I'm still confused by the explanation... "They're growing out of you?" is a very weird way to describe some man parts if that's what going on, which makes me doubt things.
Since magic was involved, is it something else more grotesque and unnatural that shouldn't be around there, like fingers or an entire extra hand? Flowers? An extremely bright street lamp that makes always blinds anyone that looks at Lyle's crotch? Or maybe there is something more punny going on and Lyle has a literal beaver or literal rooster growing out of Lyle's crotch?