Motto mo Kirawareteiru Saikyou no Akuyaku ni Tensei - Vol. 3 Ch. 13

Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 15, 2019
Messages
832
Sarin is possibly the fastest acting poison, and requires a minimum of roughly a minute. All poisons require the body to spread the poison to its target, and then time for the chemical reaction to occur. Neither of these are lightning fast processes.
Try looking at poison not limited to human targets, all of those tests are tiny tiny amounts on quite large creatures (humans).
It's like, you're all comparing poison a 20cm frogs poison to a 1.7m human and not a fucking huge chimera and a 1.7m human, do you really think that makes sense? (not you specifically btw).
Not to mention whatever bullshit physics work in that otherworld.

Rather than firmly believing nothing new could exist outside of our current knowledge and say that a fast and lethal poison is impossible.
Consider that there's not really any need for any animal to evolve poison for such a purpose, since immobilizing or "digesting" for pray, or killing with large chance of success for self defense (of the species not the individual), is all that is really needed in this worlds normal evolution. Who is to say that other paths of poison is impossible?

Oh also this scene is NOT lightning fast.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 20, 2019
Messages
1,093
Try looking at poison not limited to human targets, all of those tests are tiny tiny amounts on quite large creatures (humans).
It's like, you're all comparing poison a 20cm frogs poison to a 1.7m human and not a fucking huge chimera and a 1.7m human, do you really think that makes sense? (not you specifically btw).
Not to mention whatever bullshit physics work in that otherworld.

Rather than firmly believing nothing new could exist outside of our current knowledge and say that a fast and lethal poison is impossible.
Consider that there's not really any need for any animal to evolve poison for such a purpose, since immobilizing or "digesting" for pray, or killing with large chance of success for self defense (of the species not the individual), is all that is really needed in this worlds normal evolution. Who is to say that other paths of poison is impossible?

Oh also this scene is NOT lightning fast.
Well, I will accept the bullshit otherworld physics defense. You have a point there.

But the basic mechanics of poisoning (in normal biology) is very different for a human and a small prey. They have a system that is much more reactive simply due to much smaller distance for the poison to cover before it hits all the affected organs. The circulatory system simply covers the distance faster. Poison spread is pretty much limited by the speed of blood circulation, the fastest vector for poison delivery. Blood moves the speed it moves, regardless of the size of the source.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 15, 2019
Messages
832
Edit: forgot the reply button and then stuff happened, is there really no delete post button.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 15, 2019
Messages
832
Well, I will accept the bullshit otherworld physics defense. You have a point there.

But the basic mechanics of poisoning (in normal biology) is very different for a human and a small prey. They have a system that is much more reactive simply due to much smaller distance for the poison to cover before it hits all the affected organs. The circulatory system simply covers the distance faster. Poison spread is pretty much limited by the speed of blood circulation, the fastest vector for poison delivery. Blood moves the speed it moves, regardless of the size of the source.

From a random google search "It takes the heart less than one minute to pump blood to every cell in the body. In fact, six quarts of blood can fully circulate throughout the body at least three times within that minute. That totals thousands of round trips each day." So I'd say it's quite fast.

Anyways, we ware discussing time from poison to death so if we are debating what it needs to reach to lead to death we'd also need to talk about what constitutes death. Poison reaching the heart could be seen as lethal, but it also could be said you'd be fine till the brain gets fucked by the lack of blood flow... If you somehow stopped the poison from fucking up the brain directly.

Would the healing magic stop the poison spread & fix the heart instantly, would the magic heal any damage to the brain as well? Is it that OP? Seems not since the healing didn't work.

Actually we don't really know how much healing magic can do in the first place, maybe he'd just die from the shock or the bleeding without poison even mattering.

I don't find this death to be hard to believe...
 
Active member
Joined
Feb 11, 2018
Messages
110
@Valve
You're putting way too much effort into explaining a dumb plot point. You are literally writing paragraphs after assuming there's venom (Pet peeve of mine. Quick rule of thumb: it bites you = venom, you bite it = poison.) because you're assuming it's a chimera.

If there really was some fantasy uber-venom involved, then someone in the story probably would've said something about it. Or maybe you're somehow right and the rest of us will look dumb for assuming the author was capable of basic storytelling.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 15, 2019
Messages
832
You're putting way too much effort into explaining a dumb plot point. You are literally writing paragraphs after assuming there's venom (Pet peeve of mine. Quick rule of thumb: it bites you = venom, you bite it = poison.) because you're assuming it's a chimera.

If there really was some fantasy uber-venom involved, then someone in the story probably would've said something about it. Or maybe you're somehow right and the rest of us will look dumb for assuming the author was capable of basic storytelling.
And you are putting way too much effort into policing where others put their effort.

It's not really uber, it's just that people arguing is shortening the time for events to fit their argument.

Also when reading manga or any other story really, the reader is expected to insert some details on their own when building the scene in their imaginations, that does not mean the author has FAILED BASIC STORYTELLING.

In the first place what I was talking about was the possibility of the character dying and not some attempt to add stuff in the story.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 9, 2020
Messages
217
I wonder if Mc will be mr.steal-ur-girl.😏
That would rile-up the crowd.

Weeeelll... We're already seeing signs that the "Hero" isn't all that great, a relatively common feature of "I'm a villain/NTR protag, but don't wanna villain/NTR" stories (In fact, sometimes they're the evil ones.)

So I doubt it'll rile up the crowd.

But we will see whether it's the interesting kind where the "Hero" is derailed and loses things, but becomes a friendly-ish rival, or just an asshole who fails to come to terms with what's clearly a blinded sense of "justice."

I'm not laying any money down on the first, though, considering...
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top