Osananajimi Kanojo no Morahara ga Hidoin de Zetsuen Sengen shite Yatta - Vol. 5 Ch. 45

[jojoka]

They gonna ruin my favourite character by making hanabi good now aren't they

 

[henman]

Welp, yeah I'll put the Manga on hold...for the third time.

Do you do it monthly? Weekly?

 

[favine]

what is this plot line

 

[Carcer]

People just don't care about her atonement and what kind of help can you even receive from an abusive sociopath? Best thing they can do is to stay away from you for life.

The thing is, it finally got through to her at the end of the camping trip how awful she had been and began some real introspection when we last saw her in her room. She was utterly depressed and had even contemplated suicide.

 

[Kaito57]

Oh no ! Trash blackmailing Trash !! I'm so invested in this... NOT !!!

 

[darkesword]

Seems like a good time to drop. The original premise of the manga (a guy finally breaking out of an abusive relationship) was interesting. This weird dumb blackmail plot is bad.

 

[Septazia]

Do you do it monthly? Weekly?

I stopped when the bullying was taking too long and again when the story kept throwing obstacles at the romance to make the protagonist the magnet for crazy girls.

 

[KanchouM]

Fix...

 

[Joirish1495]

The sad thing is, the dumbass who was tortured by her his entire life will end up saving her. God forbid an author be able to write a character with resentment properly

 

[Graywing]

MC will definitely help her. I may not like her but I damn sure don't want to see her forced into prostitution. She doesn't deserve that. Thanks for the chapter!!!

 

[LeonsamaX]

I was wondering what was gonna be different from the novel but all we get is a generic blackmail from a one dimensional fuckboi. She's just gonna be forgiven because "well she went through a tough time and MC saved her.

 

[ENCORAAAAAAAAA]

I find it funny how this guy started as a generic NTR fuckboy and then degenerated into a psycho.

Bro sped ran the alpha male pipeline

 

[SuperQ]

Everyone's talking about how dumb this development is, I'm just impressed Hanabi was able to heal completely from twisting her goddamn foot around backwards in just a month

 

[WalkingTargetPractice]

Is this dude seriously trying to get a teenage girl to prostitute herself? The hells wrong with this freak?
Hanabi may have been a bitch, but no one deserves that

 

[henman]

I stopped when the bullying was taking too long and again when the story kept throwing obstacles at the romance to make the protagonist the magnet for crazy girls.

Hahaha, you can drop it even more often, you know?

 

[zacthemanwhohasseenitall]

It's a little bit funny having already read the light novel and know what's gonna happen, but I think I won't spoil everything, just a few things and only if everyone wants... This is just a test, I won't reveal almost nothing for respect to everyone, only just a few things

 

[jwl092]

The Hanabi was written means that she doesn’t really deserve a redemption arc but I wouldn’t have minded it if the way it was written was actually decent. This chapter has destroyed any chance of it being decent though. Making her a victim who needs saving by the MMC or FMC essentially ruins any chance she has of being an interesting character since she won’t be redeemed through her own actions.

 

[Novis]

manga authors have an obsession with letting abusers off the hook for some reason. is there actually something about japanese society that makes them think they have to include it, or do they think it makes for good storytelling...?
they even do it when there isn't an irl get-out-of-jail-free card in play like being rich or a woman

Japanese society? I see this all the time in American stories too. Let's not make it a Japanese cultural thing, it's just a thing humans like to try to do in their stories and it usually sucks. It's a bad way to think about victims and their responsibilities towards their abusers. It's also a way to show the protag is always in the right and takes the high ground no matter what when they shouldn't have to.
I do think everyone should have a second chance but unless the abuser is making amends towards their victim, the victim has no obligations to forgive or forget. victims also shouldn't HAVE to see their abuser just because the abuser can't handle themselves in life without the victims. This is a problem I had earlier in the manga and I was hoping it was going to be a one-off thing but... I guess this is just how this story is. Ugh.

 

[Novis]

Am I the only one that wants to see Hanabi's redemption arc? After all, she can't atone and help our boy out if she's just wasting away as a hikikomori.

I think it's okay for a story to explore someone that did terrible things and has to make amends or decides to do better. Everyone does deserve second chances. HOWEVER the story isn't about the abuser, it's about the victim and how he's trying to move on with his life and help his friends and strengthen his support structure. And we're not seeing the abuser trying to do better because she wants to, we're going to see it because she's ALSO getting abused and the protag(s) are going to have to swoop in and save her, even though she's the reason things got so rocky in the first place. Victims shouldn't have to keep facing their abuser, victims should be allowed to just walk the fuck away. This is where I'm having the biggest issue. And it's not just this story, it's so many stories like this that I also have issues with. The protag is SUCH a bastion of morality and goodness that they have to solve everyone's problem and no one really has agency in their own lives, even when things go terribly. It's frustrating.

 

[Insignis]

Can we go back to cute fluffy romance? I don't give a single fuck for this asshole, for Hanabi, for that other girl from part-time job place, nor for that NTRap girl who fucks with MC best friend. If you can't not draw this drama BS, then at least make a side manga about only MC and glasses wearing cutie-pie.