NEET dakedo Hello Work ni Ittara Isekai ni Tsuretekareta - Vol. 3 Ch. 20
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 23, 2018
- Messages
- 668
wouldn't those dragons (or whatever giant monsters) be able to simply overrun that fortress by themselves if they would not waste their time to drop off those useless normal sized monsters (like goblins and orcs)?
What I mean is...
WHY waste time, work and effectivity by making the effort to bring goblins, orcs and so on if those giant monsters could simply tear down the wall and devastate everything behind it by breaking through it with a full speed body slam?
What I mean is...
WHY waste time, work and effectivity by making the effort to bring goblins, orcs and so on if those giant monsters could simply tear down the wall and devastate everything behind it by breaking through it with a full speed body slam?
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- May 20, 2018
- Messages
- 3,426
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2019
- Messages
- 1,132
@Talh
Sure, they could probably destroy the fortress by themselves.
But we don't know how easy they are to kill, they could be killable by enough people doing something at them, and with that size, focusing on small humans is kinda hard.
So i'm assuming it's something like the efficient cooperation between tanks & infantry.
Sure, they could probably destroy the fortress by themselves.
But we don't know how easy they are to kill, they could be killable by enough people doing something at them, and with that size, focusing on small humans is kinda hard.
So i'm assuming it's something like the efficient cooperation between tanks & infantry.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 23, 2018
- Messages
- 668
@starburst98
They could carry a small amount of elite monsters on their back to cover their blindspots while also being supported by the flying troops.
Then they would just smash through the walls and devastate whatever is in their way.
After they have run some way beyond the fortress they turn around.
Now they can attack the fort from behind while other monsters storm from the front and the flying monsters attack from the sky - a three-pronged attack.
Instead the giant monsters carry lots of small monsters which make them unable to really run as they have to watch out for those large groups on their backs.
Then they only hit the wall until a part grumbles and need to stop then to let the smaller monsters down from via their heads.
So they are then actually forced to not move their heads in an exposed position.
A head is actually a weakspot I'd say. So having to hold still to let them down is doing exactly the opposite of what you say the small monsters are meant for.
They do not protect the weakspot called "head" they are the cause that it is especially exposed to counter attacks in that situation.
To compare it with your tank example.
It is like tanks carrying foot soldiers to look out for some enemy foot soldiers who might try to approach from blindspots.
But the tanks are attempting to attack an enemy artillery position and just before driving up the hill to those artilleries they stop to let down the foot soldiers so that the foot soldiers can storm it instead.
That does not make sense.
And that is exactly what the monsters are doing here.
Edit:
@Robbini: Check this somment above this line. That is what they should go for.
The way the monsters are attacking makes the combo of small + large monsters useless as they combine their weaknesses together instead of their strengths this way.
They could carry a small amount of elite monsters on their back to cover their blindspots while also being supported by the flying troops.
Then they would just smash through the walls and devastate whatever is in their way.
After they have run some way beyond the fortress they turn around.
Now they can attack the fort from behind while other monsters storm from the front and the flying monsters attack from the sky - a three-pronged attack.
Instead the giant monsters carry lots of small monsters which make them unable to really run as they have to watch out for those large groups on their backs.
Then they only hit the wall until a part grumbles and need to stop then to let the smaller monsters down from via their heads.
So they are then actually forced to not move their heads in an exposed position.
A head is actually a weakspot I'd say. So having to hold still to let them down is doing exactly the opposite of what you say the small monsters are meant for.
They do not protect the weakspot called "head" they are the cause that it is especially exposed to counter attacks in that situation.
To compare it with your tank example.
It is like tanks carrying foot soldiers to look out for some enemy foot soldiers who might try to approach from blindspots.
But the tanks are attempting to attack an enemy artillery position and just before driving up the hill to those artilleries they stop to let down the foot soldiers so that the foot soldiers can storm it instead.
That does not make sense.
And that is exactly what the monsters are doing here.
Edit:
@Robbini: Check this somment above this line. That is what they should go for.
The way the monsters are attacking makes the combo of small + large monsters useless as they combine their weaknesses together instead of their strengths this way.
@Talh it's carrying monsters on its back. You can clearly see them.
As for the rest. Monsters are not in diplomatic terms with each other. They don't study siege tactics either. They don't have a military organization either.
In the novels is directly stated that the only one capable of organizing monsters is the demon Lord which is why the hero was sent long ago.
This is the first organized attack with dragons, orcs and goblins in recently history.
As for the rest. Monsters are not in diplomatic terms with each other. They don't study siege tactics either. They don't have a military organization either.
In the novels is directly stated that the only one capable of organizing monsters is the demon Lord which is why the hero was sent long ago.
This is the first organized attack with dragons, orcs and goblins in recently history.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- May 20, 2018
- Messages
- 3,426
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 23, 2018
- Messages
- 668
@Faryshta
Nice try.
But these monsters are clearly organized as a troop.
Otherwise they would not work together to begin with.
The giant monsters would not carry the normal sized monsters.
The flying monsters would have no reason to be there at all either.
And even among the normal sized monsters the stronger ones would use the weaker ones as fodder.
So the fact that these monsters work together like shown in this chapter means that someone is controlling them.
And who do you think can control all these monsters?
Right! Most likely someone like a high ranking and highly intellectual demon, demon lord or even demon king.
So I would say such a high ranking demon - demon lord - demon king would be smart enough to make use of the strength of those monsters instead of putting them together in a way that they weaken each other.
Nice try.
But these monsters are clearly organized as a troop.
Otherwise they would not work together to begin with.
The giant monsters would not carry the normal sized monsters.
The flying monsters would have no reason to be there at all either.
And even among the normal sized monsters the stronger ones would use the weaker ones as fodder.
So the fact that these monsters work together like shown in this chapter means that someone is controlling them.
And who do you think can control all these monsters?
Right! Most likely someone like a high ranking and highly intellectual demon, demon lord or even demon king.
So I would say such a high ranking demon - demon lord - demon king would be smart enough to make use of the strength of those monsters instead of putting them together in a way that they weaken each other.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 23, 2018
- Messages
- 668
@starburst98:
If these giant monsters could NOT run, then
A) how did they catch enough pray to grow so big?
- Their teeth show that they are carnivorous. So they are not eating plants. And any animal or smaller monster than them would simply run away if they can only walk.
B) how could those monsters close in on the fortress without being spotted HOURS before they get close?
- It would be pretty hard for the outlook to overlook a "mountain" (or several "mountains") moving in onto their position.
If these giant monsters could NOT run, then
A) how did they catch enough pray to grow so big?
- Their teeth show that they are carnivorous. So they are not eating plants. And any animal or smaller monster than them would simply run away if they can only walk.
B) how could those monsters close in on the fortress without being spotted HOURS before they get close?
- It would be pretty hard for the outlook to overlook a "mountain" (or several "mountains") moving in onto their position.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- May 20, 2018
- Messages
- 3,426
Fed-Kun's army
- Joined
- Feb 7, 2019
- Messages
- 299
@Talh again this is the first attack like this in recent history. The dragon in chapter 8 was completely alone, the harpies in chapter 15 were alone too.
This invasion actually is a turning point in the novels militarily speaking. Here people start to suspect the revival of the demon Lord.
@saredesu the forest is the reason. The monsters used the tree lines as cover for the most part. A dragon that size can charge for kilometers in an straight line in minutes.
This invasion actually is a turning point in the novels militarily speaking. Here people start to suspect the revival of the demon Lord.
@saredesu the forest is the reason. The monsters used the tree lines as cover for the most part. A dragon that size can charge for kilometers in an straight line in minutes.
@MarqFJA87 she's from Sekai ka kanojo ka erabenai
Similar threads
