Medalion's manga meter

[medalion]

I'll rate any manga/comics posted on this thread.
I will read at least 1 chapter no matter what, usually more for a fair judgement.
The rating will be from 0 to 10.
0-2 horrid, i could only read 1 chapter
3-5 meh, will likely drop it
6-8 good reading slop
9-10 am invested and want to read it
The rules are as follows & may be subject to change.

• 1 recommendation per day
• It's in english
• I can find it

Yeah that's it show me what you got.

Spoiler

yogurtman250​

- Hirayasumi - 10

GipoScribantino​

• Even a Monkey Can Draw Manga. - 7
• Senkai-den Hoshin Engi - 7
• Freeter ga Jimini Isekai Teni Suru Manga - 6

panzerkampfwagyu​

- Stealth Symphony - 5

solstice258​

- Labradorescence - 6-7

gimme_yuri_plz​

- Soredemo Ashita mo Kareshi ga Ii - 3

Dverin_Oshiban_Duren​

- IseGure: After Constantly Being Used as a Foil for OP Isekai Protagonists, the Elite Knight has Finally Had It - 10

Itsukimoto​

- One piece - 7

Manko-sensei​

- Idol x Idol Story! - 4

bigtiddyoneesan
- Yugami-kun ni wa Tomodachi ga Inai - 7

 

[yogurtman250]

Hirayasumi (most of it it's not in this site, sorry)

 

[DavidianMillerian]

first @bigtiddyoneesan's rate any song thread, and now this?

maybe I should resurrect my rate anything thread...

 

[Itsukimoto]

first @bigtiddyoneesan's rate any song thread, and now this?

maybe I should resurrect my rate anything thread...

you already knew this was coming-nya

 

[DavidianMillerian]

you already knew this was coming-nya

the server giveth, and the server taketh

 

[Dverin_Oshiban_Duren]

Interesting
I do have a few but it's hard to pick so I need some time and I have some questions:
Is it English only?
Is it for manga only?
What if the manga isn't complete here but is available on other sites?

 

[medalion]

Interesting
I do have a few but it's hard to pick so I need some time and I have some questions:
Is it English only?
Is it for manga only?
What if the manga isn't complete here but is available on other sites?

if i can find it in english i'll read it. If you're thinking of comics they're fine too.

 

[medalion]

Hirayasumi (most of it it's not in this site, sorry)

Aight i've been reading this for 13 chapters. And i think i'll read it till the end.
It's a story about life. The story & events are interesting, characters feel real and i'm invested. Just like the mc thinks, i feel the manga telling me that things happen in life, you'll be alright.
As i was thinking what to rate it i realised i can't rate these the way i would a finished story. Meh who cares its a
10/10 so far from me.

 

[GipoScribantino]

Even a Monkey Can Draw Manga.

 

[panzerkampfwagyu]

Stealth Symphony

 

[bigtiddyoneesan]

me after i turn on notifs for every time a submission in this thread doesn't have a link and put my phone in my ass:

 

[solstice258]

I can't believe nobody posted any Mangadex links. smh
Anyway, try Labradorescence

 

[gimme_yuri_plz]

Soredemo Ashita mo Kareshi ga Ii

Rating 3.12

You’re welcome! 🤣

Edit: I recommend reading the comments section. There's a lot of rage. 🍿😎

 

[Dverin_Oshiban_Duren]

IseGure: After Constantly Being Used as a Foil for OP Isekai Protagonists, the Elite Knight has Finally Had It.
It's a comedy about a guy who is pissed at isekai'd jerks with cheat skills trying to stop the next person from dying.

 

[medalion]

Even a Monkey Can Draw Manga.

Read it till lesson(chapter?) 5
It's about @bigtiddyoneesan & @pandascepter teaching you to be a mangaka. Love the panels & facial expressions. This is peak humour.

Spoiler

Panels go Left -> Right

I don't have an artistic bone in my body so I can't apply the technical teachings of this manga, which no doubt would make this even better.

But what i can do is try to notice these things in manga that i read, pretty neat.

It also gives good general life advise.

But gag mangas with no real plot were never really my style. It's short & the teachings are interesting so i think i'll read this through when i don't want to binge anything.

All in all 7 🍔 Out of 10 🍔 tasty!

 

[bigtiddyoneesan]

 

[medalion]

 

[medalion]

Stealth symphony read till chapter 8
I've made a rant about shounens before. But in this case the setting is unique and the story isn't predictable, but there is so much action with no weight. Also character development gets pushed out. As a result I don't find myself caring about the characters. And the mc is just criminally naive & out of touch with the world around him, at least in the start. Tbf we know he will grow out of it. There are tons of mini discrepancies in the story and world that add up making me unable to take it seriously.
Couple that in with my own dislike bias.

Spoiler

Thank you mr.goon from the secretive assassins guild for monologuing the big bad's plans for shits & giggles. (he does get killed for it after)

I personally dislike this killing intent stuff. It's always very vague in its rules and feels like the authors usually pull things our of their ass when it comes to it. Common trait in shounen.

"I can detect your musky killing intent emanating from your armpits a mile away!"
"Aw, shucks! My plans are foiled!"

Another day another time.

"Shock*! H-how could i not detect you?"
"Heh, I used the new loreal paris anti killing intent perspirant with 24h protection, your days are over pal!"

hmm.. this makes me wanna bumb up Even a Monkey Can Draw Manga.
I'll give it 5 senju beans 🫘 out of 10 🫘

 

[Itsukimoto]

One piece. Nya

Ugh the urge to say the most messed up manga ever-nya...

 

[Manko-sensei]

I have no idea what you like, so I'm going to force you read this series.