Isekai Tensei Reijou, Shuppon Suru - Ch. 8

[JACGohu]

I mean, if you think about it with the purest of technicalities, the daughter IS quite dead. Her body is being puppeted by this reincarnator, who took over piloting just as the original was about to die. Sure, the reincarnator has access to the original's memories, but it still doesn't change the fact that the original girl is gone.

Circumstances of her reincarnation suggest otherwise. Her memories were programmed to unlock and return when she turned 6. She really is the owner of her new body since she was actually born into it, and didn't just jump into it at the moment of its death.

 

[mimuro]

I really don't want the father to get any kinds of atonement or redemption, his complete ignorance makes him 100% responsible for Aria's suffering

 

[DirtEater21]

Thank you for the translation

 

[Namelessmoreless]

Nahh the father being stupid is the same being evil for MC. Foolish evil

 

[Miserys_End]

The difference is that I do not have an entire lifetime's worth of knowledge and experiences from an entirely different lifetime to radically change who I am and what decisions I make.

Everything I am right now is the same as I was yesterday, just with a few more memories added. Everything else is the same. Can the same really be said about the current Aria?

Yes, because those memories were her's from birth. Just because they unlocked when she turned ten doesn't change that they belong to her.

Now if she just inhabited a meatsuit a god resurrected it for her to pilot that would be completely different.

But as this has always been her body, added memories doesn't change that.

 

[Bloddrake]

It looks like people already forgot that She was Aria all along, she wasn't reincarnated into an already existing girl she would just regain her memories at the age of 10. And why doesn't she defeat enemies with her storage skill, or did the author forgot he specified that she can store living creatures.

 

[Aran214]

this is kinda good, wtf

 

[14Darius28]

"No no guys, you don't understand. My only mistake was that I loved my Wife too much! "

What a load of rubbish, just hang this guy already!

I kept running off on my wife to this one person specifically. Love my wife and daughter so much guys. You don't even know guys I'm so foreal.

Like the only way this makes sense is if he's a repentant murderer. Like he'd have to have had to kill children for this type of personality to work.

 

[OWMWO]

Honestly, fuck you daddy.

 

[zeronatsume]

still hope they don't find her, even if just until she gained her own place in the world that can protect her

 

[DeadToReal]

Yes, because those memories were her's from birth. Just because they unlocked when she turned ten doesn't change that they belong to her.

Now if she just inhabited a meatsuit a god resurrected it for her to pilot that would be completely different.

But as this has always been her body, added memories doesn't change that.

But they are not her memories from when Aria was born.

They are an entirely separate lifetime's worth of memories, experiences, and identity that is completely different from Aria when she was born up to the age of 10.

From birth, until the age of 10, Aria was an entirely separate person.

Anyways, we are just going around in circles now.

 

[outinthegardener]

still hope they don't find her, even if just until she gained her own place in the world that can protect her

Or they find her, and she's living in her Mother's villa on the Beach surrounded by friends and running a successful "Solve anything" business. She's a integrated and vital part of her community. Then the prince or whoever says "I'm here to take you back and restore the Erandal family with you at it's head" and she says "nah, I'm good. Here, try this drink with a little umbrella in it."

So far this manga has followed the tropes pretty closely, so it's been predictable. A twist like that would be really fun.

 

[DeadToReal]

Or they find her, and she's living in her Mother's villa on the Beach surrounded by friends and running a successful "Solve anything" business. She's a integrated and vital part of her community. Then the prince or whoever says "I'm here to take you back and restore the Erandal family with you at it's head" and she says "nah, I'm good. Here, try this drink with a little umbrella in it."

So far this manga has followed the tropes pretty closely, so it's been predictable. A twist like that would be really fun.

I'm guessing no one knows who she is, because they have never seen her before. Only the butler and that head maid know what Aria actually looks like, and they are probably headed straight for the guillotine real soon.

My guess is they see a beautiful teenage Aria and won't leave her alone. All the while Aria has to hide her house that is a dead giveaway of who she really is.

 

[Tiny_Miney]

All this support and caring for Aria feels extremely hollow as apparently none of these people, including the father, have even seen or checked on her in what appears to be at least a couple years.

 

[caliche9700]

Thanks for the TL. I dont like how in these last two chapter the author like wanted us to feel some simpathy for Aras adad and her step sister. No, fuck that, there were horrible people to her and there is no excuse for how they abused her,

 

[Miserys_End]

But they are not her memories from when Aria was born.

They are an entirely separate lifetime's worth of memories, experiences, and identity that is completely different from Aria when she was born up to the age of 10.

From birth, until the age of 10, Aria was an entirely separate person.

Anyways, we are just going around in circles now.

O . o;
Are we even reading the same manga? She was reincarnated thrue natural child birth with her otherworldly memories lock till the age of ten. She was born with them.

God didn't insert her into a fresh corpse for her to take over, he just did her a solid to avoid the awkwardness of being a mature mind in a newborn body. God even informed her of this before being conceived on this world.

So no, I fully reject your assertation that the additional otherworldly memories effectively killed the old Aria. They were always part of her, and always intended to be released when she reached age ten.

You are free to keep your opinion, even if objectively wrong. But that doesn't change the facts that are presented in the story thus far.

 

[DeadToReal]

O . o;
Are we even reading the same manga? She was reincarnated thrue natural child birth with her otherworldly memories lock till the age of ten. She was born with them.

God didn't insert her into a fresh corpse for her to take over, he just did her a solid to avoid the awkwardness of being a mature mind in a newborn body. God even informed her of this before being conceived on this world.

So no, I fully reject your assertation that the additional otherworldly memories effectively killed the old Aria. They were always part of her, and always intended to be released when she reached age ten.

You are free to keep your opinion, even if objectively wrong. But that doesn't change the facts that are presented in the story thus far.

It doesn't matter if Aria's past life memories were locked if she didn't know about them in the first place. Since Aria grew up independently without those memories, this means Aria was a completely different person when she was born up to when she got her memories from her first life. Having Aria develop her own unique and independent identity is the whole reason why that god held back giving her memories and powers in the first place.

Aria Erandal before 10 years old was just Aria Erandal. Aria Erandal at 10 years old is the combination of Aria Erandal and Nagisa Kudou. Aria Erandal is a young girl, while Nagisa Kudou was a young woman. Two completely different people with two completely different experiences that merged into one person.

 

[TheCasualEnjoyer]

I was just waiting to see how yah'll would react to chp 8. When I stated the fathers reasoning to be really dumb. And to brace yourself.

 

[DeadToReal]

I was just waiting to see how yah'll would react to chp 8. When I stated the fathers reasoning to be really dumb. And to brace yourself.

The irony is that everyone knew the father was retarded and thought he got what he deserved.

The real controversy is Rosa turning on her mother and whether fresh water (Aria before 10th birthday) mixed with salt (past life memories and experiences) is still the same water. I would say it would now be salt water, but I am apparently, objectively wrong.

 

[gabbo89]

tyv m for ur work!