Idk if that's a great gift. Bibi might feel awful seeing those plushies. It's like a "remember the time you killed our rabbit and dog?"
Sure she didn't realize what she did was insane but reminding her of such a horrible 'MISTAKE' seems cruel.
I get it's supposed to be like, "even though they're gone we'll always love them. They were part of our family so here's something to remember them." It's just in poor taste imo
EDIT: she only killed the dog. I forgot that. That's my bad. The question is, has her emotional range changed enough that the gift could be a painful reminder, or is it a good gift for someone like her. Showing her that nick loves her despite her flaws and the pain she caused him. I didn't think of it that way until wujushounen pointes it out.
