Nise Seijo Kuso of the Year: Risou no Seijo? Zannen, Nise Seijo deshita!

[Thrackris]

Art is good. But the way the story is going... It feels rushed, I think, I will stick with the novel.

 

[Protoayi]

I've binged all 4 volumes of the LN and I have to say, this adaption does not do the LN justice enough. This manga is told solely from the perspective of Ellize without any of the more interesting/important internal monologue that breathes life into the characters. They just don't get enough time in the spotlight to make them interesting. The art is cute I'll give it that much. However, this whole speedrunning through the plot leaves much to be desired.

For the reasons above I'll be putting this on hold until its done. (Ch29.2)

 

[mgRdr]

I read from spoilers about all the amazing things hapening in the WN/LN, but the manga is an incomprehensible mess

 

[Fusang]

This is my favorite isekai, the novel that is. i can't read the manga because it just disappoints me when i try. fake saint deserved a better adaption than it got, too bad the publisher didn't see it that way.

 

[koplomen]

mimpi basah author lagi

 

[Gigz]

I'm back 2 years later just to say it again: READ THE NOVEL!!!

After reading more of the manga, it just feels like someone drew a manga off of a summary of the story. I'm just so sad about it. There are so many moments glossed over that should've drawn genuine feelings out. I looked for each of my favorite parts only to see them passed over in a panel and tarnished.

I reread the novel again out of spite. I still love it.

 

[scrangos]

is the light novel or the web novel better?

 

[leviadragon]

Dammit, another story I was enjoying abruptly cancelled.

 

[mustakim367]

Noooooo Don't Cancelled😭

 

[hozuki16]

Shame it got axed on the story's climax

 

[zaxthealien]

I'm back 2 years later just to say it again: READ THE NOVEL!!!

After reading more of the manga, it just feels like someone drew a manga off of a summary of the story. I'm just so sad about it. There are so many moments glossed over that should've drawn genuine feelings out. I looked for each of my favorite parts only to see them passed over in a panel and tarnished.

I reread the novel again out of spite. I still love it.

Moreover, the manga even got axed just before final act. just read the novel instead of reading this manga.

 

[grimathefelldragon]

This is the first time I've seen a read the novel ending and I hate it

 

[IMissU]

This is pretty good thus far if I completely ignore the few real world pages of the story which is not quite to my tastes

I cannot edit my post anymore so I will state it ended very meh. Story wasn't the best to begin with but goes a bit downhill halfway and becomes a complete mess by the end. There were interesting plot points but in the end they were just that, plot points. Ones which the author never really had a good development in mind for to begin with. Just an interesting thing to toss in and then at the end have to somehow find a way to work in again in the whirlwind of unthoughtout senseless chaos the story devolves into

 

[DarkYetDarker]

Having read this manga in its entirety, I will give my honest thoughts.

1. Much of the humor is centered on the main character's saintly outward behavior and overwhelming power being contrasted with her irreverent, hedonistic personality, which is hilarious. It's very reminiscent of other isekai power fantasies that base themselves on such a division, such as Overlord and Eminence in Shadows.

2. The manga's story has a brisk pace, not getting bogged down in the weeds at any particular point, and it seemed to be moving towards a definitive climax before it concluded abruptly with a "read the novel" ending.

3. Unfortunately, the other characters besides Elize/Niito do not get much in the way of depth. They follow well-worn character archetypes religiously (the overenthusiastic servant, the oblivious male lead, the insecure heroine with great potential, etc.) and have little in the way of depth. Verner seems to have something mysterious about his backstory and role in one of the secret endings, but this never gets much attention in-story.

4. Ellize's foreknowledge of the story and overwhelming power kills any tension in the story. In Overlord, the tension is built up over Ainz's minions' plotting as well as the nail-biting fate of the 'heroes' in a world with such an overpowered villain protagonist. Eminence in Shadow is primarily a comedy, and the highlights are always when Cid misinterprets events in such a way that hinders his personal goals of becoming the "Eminence of Shadow" - he might save the day, but his efforts always backfire, and we are eager to see more. We don't get anything like that in this story, unfortunately.

5. The "read the novel to find out more" ending is always annoying.

Overall, it was somewhat entertaining, but not something I'd recommend to anyone.

 

[NEN_POL]

Damm it I just wondering why it's so short and already end and yeah it got axed and poor adaption too bad for me I don't like to read LN/WN so yeah I have to skip this one

 

[VNBACHLIKEANIMEANDMANGA]

Damm it I just wondering why it's so short and already end and yeah it got axed and poor adaption too bad for me I don't like to read LN/WN so yeah I have to skip this one

I highly recommend you read LN or WN online, although you said you dont like read LN/WN, i recommend you should try 1 time, im so lazy to read LN/WN but i really interested in this manga/LN/WN so i try read it and yeah

 

[VNBACHLIKEANIMEANDMANGA]

The manga is good, but the ending is so abrupt, I came to this side and saw that the manga cut a lot of parts
Anyway, this is a manga/novel that I really like, probably one of my favorite masterpieces
Thanks to the trans as well as the people who contributed to this series
Peace!!!