Itte Hoshikatta dake no Onee-san - Ch. 4

[cor3zone]

@Tersione
That's the thing, though. Since you can't know other people's intentions in real life, you judge them by their actions. By her actions, she's a total bitch and deserves this.

 

[So-chan]

@Xcaliblaster nice. Hopefully they will grow farther apart and her communication disorder will get even worse. This manga needs a `tragedy` tag.

 

[Tersione]

@cor3zone Well, no shit she wouldn't look as sympathetic if we weren't privy to her inner thoughts, but that's exactly the benefit of being a reader. But even without the internal dialogue, from rereading the chapters, I seriously can't see any instance of her acting like a "total bitch". The worst she did was make a vague statement that can be easily misinterpreted.

Seriously, you guys make it sound like she's one of the more verbally or physically abusive tsundere characters who've been around.

 

[KafukaPalazzo]

@Tersione: Agreeing with you. People go from 0 to 100 way too fast here. I mean, situation where your words goes far beyond your thoughts exist, and you won't make me believe that all the people in the comments here never hard a moment like that in their life.

There is a godamn difference between doing a mistake and don't give a fuck about it, and doing a mistake and realising it (and worst, have the guilt detroying you little by little). Now we just need to see if she's going to try to get redemption or not. (and to the "yeah but she's already fucked up 3 times and continue", yeah, because it's not simple to realise or to decide to act. Now she finally seems to be conscious of the situation. I mean, this is just freaking chapter 4, so, wait and see.)

 

[FireCamp]

Oof on that one

 

[ninjazz]

well he's shown his interest and even put up with her misunderstanding. if she wants it fixed, she should go see him herself.

then again this doesn't seem to be that kind of manga.

 

[cor3zone]

@Tersione
Regardless of what people think, only their actions matter in the slightest. "The road to hell is paved with good intentions." She could be the kindest person in the world, in her thoughts. Doesn't change the fact that the thoughts she acts on, are the bitchy ones.

Ch 1: She straight up tells him he's a liar, and that she can't trust him.
Ch 2: She insinuates that he's trying to get her drunk, to get in her pants. Basically rape.
Ch 3: She walks away, telling him to not even come near her. No explanation.
Ch 4: She does exactly nothing to get in touch with him, or clear up the misunderstanding.

I understand that people have issues, and have trouble communicating. Hell, I'm one of them. I can hardly have a conversation in person. But I don't expect people to understand or forgive me when I act like an asshole, just because I meant no harm. When I act like a dick, I am being a dick. I expect people to judge me fairly, even if it's negative.

 

[liquidsword]

@HauntedPizza Some people here act like they’re perfect human beings that have never made a mistake in their life. Yeah, it was her fault, but saying it’s “satisfying” or that she deserves it is just weird and trying way too hard to be “edgy.”

 

[thekidsareminnowkaren]

well
this is cute

 

[ArisenDresden]

man, these comments do not raise my opinion of the average manga commenter at all. democracy was a mistake

 

[HauntedPizza]

@liquidsword Exactly, you hit the nail on the head.

 

[OmniscientOnion]

@ArisenDresden As soon as I see a user mention and a wall of text, I just nope out of the comment section.

 

[ArisenDresden]

@OmniscientOnion that's good advice. i'm gonna take it

 

[alltsunnodere]

A lot of these comments against her, seem very harsh. Her mean moments haven't been due to really being mean, just from her not knowing how to respond. Seems like she has accepted her mistakes, just doesn't know how to fix it

 

[cor3zone]

@alltsunnodere
She treated him like air, and is being ignored as a result. She is already suffering, because of being ignored. I merely mean she deserves what she is already getting.

Also find it interesting how I'm apparently treating her too harshly, but a lot of people think it's fine to bitch at me. Double standards?

 

[alltsunnodere]

@cor3zone I can understand what you are coming from by “deserving it” by actions alone. I saw comments from people saying they were happy she is in this situation, which I disagree with

 

[cor3zone]

@alltsunnodere
I'm not happy about her suffering, but 'happy' and 'right' rarely go hand-in-hand. Thanks for being reasonable.😊

 

[Dabaha]

my fucking heart m8

 

[Tamerlane]

Relatable

 

[leusee]

Why's there such emphasis on the smoking is this gonna end with her quitting lol