Hana to Hoshi

[MangaDex]

 

[VadimZap]

Pretty good. Ended a bit too soon I feel.

 

[cixous]

uwu

 

[PrunJuice]

Really enjoyed the bitterness of the first few chapters. But that was the highlight.

Spoiler

For some reason I'm annoyed they started playing table tennis again in the end. It's almost like the moral of the story becomes, "Table tennis is the best" instead of anything substantial.

Also, random NTR girl seems to come out of nowhere and stays until after the end. Not where she came from or what purpose she served.

 

[VoidR]

Spoiler

For some reason I'm annoyed they started playing table tennis again in the end. It's almost like the moral of the story becomes, "Table tennis is the best" instead of anything substantial

Spoiler

Completely disagree. It even mention in a chapter how she never could actually enjoy the sport due to frustration and everything that comes with going competitive, while now she has gotten over that frustration and is doing it for fun.

 

[Veldor]

Garbage. Dont bother.

 

[AnxietyAtTheParty]

Table tennis was the best part.

Spoiler

Somehow the white-haired girl (forgot her name) had more chemistry with her ex that with her supposed girlfriend.

 

[LittleSisterLover]

Man I've read some trash in my time but this one is some special garbage.

 

[Trevoga]

Then you haven't read much trash. This is just subpar. Nothing special.

 

[emMeBi86]

Spoiler

Well...seems like they wrapped up things a little too soon. No real romance outside confession, at school the two annoying characters are still in the way, and the date chapter is a wtf.
Could have endend slightly better.

 

[Venuume]

Man this was adorable but too short and jumps around a lot with the plot it wants, and those two annoying characters really make it hard to adore.

 

[MyersMan69]

this was pretty bad? I feel like there was alot missing and the author rushed to write the whole thing. I'm not totally sure why some things happened. Upto the scene where the senpai brought her out to play table tennis for the other girl I thought it was fine but then it was almost like the author knew their days were numbered and just rushed to finish it off by giving us a few random important event scenes with no real reasoning for why we were supposed to think that they should be dating/why hanai would like her? Idk mostly just surprised this has such a decent rating.

ps the cover art is way better than anything else in the manga by like 100 times lol

 

[Mr_E_Panda]

Sweet story. really heartfelt. It really comes together when she is able to sort out her feelings. Good story.

 

[KazuDygo]

End nya gantung anj

 

[Mask8850]

Beautiful but irritating stroy so prepare for Drama

 

[SapphicsUnite]

Imo the people calling this trash are the lurky hets that go around and leave bad reviews on anything yuri just bc it's yuri. Especially back in the day when this came out. To me this series was heartwarming and actually fucking hilarious. I loved it the only problem I have is that it was to short. I would love for many more volumes this is one of my favorite yuri of all time now. It's really really good. I do wish it was longer so we could see Hanai grow more and that her relationship with Hoshi be more loving and intimate like gfs.

 

[nasenbein]

I still reread this every few years. Pretty bummed that it seems to be the only work of the mangaka translated to English.

 

[NARESH4444]

It's not trash,it's not garbage,and none of the character are unlikeable.

What it is,though,is a free flowing work,as the artist mentioned,touching upon plot points that are left in a manner that a longer run would mean actually exploring them,at this point,a task for the fans to who can,double points if one can somehow get an AI to get that scratch look out.

Ended nicely enough,was not a waste,but is truly a damn shame to be the only work the artist has made that is on Mangadex,not the recent butchering makes it easier to get more of the works.

 

[banaba2]

i first read this in 2021 and it was so good and i found it again today and its better than ever 🥹