Marquis of Amnesia

Double-page supporter
Joined
Aug 13, 2018
Messages
257
I really hate it when whole chapters get split up into little chunks, it seriously messes up ease of reading and flow when there's a break in what should be a cohesive story every 8 pages. For this particular example, I know it's the publisher's fault and not the scanlator's, but some notable scanlation groups purposefully choose to do this to monthly releases and I can't get over it. This series is looking okay so far but I still really wish the publisher or artist would just release complete chapters instead of doing whatever this is.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 14, 2018
Messages
1,214
@cinnamoncookie

If tropes are anything to go by: his new and old memories mix, he realizes he was a POS and that the excuse of trauma only go's so far yadayada happily ever after.
 
Active member
Joined
May 1, 2018
Messages
615
The chapter chunks are really annoying.
Dropping sorely because of that.
 
Joined
Jun 7, 2020
Messages
105
The art is great but there's no detailed background even though i know it will be explained later but still, not getting me hooked enough to read the next chapter
 
Group Leader
Joined
Feb 14, 2018
Messages
41
Oof, I am still hoping for some healing, but it still hasn't happened yet; right now we are still in the 'angst' phase.

Still, both the FL and ML are quite pitiable... FL was abused by her family and had an apathetic husband (but all of the servants love her, so at the very least she wasn't lonely, and she had trustworthy companions), while ML has to navigate the world with no memories, and is being constantly reminded that he was a horrible person in the past. That said, since his current personality is so kind, it's likely that this is his "original" personality, and it was the stuff he experienced in life that made him a terrible person.

IMO this story might have started off stronger if we saw this from the ML's perspective first, since he basically needs to start things from zero, like us as the audience. He gets thrown into a world of grandure and learns of the duties he had, and needs to start all of them from scratch. Then, as he interacts with his wife (FL), he learns how horrible of a person he used to be; thus we enter FL's perspective to see how she had experienced it. That would have been a more interesting development, and his "past terrible personality" would become an early twist that sets the main conflict into motion.

Still, it seems like the ML wasn't a bad person per se, just apathetic, and even now we are still picking up the pieces of what kind of person he used to be (which is probably a set-up to show that he had his reasons to become his apathetic self). But the fact that they chose to start from the FL' s perspective seemed to cement the impression that the ML was a terrible person, which is kinda unfair for him (especially when people are talking about dropping this already when we barely started). And, well, the ML's character arc is 1000x more interesting than the abused FL cliche, and it's pretty obvious he will be going through a dramatic character development and having to take the most active role, while the FL will remain a blank static character that just sits by and watch what he brings her. Just that alone makes it clear that the ML is the protagonist of this story, not the FL. Regardless, we are still at the early parts of the story, and I am looking forward to see if it might overturn my expectations.
 
Supporter
Joined
Dec 24, 2018
Messages
577
Having the chapters broken up into so many tiny sections really breaks the flow when reading.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top