Meccha Shoukan Sareta Ken - Ch. 43

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 15, 2019
Messages
318
Well, that's a terrifyingly effective means of carpet bombing a battlefield! Didn't know it'd have as much power as the others mentioned, but it's still pretty damn cool! Meteor Rain's been invented!

Thanks for the translations!
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Oct 19, 2019
Messages
62
Its not like this is the worst example but I wish fiction authors had a little more awareness and corollary respect for the proportionality of real world physics.

Thanks for the chapter!
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Feb 12, 2023
Messages
269
aside of the overkill energy, the author messed up a whole lot of other physics.
1000km is a quite noticeable 17% of earth's radius, way above the atmosphere. that's low earth orbit. the fall would take 7.5 minutes at 1 g or over 8 minutes accounting for the 25% reduced gravity it starts in, not 5 like author said, and in the mean time earth's surface would have moved 200 km on the equator, less on other places. because the linear difference between the velocities of the start and end points is the same 17% (assuming earth-sized planet) it is impossible for something to just fall straight vertically from there, it'll always have to take an arc path of some sort. so it'll be impossible for him to aim precisely without some trial and error first. or some math, which both he and the author are clearly incapable of.

the small rocks they were shown gathering also didn't seem anywhere close to 6 tons. if it were a few hundred kilo rocks dropped from a few hundred meters it'd still be powerful enough, easy to aim, and air resistance would not have any effect so he wouldn't need to handwave that part away too.
 
Last edited:
Supporter
Joined
Jan 28, 2018
Messages
900
aside of the overkill energy, the author messed up a whole lot of other physics.
1000km is a quite noticeable 17% of earth's radius, way above the atmosphere. that's low earth orbit. the fall would take 7.5 minutes at 1 g or over 8 minutes accounting for the 25% reduced gravity it starts in, not 5 like author said, and in the mean time earth's surface would have moved 200 km on the equator, less on other places. because the linear difference between the velocities of the start and end points is the same 17% (assuming earth-sized planet) it is impossible for something to just fall straight vertically from there, it'll always have to take an arc path of some sort. so it'll be impossible for him to aim precisely without some trial and error first. or some math, which both he and the author are clearly incapable of.

the small rocks they were shown gathering also didn't seem anywhere close to 6 tons. if it were a few hundred kilo rocks dropped from a few hundred meters it'd still be powerful enough, easy to aim, and air resistance would not have any effect so he wouldn't need to handwave that part away too.
Thank you, was going to also comment on the 1k km up in the "air". Confusion remains, if it was the authors goof, or an issue with the translation (as other comments are talking about ~10 km instead of the ~1k km?)
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top