Isekai H Eiyuuden ~Bishoujo Senshi-tachi wa Saikyou Gunshi no Muchana Onegai ni Sakaraenai~ - Vol. 1 Ch. 2.1 - Tactical Sight [part 1]

[Trippersigs22]

You know this bout to be some SLOP

 

[DemonHide]

I didn't notice in the first chapter, but the murderer looks to be wielding a Beretta-profile semi-auto handgun in one panel, and the next the MC is staring down the barrel of a S&W X-Frame revolver (maybe a Performance Center 460XVR). So he's got the Ebay special sawback jungle knife that he decapitates people with, a semi-auto handgun we don't see him use, and a large hunting/long-range revolver that apparently recoils faster than the bullet leaving the muzzle. Folks, Truck-kun is the only thing that makes sense so far.

 

[Zreth]

The dude's a former mercenary.

So it's kinda plausible?

The army doesn't teach you how to decapitate people with one hand using a kitchen knife

 

[theOOFman]

The dude's a former mercenary.

So it's kinda plausible?

It is in no way plausible, however it's edgy Isekai slop so I'm just gonna move past it

 

[Tobesmgobes17]

Well that got fucking dark

 

[Bobdillan69]

no it isn't
we have these things called bones and a small knife isnt going to cut through them like paper even if the wielder is a glorious nippon mercenary deployed over 1000 times

Uhhhh, depends on how sharp the knife is tbh.

Like if you don't butchering a sharp knife slices through bone without much issue.

Sharpness was actually an issue in medieval warfare, you'd never want a properly sharp sword, cause if it cut too deep it'd get stuck in an enemy. that and since you're clashing there's also the issue of it chipping/bending.

But with modern metallurgy it isn't as much of an issue.

That cleanly tho? nah, maybe if two hands, although... between the bones. That would be a bit too surgical tho.

 

[Bobdillan69]

Real talk that knife she be broken cutting at the handle at that point.

No no, butchers knives don't break that easily, so I doubt a military knife would be fragile.

 

[madlad7]

Mangakas really be like "How do we shock the audience?" and then just kill someone in the most tryhard edgy way possible

 

[Vester]

Damn Bro...

 

[CalebPlowmann]

Welp, this turned really dark

 

[Lbofun]

just wait. we will come to learn that evil McKillkids was actually sent to this world to push MC to be a hero. How else would he have super decap powers

 

[parkourse]

holy shit

 

[IJustReadEverything]

Mangaka could've just told me MCs past. I didn't have to see this.

He did in chapter 1. But decided to show you anyways.

 

[Fuzaki]

Guy that got his neck sliced clean is a real one for trying to protect the kids and woman.

 

[wizard_mouse]

LOL, this is one of those situations where making it super dark and tragic, just kills the dramatic element, I was not thinking about how a kid lost his sister, I was thinking about HOW THE FUCK did a man cleanly cut off a head with a 7 inch knife

 

[Drsilence1]

The dude's a former mercenary.

So it's kinda plausible?

And he only have one gun one knife... where machine gun where big gun where rocket launcher where tank where bomb!!! If it was a terrorist attack and a suicide bomber went off, I would call it real. Shooting a moving child without even aiming? It would actually be easier to shoot a flying bird.

 

[timcal2136]

I see people complaining about the bullet trajectory but the thing I think make sense is that, first of all he is a kid and I imagine that for him in his "intelligence" thought : "I can't reach with a jump, so I'll stretch my neck" so he extended his chin and that's why his forehead was aligned with the bullet path.

I could be wrong but that's my take

Even so, it doesnt make sense that a bullet that grazes what shouldve been the top of his head would absolutely dome-piece his much shorter younger sister (who wasn’t even in line for the shot anyways)

 

[booterror]

no it isn't
we have these things called bones and a small knife isnt going to cut through them like paper even if the wielder is a glorious nippon mercenary deployed over 1000 times

That's it. I'm sick of all this "Masterwork Katana" bullshit that's going on in the d20 system right now. Small knifes deserve much better than that. Much, much better than that.

I should know what I'm talking about. I myself commissioned a genuine small knife in Japan for 2,000 Yen (that's about $13 USD) and have been practicing with it for almost 2 years now. I can even cut slabs of solid steel with my small knife.

Chinese knife making machines spend seconds working on a single small knife and fold it up to a million times to produce the finest blades known to mankind.

Small knives are thrice as sharp as katanas and thrice as hard for that matter too. Anything a katana can cut through, a small knife can cut through better. I'm pretty sure a small knife could easily bisect a knight wearing full plate with a simple vertical slash.

 

[hevensdragon]

The dude's a former mercenary.

So it's kinda plausible?

That is one of the dumbest posts I has seen in quite some time. Lets bring in real examples of decapitations. Executioners, even with axes designed specifically for cutting off heads, they failed often. And axes much longer shafts, and weight distributed at the head, these both are what give it the needed force to cut clean through a neck. But even things like hair, slight movement, or anything else getting in the way often lead to failure. A knife lacks the power of length, the weight of mass, and the direction given from weight distribution. It will hit resistance and you will not be able to keep it pointed straight, it will rotate causing you to slide the edge of the blade along the target, its a slashing weapon vs cleaving. The only way to decapitate is for you to cleave vs slash, and the only way to cleave is for enough weight to be distributed past the middle of what you are cutting. A knife can't ever do that do to length.