Ikoku Nikki - Vol. 5 Ch. 23 - page.23

Member
Joined
Mar 20, 2020
Messages
78
i wonder why asa doubts her mom's diary so much, it seems kind of out of character? i think what her mom wrote about her name is really beautiful so i'm just a bit confused.
 
Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2018
Messages
26
asa is still young and doesn't have enough life experience to process her current situation. i think her reaction was natural since she still a kid. maybe asa feels betrayed? her mom died before she could give asa the diary and there's that comment on death in her notebook...
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 15, 2018
Messages
1,541
Best case interpretation of Asa's name: I named you Asa in hopes that you can be loved by everyone and love your life in turn.
Worst case interpretation of Asa's name: I named you Asa in hopes that I could love you and bring my life to what I hoped it would be.

I'm honestly super confused about Asa's dad. I mean they were effectively in a legal marriage because that's how common law marriages work, right? He wouldn't have stayed otherwise if he hated them or something like that. Maybe he just has a trauma regarding marriage, but it's too early to tell.
 
Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2019
Messages
116
Thanks for the translations, this is a gem of a story!
I'm sure more about her dad will be revealed in later chapters but for now its a bit......odd?!?! So he was ok being a father (did Asa not say in some early chapter that her parents were average or something like that- I mean it gave me the impression that she wasn't close to either parent or maybe I'm just not remembering it right) but not a husband in the legal sense? Was he married, was this bigamy? Did he have another family or some trauma of his own? Or he did not like Asa's mother- or just someone who did not believe in the institution of marriage??? The plot thickens.....🧐
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 7, 2020
Messages
176
I didn't realize this in my initial read-through, but I am pretty sure pages 28-29 are supposed to be a 2-page spread. There's detail in the bottom half of page 29 that looks like it bleeds over from page 28. Setting the reader to "right-to-left," two pages and going to pages 28-29 definitely shows that is the case. @Kewl0210, when you can, please fix this.
Edit: It's been fixed. Many Thanks to you @Kewl0210 and your group. 😃
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 11, 2018
Messages
619
it's interesting to see in minori's memories, makio pointed back at her and yelled some things too. not that it makes it 'even,' we don't know the full story, but it's interesting to remember that makio herself said she could only see minori from her own limited perspective, and that's why she refrains from imposing it on asa. how much of how makio viewed her sister is warped? i'm so curious to see more of how minori viewed their relationship.

more and more this manga seems to be underlying the theme that everyone lives together, but in their own worlds. makio says writing is lonely, which is strange because it's meant to be communicating to someone. but that's how life is as well, no matter how we form relationships with others, the way we view those relationships is wrapped up in our own perspective. "we're two different people." it's both inane and profound. there are just some things we won't see the same, but we're drawn to each other, while still living alone.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 22, 2018
Messages
4,145
some chapters ago I did comment why Asa started to be a little more disrespectful for Makio realizing she was a normal person, I should have given a little more introspection to Minori, we saw only Makio's POV and ofc she's not gonna remember how she grabbed the bricks and throw then back to her ... hate is actually a thing really hard to have, she can just don't care about a person, that would be indifference, but hate it comes from inside, it's emotions hard enough to make you sure you have them, like poison escaping from your mouth, sadly it's contagious.
chapter just show what has been doing for all the other characters, raw reality, now it was the turn of the mom, she was a normal person, even if she was pretty much mostly shown as a witch, she has her own feelings, her own dreams and problems too, and now thanks to Makio (something she clearly didn't want to happen btw), Asa is doubting her mom feelings, and that's hurt like daaamn, it actually made me sad.
kudos author kudos :qq: :thumbsup:
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top