Damn reading this same day? (My original comment...) - I dont care that people can analyse this and write out long paragraphs explaining why the philosophy isnt right and so on. If it takes that much analysis and thought to make a claim that this story isnt as good as people say, are you sure it isnt good? You should deem how good it was mainly based on how you felt about it when reading it, as that is the primary way to consume fiction. that is likely the way it was intended to be consumed when written - to give you a good experience.
So stop analysing everything because your so smart and then prioritising that over your true opinion.