I love both manga, but this manga is really about the woman’s clumsy’s antics… the mc feels like an afterthought and an extension of the plot instead of an individual. And unfortunately some people don’t want an mc to be anything more than generic/self-insert… meaning they might not like the other manga
The other manga has both a quirky mc and quirky main girl. The quirks allow them to act on their own in the story and when they interact it’s really good fuel for romance. Also the artstyle is highly detailed to give a false sense of fear/horror to add to the comedy