then the cover.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Messages
2,276
and the series makes it obvious from the beginning that it's not going any sort of adult route with her. it's been adorable from the beginning so i guess all those monsters who rated it as a 1 didnt go further then the cover.
I can agree with that, but you don't need the incest to be explicit. The mere implication of it is enough to deter readers..
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 21, 2023
Messages
860
I can agree with that, but you don't need the incest to be explicit. The mere implication of it is enough to deter readers..
Err there’s no blood relation between the guy and the Oppai rori so not sure why you keep bringing up incest
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Messages
2,276
Err there’s no blood relation between the guy and the Oppai rori so not sure why you keep bringing up incest
Well, the 1st chapter says: "...She's the product of the time spent between myself and a human.", which implies the guy is her dad, but then at another chapter the guy does go: "..She thinks I'm her parent.."
So, yeah, probs not bio-dad.
TBH, the incest shit isn't really the problem with having a horny 3-5 years old on a grown man's lap. It's just the easiest way to point out why this comic can so easily rub people the wrong way.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 17, 2018
Messages
136
For anyone wondering "Why does it have to porn tag" The small child with humongous tits goes naked alot. I know you(we) degenerates might forget sometimes, but pictures of naked people are, in fact, porn. It's what we in the biz call softcore porn.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 4, 2018
Messages
490
For anyone wondering "Why does it have to porn tag" The small child with humongous tits goes naked alot. I know you(we) degenerates might forget sometimes, but pictures of naked people are, in fact, porn. It's what we in the biz call softcore porn.
I thought the distinction—on mangadex—was that porn showed explicit sex i.e. penetration, creampies, etc. while erotica is either heavily implied or just cropped porn. There's not even a visible nipple. With that tag I was honestly expecting a page of him having raucous sex with the milf, but I haven't looked at the raws either. Either way, the tag removes it from casual searching so to the somehow normal people who find this site they don't have an aneurysm from seeing the oppai loli.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 22, 2018
Messages
231
For anyone wondering "Why does it have to porn tag" The small child with humongous tits goes naked alot. I know you(we) degenerates might forget sometimes, but pictures of naked people are, in fact, porn. It's what we in the biz call softcore porn.
That is one of the most ridiculous generalizations I've read in a long time. I want you to think of every manga you've ever read. Are you thinking of them? Good. Now, every manga that includes scenes of people changing clothes, showering, or bathing should be tagged as pornographic according to your comment. That's a staggeringly large amount, isn't it? Then of course you also have to think about babies being changed or bathed. The transitive property does not work in these situations (i.e. All porn has naked people, thus anything with naked people is porn). Next you're going to suggest that gore is all about blood, so anything with blood should be tagged as gore. All those poor romcoms where the MC gets a nosebleed seeing sexy situations are now gore. That's why MangaDex has defined in the Site Rules what should be in each category in the Title Metadata segment:

"2.2.2 The content rating for a series is based on the highest level of sexual content in the series. In general, entries that focus on sex or contain uncensored sex scenes should be marked as pornographic, entries with heavily censored or non-explicit sex as erotica, and entries with light exposure as suggestive."

Which means that unless something seriously changes in the future raws (which I haven't looked at), this should probably be suggestive or erotica at worst. Now, I'm sure there are some 'side' illustrations the author has done that probably depicts some rather explicit situations, but if they aren't part of the actual story, it's easy enough to just not include/separate them. Meh, whatever, if I lose easy access to what was a mostly cute manga it won't be the worst thing.

Side note: Doing a bit of investigating (noticing all the threads for much further ahead chaps down below), it seems that it might be the fact that the Spanish translation of this series has included a bunch of those 'side' Fanbox illustrations, so that's probably why it got the tag change.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 22, 2018
Messages
1,411
That is one of the most ridiculous generalizations I've read in a long time. I want you to think of every manga you've ever read. Are you thinking of them? Good. Now, every manga that includes scenes of people changing clothes, showering, or bathing should be tagged as pornographic according to your comment. That's a staggeringly large amount, isn't it? Then of course you also have to think about babies being changed or bathed. The transitive property does not work in these situations (i.e. All porn has naked people, thus anything with naked people is porn). Next you're going to suggest that gore is all about blood, so anything with blood should be tagged as gore. All those poor romcoms where the MC gets a nosebleed seeing sexy situations are now gore. That's why MangaDex has defined in the Site Rules what should be in each category in the Title Metadata segment:

"2.2.2 The content rating for a series is based on the highest level of sexual content in the series. In general, entries that focus on sex or contain uncensored sex scenes should be marked as pornographic, entries with heavily censored or non-explicit sex as erotica, and entries with light exposure as suggestive."

Which means that unless something seriously changes in the future raws (which I haven't looked at), this should probably be suggestive or erotica at worst. Now, I'm sure there are some 'side' illustrations the author has done that probably depicts some rather explicit situations, but if they aren't part of the actual story, it's easy enough to just not include/separate them. Meh, whatever, if I lose easy access to what was a mostly cute manga it won't be the worst thing.

Side note: Doing a bit of investigating (noticing all the threads for much further ahead chaps down below), it seems that it might be the fact that the Spanish translation of this series has included a bunch of those 'side' Fanbox illustrations, so that's probably why it got the tag change.
Ooohhh i see... No wonder the tag was changed from erotic to porn... Too bad no english translation...
 
Joined
Sep 25, 2023
Messages
4
The fan box issues should be put in there own manga on this site like with divorced crybaby. That should be the standard way of handling situations like this
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 5, 2019
Messages
28
That is one of the most ridiculous generalizations I've read in a long time. I want you to think of every manga you've ever read. Are you thinking of them? Good. Now, every manga that includes scenes of people changing clothes, showering, or bathing should be tagged as pornographic according to your comment. That's a staggeringly large amount, isn't it? Then of course you also have to think about babies being changed or bathed. The transitive property does not work in these situations (i.e. All porn has naked people, thus anything with naked people is porn). Next you're going to suggest that gore is all about blood, so anything with blood should be tagged as gore. All those poor romcoms where the MC gets a nosebleed seeing sexy situations are now gore. That's why MangaDex has defined in the Site Rules what should be in each category in the Title Metadata segment:

"2.2.2 The content rating for a series is based on the highest level of sexual content in the series. In general, entries that focus on sex or contain uncensored sex scenes should be marked as pornographic, entries with heavily censored or non-explicit sex as erotica, and entries with light exposure as suggestive."

Which means that unless something seriously changes in the future raws (which I haven't looked at), this should probably be suggestive or erotica at worst. Now, I'm sure there are some 'side' illustrations the author has done that probably depicts some rather explicit situations, but if they aren't part of the actual story, it's easy enough to just not include/separate them. Meh, whatever, if I lose easy access to what was a mostly cute manga it won't be the worst thing.

Side note: Doing a bit of investigating (noticing all the threads for much further ahead chaps down below), it seems that it might be the fact that the Spanish translation of this series has included a bunch of those 'side' Fanbox illustrations, so that's probably why it got the tag change.
The fan box issues should be put in there own manga on this site like with divorced crybaby. That should be the standard way of handling situations like this
This also happened with Kore kara Dandan Shiawase ni Natte Iku Kowai Onna Joushi, where the Indonesian translation included the 18+ contents. Resulting in the rating to go from "Suggestive" to "Pornography". I was able to get the rating back to "Suggestive" by creating an MD page for the 18+ version of the manga and requested the 18+ chapters to be moved to the 18+ page.

From looking at the Spanish and other translations that have been uploaded, it seems that the Spanish translation has 4 chapters focused on 18+ content, and 2 chapters that includes extra more suggestive content in the chapters that can be separated from the main chapter to become a "#.5" chapter. Following include spoilers for the mentioned 2 chapters.

The 2 chapters that include the suggestive extra contents are part of a beach arc. The extra contents of the chapters contain characters from Zurikishi's other series interacting with each other. These interactions have nothing to do with the main story. This includes the 2 suggestive contents (which only contain characters from Zurikishi's other series and none from this manga) that contain "uncensored breast fondling that is not in a sexual way". These contents could be separated from the main chapter if they do not impact the main story. However, I would say that it pushes the boundary of the "Suggestive" tag.

There are also a bunch of 18+ content from this manga that has not been translated by anyone yet. So having a dedicated 18+ MD page should be necessary to put those extra 18+ content so they don't impact the MD page of the main story, like with other MD page handles (e.g. Divorced Crybaby). I have started doing this by sending a request for a MD page for the 18+ version. Hopefully, it gets approved so the 18+ chapters can be moved to the 18+ page.

Update: The 18+ MD page has been approved (Half Succubus wo Hirotta【R18+】) and the four 18+ chapters have been moved to the 18+ MD page. With the 18+ content now located on the 18+ MD page, I have requested the change of the rating of this manga to "Suggestive".

Update 2: The rating changed from “Pornography” to “Erotica”. Even though it’s not “Suggestive”, with the non-pornographic extras that are coming out are more suggestive for the “Suggestive” rating, I say the ”Erotica” rating is a good middle ground.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Feb 18, 2023
Messages
35
I vote for "let them smash" so I'm happy to learn of the fanbox. I hope everything gets translated.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top