Live Dungeon! - Vol. 3 Ch. 12 - Outstretched Hand

Group Leader
Joined
Dec 28, 2018
Messages
707
@CraniumAmbiguity I totally agree that the guild should also do their own PR campaign to show that one of their own, a very popular member, was not being blackmailed. This also looks poorly on the guild too if something like this was going on under the nose of the guild. The narrative said the guild and the news station had equal power, therefor their word should have some way as well, even more so when the guild says they held her captive on ransom when she stormed the building.
This whole thing is revolving around Amy as the center piece. The moment you let out that Solit is keeping her on ransom, their will be a huge shit storm on them instead. Sure no one will believe the "Lucky Boy", whom they all hate, but the guilds word is strong enough to put heat on them.

Instead he is going to beat the dragon with 2 of the strongest guild members. He is just "lucky boy", he gets lucky.

At the end of all this, he better get hugely compensated for not only the slanderous article, but also what the article conspired to do and has done to his daily life (and threats/attempts to his life).

Its upsetting how poorly and unrealistic this is all being handled.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 8, 2018
Messages
777
@GrimGriefer That is another note I wanted to point out. Why does the guild have equal or less power than a news outlet? The dungeon in this world is created by GOD and he watches attentively. So an organization that regulates the dungeon and the adventurers there in should have the highest standings in the city.


At the end of all this, he better get hugely compensated for not only the slanderous article, but also what the article conspired to do and has done to his daily life (and threats/attempts to his life).

At the way this is being written, I doubt that we would get that kind of satisfaction. This will likely result in some sort of compromise where the Mc's reputation just goes back to how it was before the article and Amy rejoins the party like nothing happened but with new party member. At best the reporter might become a scapegoat for the company.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 23, 2020
Messages
2,804
This all reminds me: A good enough Minion Master, like a Necromancer type, can completely outperform a Tank quite often. While a proper Tank build in most MMOs can take a lot more damage than the average throwaway minion, it is usually a lot easier to control aggro with a cluster of multiple minions and even bodily obstruct enemies by crowding around them. Plus particularly with Necromancer type MMs, they tend to excel at battles of attrition since every dead enemy further empowers the Necro.

It was just a random thought. That a team-mate drawing too much aggro from the Tank with their high damage output wouldn't necessarily have the same problem with a Minion Master set-up.
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Dec 27, 2018
Messages
357
I know this is old and equivalent of necroing the forum, but had to get this off my chest...

Way too forced mini arc with the whole PR thing and everyone thinking MC is some kind of scumbag. I'm sure news traveled that Amy pretty much attacked the news organization for the lie. If the Squirrel Girl (fitting, for those of you that know [see Marvel]) reporter girl was supposed to be such a big fan of Amy and Garm and heard that Amy was upset that they lied about MC, why didn't she write a quick retraction and admit her faults in order to appease her idols? if she couldn't because her company told her not to, author should've gotten into that. Instead, somehow MC is supposed to prove his innocence by having two of the most strongest adventurers in town on his team and defeat the Flame Dragon or whatever? I mean that's what started this whole thing?

Why not just make sure everything they do as a party now is recorded like he should've done before. Yes, yes, I get the whole wanting to be unique thing, but that didn't make sense if his goal is to defeat the overall dungeon in hopes of getting back to regular old mundane Earth. It shouldn't matter if everyone sees...how...in fact that should more than help his goal because it will remove the stigma of being a White Mage from him and he can get more people fighting with him in the dungeon to conquer it.

Always wonder why manga authors create counterproductive ambitions in their characters like the "must-hide-myself" trope.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 22, 2020
Messages
661
I know this is old and equivalent of necroing the forum, but had to get this off my chest...

Way too forced mini arc with the whole PR thing and everyone thinking MC is some kind of scumbag. I'm sure news traveled that Amy pretty much attacked the news organization for the lie. If the Squirrel Girl (fitting, for those of you that know [see Marvel]) reporter girl was supposed to be such a big fan of Amy and Garm and heard that Amy was upset that they lied about MC, why didn't she write a quick retraction and admit her faults in order to appease her idols? if she couldn't because her company told her not to, author should've gotten into that. Instead, somehow MC is supposed to prove his innocence by having two of the most strongest adventurers in town on his team and defeat the Flame Dragon or whatever? I mean that's what started this whole thing?

Why not just make sure everything they do as a party now is recorded like he should've done before. Yes, yes, I get the whole wanting to be unique thing, but that didn't make sense if his goal is to defeat the overall dungeon in hopes of getting back to regular old mundane Earth. It shouldn't matter if everyone sees...how...in fact that should more than help his goal because it will remove the stigma of being a White Mage from him and he can get more people fighting with him in the dungeon to conquer it.

Always wonder why manga authors create counterproductive ambitions in their characters like the "must-hide-myself" trope.
Though this is 3~ish months after your comment, I think it could be explained as the author's cultural biase/home country knowledge. In Japan, they've seemed to have taken tabloid news up to the nth degree, and the author user that as basis for this story.
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Dec 27, 2018
Messages
357
Though this is 3~ish months after your comment, I think it could be explained as the author's cultural biase/home country knowledge. In Japan, they've seemed to have taken tabloid news up to the nth degree, and the author user that as basis for this story.
Going to be honest. I forgot about this manga. I see that I made it to chapter 20-something (according to my reading history on the browser I'm typing this on, but could've been further on another browser...dunno). But you might have a point about the author falling prey to the current PR/Tabloid culture in Japan and I don't recall enough about this particular mini-arc to give an adequate response either way other than to skim my pervious reply and see that my context and annoyance was about the "must-hide-myself" trope prevalent in isekai genre.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top