One Punch-Man (Webcomic) - Ch. 160

[vagligeiro]

What "nonsense Murata wrote" are you referring to?

Do you mean the manga version of OPM? Or something that Murata said himself?

https://fandomwire.com/opm-mangaka-...l-comments-on-pakistani-immigrants-explained/ "How Yusuke Murata’s X Post Ignited a Racism Controversy"

This was debunked like 4 years ago bud keep up. ONE admitted that he lets murata do what he wants.

Yeah!

ONE/Murata 2015 Joint Interview - https://onepunchman.fandom.com/wiki/Interviews​

--How do you two work together during the writing process? Does ONE-sensei create new storyboards?

Murata: With the main storyline or anything else where I’m going off of ONE-sensei’s original, I’m generally given free reign with page distribution and whatnot. But I’ll ask ONE-sensei if I have any questions.

ONE: That’s right.

Murata: For the main storyline, the dialogue stays pretty much the same. But with side-stories, sometimes I’ll try adding in scenes to ONE-sensei’s storyboards, or change the dialogue up a bit. In such cases, I’ll always ask ONE-sensei’s opinion. We’ll go back and forth fine-tuning it…and sometimes it’ll just end up reverting back to how it was in the beginning (laughs).

-----------------

The Monster Arc and the Garou Arc underwent significant story restructuring precisely because of the side stories created by Murata. I honestly don't know if Blast's introduction in the arc was Murata's idea or ONE's, but given how it played out—and the fact that we seemed stuck in a "loop" for about two years—I'm pretty sure it was Murata's idea.

To me, Blast was always a "wild card" character in the webcomic; he hadn't been revealed up to that point for that very reason—if Saitama was the embodiment of an "overpowered cheat character," Blast was the series' "Konami Code," meant to appear only in truly absurd situations.

"But the Garou Arc was pretty absurd"... sure, but I don't think it reached the level where Blast needed to step in. In the webcomic, Saitama resolves everything, and there is no "reset."

 

[Scytale]

https://fandomwire.com/opm-mangaka-...l-comments-on-pakistani-immigrants-explained/ "How Yusuke Murata’s X Post Ignited a Racism Controversy"

Yeah!

ONE/Murata 2015 Joint Interview - https://onepunchman.fandom.com/wiki/Interviews​

--How do you two work together during the writing process? Does ONE-sensei create new storyboards?

Murata: With the main storyline or anything else where I’m going off of ONE-sensei’s original, I’m generally given free reign with page distribution and whatnot. But I’ll ask ONE-sensei if I have any questions.

ONE: That’s right.

Murata: For the main storyline, the dialogue stays pretty much the same. But with side-stories, sometimes I’ll try adding in scenes to ONE-sensei’s storyboards, or change the dialogue up a bit. In such cases, I’ll always ask ONE-sensei’s opinion. We’ll go back and forth fine-tuning it…and sometimes it’ll just end up reverting back to how it was in the beginning (laughs).

-----------------

The Monster Arc and the Garou Arc underwent significant story restructuring precisely because of the side stories created by Murata. I honestly don't know if Blast's introduction in the arc was Murata's idea or ONE's, but given how it played out—and the fact that we seemed stuck in a "loop" for about two years—I'm pretty sure it was Murata's idea.

To me, Blast was always a "wild card" character in the webcomic; he hadn't been revealed up to that point for that very reason—if Saitama was the embodiment of an "overpowered cheat character," Blast was the series' "Konami Code," meant to appear only in truly absurd situations.

"But the Garou Arc was pretty absurd"... sure, but I don't think it reached the level where Blast needed to step in. In the webcomic, Saitama resolves everything, and there is no "reset."

Damn, that's so out of pocket. I don't know why the fuck the guy would get mixed into something like that, especially on his official account as a high-profile artist.

Him apparently regularly communicating with right-leaning Japanese groups online is concerning too, especially considering how gung-ho about "racial purity" Japanese narratives tend to be... But that's a whole can of worms.

And yeah, I too am willing to believe that the baffling direction and countless rewrites that the manga has been plagued with are Murata's doing, given how the tone and dynamic are such a stark, meaningless shift from OPM's core themes and tropes.

 

[holyjay]

Damn... What am I going to do with my life now while waiting for the next chapter?...

 

[chucke1992]

So many enemies and we still don't know what that god is that gave powers to the Homeless Emperor.

 

[Dargkkast]

this doesn't make much sense, nothing ONE has written before was that bad and than cliched, unless one is trolling on purpose in OPM manga. In that case he's doing it perfectly

you think ONE doesn't use a ton of clichés? What I think is that either the editor tells them to change story stuff (not weird in other manga) or ONE and Murata have some reason they haven't told just yet, maybe there was some kind of miscommunication once and that resulted in a new storyline that they're not sure how to close.

 

[AAA1]

you think ONE doesn't use a ton of clichés? What I think is that either the editor tells them to change story stuff (not weird in other manga) or ONE and Murata have some reason they haven't told just yet, maybe there was some kind of miscommunication once and that resulted in a new storyline that they're not sure how to close.

Of course there is miscommunication. Too much actually. Whatever it is, it's begin when murata think that was a good idea. I don't want to blame murata that much since people make mistakes and i've seen countless times other authors make mistakes too. Just don't be denial about it. People can voice their disappointment as long as it's not mixed with headcannon or lies just like death battle enjoyer or shipper do.

Is there hope murata can fix his mess? Well i still read what he make. His version only feels inferior plotwise but not to the point i got multiple big disappointments when i read naruto shippuden when they still ongoing. It's unfair to say he is got no talent in writing stories too. Eyeshield 21 is a good series or that one actually not purely made by murata after all?

 

[Gregorein]

Lads. It’s a manga. Sure, we can mourn the drop of quality, but it’s no reason to go into hypothetical whatnots of politics and shit.

 

[yinkyo]

genos being a pika pika mode was really prophesied from a good amount of time ago, but seeing it's awakening feels really cool...the last upgrade from Kuseno. Let see how far this teacher student sparring goes

 

[Claith]

The only powerhouse in this chapter was the translator. Forget the combat, Genos' ramblings did the most damage.

 

[Dargkkast]

Is there hope murata can fix his mess? Well i still read what he make. His version only feels inferior plotwise but not to the point i got multiple big disappointments when i read naruto shippuden when they still ongoing. It's unfair to say he is got no talent in writing stories too.

Yeah I agree, he still can fix it.

 

[Mineta_The_Grapist]

😭😭😭😭

 

[NorwegianJap]

So many ignorant haters here have no idea that Murata does none of the writing on the manga, ONE has been writing all of it. Murata only does the artwork, and ONE sends him the concept part and panelling where Murata makes it pretty.

ONE is simultaneously working on both the manga and webcomic at the same. Whenever the updates on one slows down, generally it means the other one is getting the focus.

Murata at best makes suggestions to ONE who then decides to include it or not.

This isn't your echo chamber r/onepunchman. You must be an ABSOLUTE FUCKING MORON to think Murata is not to blame for this. Do you think it's fucking ONE telling him to redraw over and over again when that is none existant in all his other works? Or the fact that the writing style is absolutely nothing like ONE's previous works but exactly like Murata's in his previous failed works? Or the fact that we have not had a confirmed storyboard from ONE in almost a decade? Or the fact we have countless evidence of the opposite, like when Murata went out on twitter and stated how he redraw ONE's 12 pages storyboard of Phoenix Man vs Child Emperor 3 times and the final time it was +100 pages nothing at all like the storyboard?

Jesus, are you COMPLETELY unable to think a little for yourself?

 

[deepcom]

Why are you people even arguing about who's writing what in the Murata manga and original vision and whatnot? They're just clearly two different things and a 1-to-1 conversion of OPM would in any case be excruciatingly boring. ONE's OPM is an gag manga; the simplistic art style is part of the point. I wouldn't want a "good" redraw of some 4-koma either.

Murata's manga is an action cape comic that spawned from it, kind of how it Invincible supposedly started out as a joke before taking itself too seriously (I've never read/watched it). You're angry about Murata inserting some grand plot beyond Saitama punching a guy? Buddy, that's the very reason that manga exists. Enjoy each for what it is, or don't (I've not kept up with the Murata manga for over a year now).

 

[Dargkkast]

If you are reading both stories and truly believe they are made by the same person, then I'm afraid you are the retarded one.

Don't use that word.

 

[Dargkkast]

Why are you people even arguing about who's writing what in the Murata manga and original vision and whatnot? They're just clearly two different things and a 1-to-1 conversion of OPM would in any case be excruciatingly boring. ONE's OPM is an gag manga; the simplistic art style is part of the point. I wouldn't want a "good" redraw of some 4-koma either.

Murata's manga is an action cape comic that spawned from it, kind of how it Invincible supposedly started out as a joke before taking itself too seriously (I've never read/watched it). You're angry about Murata inserting some grand plot beyond Saitama punching a guy? Buddy, that's the very reason that manga exists. Enjoy each for what it is, or don't (I've not kept up with the Murata manga for over a year now).

People love obsessing over everything and then turning their brain off.

If some of you don't like the manga anymore, that's ok. It's not like the webcomic doesn't exist. Also, it doesn't matter who is the guy making the manga, there's no reset button that will fix it. But you all (supposedly) like the webcomic already, so what are you all complaining about?

 

[manga_follow_75743857]

Thank you for the release
Miquizli, Mrzardark, Currency.

Since Genos final stand against the Machine God is done off screen, Saitama take on Talk No Jutsu will probably be just a punch. The story has reach the point where Kuseno is just a prop for Dr. Bofoi, Child Emperor and Genos.

Bleach, Yu Yu Hakusho, Eyeshield 21, Naruto > Naruto Shippuden > Boruto, Dragon ball Z > Dragon ball Super. The series change despite the author is writing them. We could end up way worse where the author never stop delaying the plot like Detective Conan...

 

[jarjaxle]

Well....Genos vs Saitama Round 2...until Genos is saved at least