Non-Intrusive Ads… for a Short While

[Spica]

Sure, but I haven't seen a single legitimate critique so far outside the banner ad being too large in mobile due to a bug.

I agree again. Some critiques are just ads bad which is unconstructive, useless, and stupid. There are some interesting points IMO in page 19 alone (there was more in previous pages, but i'm lazy):

Note: I cut some sentences to make it more concise. U can read OP's post urself

I expect a big, honest and very personal post about going against the number one policy after years of openly dismissing ads

Still, on the other hand I understand needing the funds, not like the servers pay for themselves. My main issue is with the delivery I guess.

@N0Mi0 said the announcement could be better. It is understandable to move to ads. So a critique on the delivery, not the ads itself.

any advertisement will be seen as income by publishers, regardless of what you say the funds will be used for. You're just giving them another reason to come after the site yet again.

@KazuyaKan said that ads could move the Eye of Sauron to MD even harder. Maybe it's good to reconsider ads implementation to evade it.


I love these kind of points. It enrich my mind especially for topic that I'm interested in. Feedback should always be welcomed especially if it's constructive. Even if ads go through, at least the decision is better made.

 

[HaikenEdge]

Sure, but I haven't seen a single legitimate critique so far outside the banner ad being too large in mobile due to a bug.

I mean, I feel like if you're going to be on a manga piracy website, you're probably also savvy enough to be using some sort of adblocker.

 

[panzerkampfwagyu]

I still hold that they should've used selling known useless funsies as their main method instead, though.
Think that also would've been easier to seperate from making money from piracy too.
Also, I am happy that the banner got fixed now.
Still would like the "for a Short While" to be clarified though, as I am bothered by the lack of a clear definition there

 

[mangadexjp]

I still hold that they should've used selling known useless funsies as their main method instead, though.
Think that also would've been easier to seperate from making money from piracy too.
Also, I am happy that the banner got fixed now.
Still would like the "for a Short While" to be clarified though, as I am bothered by the lack of a clear definition there

where did the money from namicomi go?
wasn't there some news about them getting huge amount of funding?

 

[HaikenEdge]

but we're just opposed to both advertisements and also to making money off of content that isn't ours in the first place.

Funny how that's changed.

 

[OisE]

Funny how that's changed.

Funny how you are not funny.