Isekai ni Teni Shitara Yama no Naka datta. Handou de Tsuyosa yori mo Kaitekisa o Erabimashita - Ch. 25.5

[GridLite]

Definitely not weird at all lmao
So big sis legit just has some kind of twisted sibling love for his lil bro, which is mc, because she's a fucking lunatic lol

 

[Vinnaka]

chose to have a magic doll clone thing of original Earth Jin

So basically, she chose power to create dildo.

 

[EchoGirl]

The blonde people are the sister's friends. The female friend created a fake puppet version of the MC.

at least with a "puppet" jin they wouldn't know about the "real" one existing and chasing after him (tho idk if he'd be recognizable if his face was changed to be younger and that pony tail lol), unless that stupid ball of light spirit snitches unless the other deities are powerful enough to restrict him from telling them or the spirit just approaching Jin/Jean after and never met up with the "sister/hero party" again lol, although the fact that his sister is here in the first place wouldnt' be surprised if they did 'cross paths'/have some kinda confrontation as a way for him to 'grow' unless he does get away with just never meeting her, or having to kill her or so if she gets corrupt or just leave the country XD

Although considering MC always acted as a 'pack mule/gopher', surprised the sis's friend even likes Jin at all unless they had some private one on one convos when the sister wasn't around or so to actually know who he was as a person as opposed to being 'convenient' and forcing errands on him too, if she didn't create some kinda 'idealized' ver of him based on her own thoughts

 

[lycantant]

???

 

[Seraphus]

The blonde people are the sister's friends. The female friend created a fake puppet version of the MC.

Okay, but where in Odin's name would we (the readers and weebs on this site, that is) have learned that?!
It's not even suggested in the first few chapters, and we've seen NADA since then.
I'm not upset, or anything, but.... honestly, if we're gonna be referring back to some hack-written LN every so often, that's a bit much...

Also,

If all you care about is the id, ego, superego, ood, personality, memories, identity, or whatever - and not about the continuity - then there are literally 2 jins in this world now (because this was described as a "puppet that can read memories", meaning it is all that matters to be a person - makes sense since otherwise her blessing would not fulfill what she asked for and the gods wouldn't be divine or gods). Identical in all aspects from the onset, and only diverging from what they acquired and experienced from thereon.
So arguably the one that is a slave to the heroine is the most "true" jin, since he presumably lacks all those divine blessings, life-changing experiences, and freedom, that our jin has. In conclusion, this manga follows a fake.

1. The Ood usually have a little ball-thingy in their hands, and don't have hair, and they definitely aren't in this universe... but I'll let it slide because I really like Doctor Who.

2. All of that makes sense, and tha k you for pointing it out, but... WOW, that is so fucking gross.
These people are seriously icky.
We sould sick Note (the Butler) on them, and just be done with them; he seems like the type of badass butler to jist... buttle them off somewhere else.

 

[feha]

1. The Ood usually have a little ball-thingy in their hands, and don't have hair, and they definitely aren't in this universe... but I'll let it slide because I really like Doctor Who.

I am so happy someone caught that reference

2. All of that makes sense, and tha k you for pointing it out, but... WOW, that is so fucking gross.
These people are seriously icky.
We sould sick Note (the Butler) on them, and just be done with them; he seems like the type of badass butler to jist... buttle them off somewhere else.

Sadly I can't reciprocate, as I don't actually get that reference

 

[Seraphus]

I am so happy someone caught that reference

Sadly I can't reciprocate, as I don't actually get that reference

Couple chapters back, Note asked if he should "relocate" the neighbors, and it seemed a little... dark.

As for the rest, well...
His sister seems terrible, and Note... ummm... well...
A "settler" settles things (an area of land usually); a "thatcher" thatches things, and a "buyer" buys things, sooo... since he's a "Butler," that should mean that he buttles things, right?

 

[morichiro]

Who?

 

[Goldenzeal]

That is not very cash money of them...

 

[ShinduPK4]

My face this whole chapter:

 

[Kendrakirai]

Ooo this is an interesting brainer. It is something to think about whether a person isekaid is still the same from when they were still in their original world.

In my thoughts a memory card who has all the fundamental aspects of the original from Japan is still technically a copy isn't it? He's still not exactly Jin as this puppet just happens to have the ingredients to be similar to Jin, but you could say, in terms of inheriting a real being's ego that the puppet can very much still able to exist as a "true individual".

For the last speculation, saying that the one we're following is a fake kind of discredits human's nature to experience: "Despite everything its still you" y'know. But! If we do want something more concrete, if we want to guess "How" jin was transported, honestly I'd bet on spontaneous teleportation since his bags, food and stuff remained intact with him when woke up in the mountains.

Another thing that can assure us that our Jin isn't a fake is that based on ch2, we recall the God's offered our Jin power "in proportional to the lifespan he had left on Earth". This directly coins the narrative the fact that his current prowess were all extracted from "earth Jin's" lifespan, making him indeed the actual Jin.

Pretty sure this Jin is 100% a fake who's just exactly what the psycho friend THINKS he's like.

 

[Lelouchezero]

Whoa... just.. whoa this went from 0 to 100 really fast. Jin my man if you ever see ANY of these people RUN LIKE HELL!

 

[Nixeu]

Okay, but where in Odin's name would we (the readers and weebs on this site, that is) have learned that?!
It's not even suggested in the first few chapters, and we've seen NADA since then.
I'm not upset, or anything, but.... honestly, if we're gonna be referring back to some hack-written LN every so often, that's a bit much...

It's made somewhat more clear by the flashback to Japan near the end, which shows the blonde sister as she was, getting told by Jin's sibling (Haruka) not to confess her feelings to Jin. It's also made made much clearer in subsequent chapters that this is just a formed by blonde-sister's memories of Jin, with maybe those of the other two thrown in for good measure. It's not the original Jin, probably not even close.

Also, yikes. I'm rereading this specifically for more info on this exact situation, and I had completely forgotten this scene. Or maybe I deliberately blocked it out. I'm not sure if these three were this crazy to begin with, or if the prospect of being blessed by the gods made them even more self-centered than they were, or both. Either way, Jean was smart to pick up some powers specifically to prevent them from finding out he's also been summoned, and I hope he stays far, far away from them.

 

[CountryMage]

Basically, that they both were jin at the point of divergence, and subsequently diverged to each be different jins (the same man and river, and all that). So they are entirely separate people, but they are also both the same jin from japan.

They weren't both Jin though, the MC was Jin up until the moment of the summoning, and he was still Jin for about a month as he slowly starved to death on a mountain, before he was reborn as Jean; whereas the puppet is a piece of the lighball god that was molded into a new Jin, when that girl wished to have a Jin at her side, he's born of pieces of four non Jin existences. So, while they both may have been born when a Jin died, they did not share a divergence point.