Kimi Dake ga Hontou

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 19, 2020
Messages
937
I think the PLOT DEVELOPMENT was intended to happen since chapter one.
Chapter 1 page 23 lays foundation and pavement to what's to happen, so I don't think the author was acting out of spite because their series got axed or something. Whether this redeems the story for you, or it means the story was trash since its inception, that's up to you.
 
Joined
Nov 29, 2024
Messages
5
Binged this tonight and can't stop laughing at the complete implosion of an ending.
Started this thinking it was going to be a dramatic romance about the guy getting seduced away from his girl by her femboy twin. Then it started looking like the boy was some Yandere plotting to gaslight him into cheating. Then it looked like the sister was also Yandere and the two were going to compete by pretending to be the other and constantly gas light the MC in some sort of weird battle for supremecy. Then they completely dropped the Yan side of the boy which was hugely disappointing and went all in on the insanity and drama from the sister in a hyper grim dark ending. Then they 180'd again and went fully happy ending.

Some people I see on this thread are talking about the series getting axed leading to it rapidly shifting. No i think the author was just making this shit up as they went along since every couple chapters is a massive shift in tone.
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Jul 15, 2023
Messages
271
It was...Bad. The pacing, the characters and everything felt like author tried to bend this story to extreme.

First things first, you can't bend character sexual orientation that easily just because their faces are similar. Depending on your orientation there are specific features that you are attracted to. For example i like roundness and softness and overly fit women are a turn off, feels like touching my butt. Some character points that are more pronounced in males, if seen in a woman is a turn off. There are various degrees to that like 0 and 1. It's usually you either like softness or hardness(right or left and etc), women like fit men with pronounced muscles and hard to the touch and are likely irked off from touching something soft and round.

Next point, MC is in fact POS, dunno about the twins since their game wasn't fleshed out. But MC is indeed a POS. FMC was right to call him out on BS by playing with them both. While her actions are not good (nor her brothers), MC was trashy. If the world would be so easy that you could change your sexual preference i think we would be in a very nice place something near the heaven(or hell since more rivals means more conflict). We don't and his answer to give an answer after 1 week was utterly bad. But author somehow bended his orientation and his actions seemed just.
Normally he would clear up everything with her before giving the brother even a chance to do something. What he did? He broke off with girl while still giving the signals (basically pausing) and then starting off with the brother.

Third point, not enough chapters, we know that MC is POS but we can't judge the twins much or their reasons. For example was FMC really in love with MC or was that just brothers plans to break them apart? Was the brother a POS too? Because evidence suggests that he was. In any case many leads but not enough to have concrete judgment.

I cannot state about the trauma or state of psychotherapy in Japan but i would think after that problem arose in him, at least his mother would try to mitigate the damage or seek counsel. Somehow this massive problem was untouched by everyone until he turned 17, especially since he was going to coed school and was in his 2nd year. (Even twins didn't know, his problem would be noticed in a year max)
Also truma fleshed out very conveniently instead like the usual. Usually in these cases, men become men haters, women haters and etc. Not to the point of PTSD like feeling. Though in theory possible but it feels so artificial that you cannot overlook it.

Basically everything feels like a rubber that was stretched to every side to conveniently create this story. Remote cases are ok, but combined together it just feels like fantasy.
 
Active member
Joined
Oct 29, 2018
Messages
47
Well that was simply unfortunate, we finally get what we were waiting for and they immediately kill him.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 14, 2018
Messages
312
Well, i'm glad i decided to read comments here before starting to read...
do they at least have any lovey dovey sex before the bad ending tho?
 
Joined
Jan 9, 2025
Messages
1
OK so I just make an account in this site just for thissss particular manga which I am so piss-off, honestly I read it out of bored at my lunch and somehow get invested, and I do regret reading it. So basically this manga is about:
  • a twin sister who is introvert yandere psycho who are jealous with his extrovert brother
  • she somehow drive out his brother to become hikikimori/shut-ins
  • she going out with their male friend who's his brother have a crush, just to spite his brother
  • apparently found out his brother have seggs with his ex, after she bullied and shaming both at the schools
  • she probably kill his brother off screen
  • MC is skizo, somehow impregnated the sister and manage to forget and forgive everything the sister had done.
0/10, absolute dumpsterfire
 
Joined
Jan 9, 2025
Messages
3
Trầm cảm mất thôi🥲 T đã mong đợi điều gì, bộ này điên vl, khi Kyou sắp thắng thì lại chết💀 t cứ tưởng là mơ hay tưởng tượng nhưng hóa ra là thật, cuối cùng sao ko chết hết 3 đứa lun ik, để con em thắng xog đẻ Kyou lm con:')))) t sợ não tác giả này quá r😭😭😭💀💀💀
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top