Lovely★Complex
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 30, 2018
- Messages
- 5,330
This is an awesome classic and I am a fan forever. Well, I'll admit it: I've actually mostly just watched the anime. From what I've read of the actual manga, the anime was really faithful and works well with the main characters, who are very, well, animated. They're energetic people with fascinatingly morphing facial expressions who chew the scenery like crazy, and a format with movement really shows them off amazingly well. Also the theme song for the first season is really fun, energetic and bouncy. So really, if you're going to read this, IMO consider watching the anime instead or as well. This is probably the only manga I've ever said this about.
But anyway, in whatever format, this is a massive classic. There is an arc or two I don't really like, and I could quibble with a couple more things. But I don't feel like it because I love Risa and Otani and I love the storytelling. The dialogue is snappy, the comedy is hilarious, the characters ooze charm. And . . . look, shoujo romance always has the basic difficulty, "Why this guy?" (heh. So does real life I guess) It has to convey to you this feeling that it's right for this girl to fall for this guy, has to give the chemistry. And a whole lot of the time, it all ends up hanging on an incident or two where the guy shows that he's awesome or cool or nice in some way. It can work, but in real life most of the time that's not what happens, right? And in real life very often someone might do something nice but you don't actually have a ton in common with them so you don't fall for them you just think, "That was a nice thing that person did" and move on. What I love about Risa and Otani is that they fall in love because ultimately they have little choice--their chemistry overflows the page, and nobody else can keep up with their pace. Some of the early bits where they plot together to get the good-looking significant other they're trying for to go to the beach or whatever with their group of friends so they can flirt with those people, but then once they're there they totally have so much fun together that they don't notice that they forgot to try for that other person until it's too late--classic. And despite, sometimes directly alongside, the comedy, the feelings are often strong and deep. The scene about "bear curry" had me laughing and blinking back tears at the same time.
It probably doesn't look as impressive now, but at the time this came out I remember most of shoujo being pretty . . . samey. It wasn't as genre-aware as it often is now, and really you had a lot of the same kind of wistful heroine with the same love complications and plot curves. Not that I disliked it . . . I'm a sucker for those doki-doki feelings and shoujo could always be counted on for that. But still, it was I think ripe for a bit of a shake-up, and this I think was one of the key manga that started to deliver that shake-up, and really stood out at the time for quite different characters and strong characterization and generally playing with the formula. I suspect Love-Com was influential and part of what brought us to where we are now, where shoujo is still writing in many ways the same basic situations (after all, romance about the lives of young people only has so much realistic room to operate in), but with a much broader variety of characterization, tone, and approach to plotting within those situations. Love-Com may not stick out of the modern field as much because of that. But it's still very very funny.
But anyway, in whatever format, this is a massive classic. There is an arc or two I don't really like, and I could quibble with a couple more things. But I don't feel like it because I love Risa and Otani and I love the storytelling. The dialogue is snappy, the comedy is hilarious, the characters ooze charm. And . . . look, shoujo romance always has the basic difficulty, "Why this guy?" (heh. So does real life I guess) It has to convey to you this feeling that it's right for this girl to fall for this guy, has to give the chemistry. And a whole lot of the time, it all ends up hanging on an incident or two where the guy shows that he's awesome or cool or nice in some way. It can work, but in real life most of the time that's not what happens, right? And in real life very often someone might do something nice but you don't actually have a ton in common with them so you don't fall for them you just think, "That was a nice thing that person did" and move on. What I love about Risa and Otani is that they fall in love because ultimately they have little choice--their chemistry overflows the page, and nobody else can keep up with their pace. Some of the early bits where they plot together to get the good-looking significant other they're trying for to go to the beach or whatever with their group of friends so they can flirt with those people, but then once they're there they totally have so much fun together that they don't notice that they forgot to try for that other person until it's too late--classic. And despite, sometimes directly alongside, the comedy, the feelings are often strong and deep. The scene about "bear curry" had me laughing and blinking back tears at the same time.
It probably doesn't look as impressive now, but at the time this came out I remember most of shoujo being pretty . . . samey. It wasn't as genre-aware as it often is now, and really you had a lot of the same kind of wistful heroine with the same love complications and plot curves. Not that I disliked it . . . I'm a sucker for those doki-doki feelings and shoujo could always be counted on for that. But still, it was I think ripe for a bit of a shake-up, and this I think was one of the key manga that started to deliver that shake-up, and really stood out at the time for quite different characters and strong characterization and generally playing with the formula. I suspect Love-Com was influential and part of what brought us to where we are now, where shoujo is still writing in many ways the same basic situations (after all, romance about the lives of young people only has so much realistic room to operate in), but with a much broader variety of characterization, tone, and approach to plotting within those situations. Love-Com may not stick out of the modern field as much because of that. But it's still very very funny.
Member
- Joined
- Mar 8, 2018
- Messages
- 261
where is the rest of it
- Joined
- Jan 31, 2019
- Messages
- 196
I'm so glad I picked this up!
Im going to miss All Hanshin Kyojin 😭😭
All in all, classic shoujo manga, one of the better ones if I say so myself. 8/10 👌👌
Im going to miss All Hanshin Kyojin 😭😭
All in all, classic shoujo manga, one of the better ones if I say so myself. 8/10 👌👌
- Joined
- Mar 25, 2019
- Messages
- 96
Probably my favourite shoujo of all time
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jun 14, 2019
- Messages
- 497
Super cute and wholesome
Hmm. I have to say to start, I watched the anime years ago and it was hilarious and awesome. Very touching and heartwarming while still making me laugh. The anime from what I can see was very faithful to the manga source material but improved on it a lot imo. The sound and visuals just made it better but as I saw it first I may be biased.
The manga has some chapters towards the end that they didnt put in the anime and honestly I'm grateful? Lol I enjoyed the extra chapters especially the volume 17 plus but the others had some annoyances to them for me. Still good but eh I can see why they didn't include them in the anime I guess?
Solid 8/10 manga but I'd give the anime a 9 or even 10/10 and recommend watching it over the manga its just that much better imo. Years after watching the anime while i was reading the manga i could pratically hear their voices at times or the music. Either way loved them both.
The manga has some chapters towards the end that they didnt put in the anime and honestly I'm grateful? Lol I enjoyed the extra chapters especially the volume 17 plus but the others had some annoyances to them for me. Still good but eh I can see why they didn't include them in the anime I guess?
Solid 8/10 manga but I'd give the anime a 9 or even 10/10 and recommend watching it over the manga its just that much better imo. Years after watching the anime while i was reading the manga i could pratically hear their voices at times or the music. Either way loved them both.
Ok so Yeet
I watched the anime out of boredom and I have to say I love it!!!!! It’s my favorite!!!
I’m reading the manga rn (as you can tell since I’m on here) and I’m almost done, and with the chapters that didn’t make it into the anime just make it better!! And I’m watching the anime again but stopping before I get ahead of the manga. Once I finish the manga I’m gonna watch the movie (YES THERE IS A MOVIE OF THIS SO WATCH IT!!) then I’ll pick up the anime where I left off and finish that making it my second rewatch of it.
Overall this series is low key my happy place, idk why but it’s very dear to me.
Hopefully y’all enjoyed it too!!!
After finishing:
it’s over 😭😭😭😭.
This series (manga, anime, & movie) is really special to me so I’m sad that’s it’s over but I can say this for sure I TRULY WHOLEHEARTEDLY APPRECIATE AND ENJOYED this. So I just want to say
Thank you ❤️🧡💛💜💙💚🖤🤍🤎🧡🧡🧡
To the author and the translation teams.
I watched the anime out of boredom and I have to say I love it!!!!! It’s my favorite!!!
I’m reading the manga rn (as you can tell since I’m on here) and I’m almost done, and with the chapters that didn’t make it into the anime just make it better!! And I’m watching the anime again but stopping before I get ahead of the manga. Once I finish the manga I’m gonna watch the movie (YES THERE IS A MOVIE OF THIS SO WATCH IT!!) then I’ll pick up the anime where I left off and finish that making it my second rewatch of it.
Overall this series is low key my happy place, idk why but it’s very dear to me.
Hopefully y’all enjoyed it too!!!
After finishing:
it’s over 😭😭😭😭.
This series (manga, anime, & movie) is really special to me so I’m sad that’s it’s over but I can say this for sure I TRULY WHOLEHEARTEDLY APPRECIATE AND ENJOYED this. So I just want to say
Thank you ❤️🧡💛💜💙💚🖤🤍🤎🧡🧡🧡
To the author and the translation teams.
- Joined
- Jun 22, 2019
- Messages
- 297
Read this when I was in elementary school and honestly, re-reading this now as a college student, I can't help but feel so happy to re-read a classic. T^T Nakahara Aya is one of the best manga artist ever! <3
Aggregator gang
- Joined
- Jul 15, 2020
- Messages
- 79
I found a manga that's a little bit like this.
"Fujiyama-san wa Shishunki"
"Fujiyama-san wa Shishunki"
Member
- Joined
- Oct 16, 2018
- Messages
- 33
I enjoyed it, and I especially enjoyed the artwork, but after awhile at least for me, it became kind of samey. Tons of one off rivals and the same exact failures to communicate time and time again. If you like that you'll like this, but it wasn't my thing. 7/10
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- May 19, 2018
- Messages
- 1,045
Anime's better than the manga. Hate to say it, but the manga has some filler and idiot ball writing that's annoying, and it gets worse as it goes. If you want to read the manga legally, it's on Vizmanga at Viz.com for $2 a month, 100 chapters a day.
The Anime is a total classic, and the manga's not bad, but the Anime cut out all the filler, polished the good parts, and added great voice acting and music to boot. Voice actress for the female lead also does Nami in One Piece, it's worth checking out, imo.
This manga hasn't aged well imo, it was good for its time, but has a lot of dumb, contrived tropes and people acting willfully stupid in ways that don't match their characterization sometimes, and it starts to grate after a while.
I still think it's worth checking out, but if you only have the time or inclination to either read the manga or watch the Anime, the Anime is MUCH better.
The Anime is a total classic, and the manga's not bad, but the Anime cut out all the filler, polished the good parts, and added great voice acting and music to boot. Voice actress for the female lead also does Nami in One Piece, it's worth checking out, imo.
This manga hasn't aged well imo, it was good for its time, but has a lot of dumb, contrived tropes and people acting willfully stupid in ways that don't match their characterization sometimes, and it starts to grate after a while.
I still think it's worth checking out, but if you only have the time or inclination to either read the manga or watch the Anime, the Anime is MUCH better.
