Mizu Zokusei no Mahoutsukai - Vol. 4 Ch. 16

[MangaDex]

 

[antipothis]

Ugh, kind of gross. I don't like the use of cheap 3d models that's been a trend in anime now coming down into manga as well. It's really ugly and doesn't fit.

 

[feha]

...this "art" is awful

Good thing mc skipped the entire battle by holing up in the library. So he didn't have to see it.

 

[irem01]

this has so much potential bro fuck cgi goblins

 

[okasakisan]

As i said in the last page, this chapter adaptation was awful, random panels in a page same with that one random speech bubble "dont forget to stay hydrated" lol wut I know the manga is called The Water Magician, so there is a focus on water but come on, that comment felt so random, although to be fair it was also on the web novel but it was attached to other stuff so it didnt feel as random. I dont know if this is the first manga the authors work on but it feels so extremely amateurish.

 

[Styrr]

jfc cgi goblins on my black and white manga

 

[Dezaki]

thanks for the notes, I had no idea that it was hours of shooting. I thought the battle had only progressed like 10 to 15 minutes hence why I was thinking "those knights only brings 10 arrows or something?"

 

[okasakisan]

thanks for the notes, I had no idea that it was hours of shooting. I thought the battle had only progressed like 10 to 15 minutes hence why I was thinking "those knights only brings 10 arrows or something?"

i almost didnt do the notes because there was so much missing and even then there was still more i didnt put down, just small exchanges between Abel and his group and more small details, i tried to only put down what i thought would add the most context.

 

[nuttyknight89]

Thanks for the chapter. Also, no grammatical errors this time. Good job! Practice makes perfect.

 

[JACGohu]

CGI when properly blended with conventional art, can look quite impressive. This is not a good example of that. >_<

 

[77BLc9JwJGpLVARkamJx]

Kek. the shading was the cherry on top.

 

[Grikath]

So.... Humans take an Arrow to the Knee. Goblins just have to one-up and take a Bow to the Shin..... check

It's CGI, so it must be true....

 

[_idiot]

I generally don't like to poo-poo other people's efforts, but, really, this is bad:

And yeah, why is there a bow coming out of the left goblin's leg?

 

[GrimGriefer]

low effort art meets low effort cgi. It feel like the author went on fiverr and got any random artist for $5 a chapter.

its not impossible to make CGI look good in 2D media. You just need the experience and put in the effort to blend it properly. But considering how low the quality of art has been, that was never going to happen.

The only reason why all the models, including the MC, are not CGI, is because the artist doesnt know how to make them himself. All these models were most likely purchased from a humblebundle sale.

 

[chemy1347]

Mere goblins can easily bend the steel bars? Tf?

 

[Kirin-kun]

Where did the girl get a megaphone?

 

[wakanana]

This whole manga feels like a career ender for the artist.

Like, WTF. It might be the worst I've ever seen.