Piano Duo for the Left Hand

Group Leader
Joined
Mar 8, 2018
Messages
1,980
The first chapter definitely... surprised me
The story's got me interested, the art is really neat too
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Aug 25, 2018
Messages
534
Holy shet, I was not expecting that.
This has potential, I wish someone would pick this up
 
Joined
Oct 27, 2019
Messages
3
Why the fuck any decent musical manga have a plot like this???????

HEROINE IS DEAD!

Fuck i won't read this shit anymore.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 28, 2019
Messages
344
during world war one there was this pianist who lost his right hand and went around commissioning composers to write pieces for the left hand. listen to ravel's piano concerto for the left hand even tho it's only played with one hand the music it produces sounds so full and layered. heartfelt pieces can still be played even with one hand, all you need is a good composer

(perhaps akari's dad can dedicate himself to composing such pieces for his daughter)
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 2, 2018
Messages
567
Feels so contrived and artificial. Tries so overly hard in the beginning to make the mc seem like a "badass" that it comes off as lame. As is typical of manga, the pacing is incredibly rushed. Forcing too much into the first chapter to try to grab readers just results in tonal whiplash and kills any emotional impact because you don't have time to get attached. The dark and light hearted elements do not mix well, instead undercutting each other. As usual, none of the characters act like actual human beings.

The girl's death via getting hit by a truck when not paying attention is so clichéd at this point it's a complete joke.

All in all a very amateurish attempt from a first time mangaka.
 
Joined
Jan 17, 2021
Messages
26
I dont know why people call this trash. But its a master piece to me. Its just happen that incident seems so dumb and rushed. But this one has a good development for main character. Its not that he is a badass or something. We can find so many people like that even in real life because of influence in their bad environment. Dont have a goal and dream. No motivation. Just going by the flow. Some are acting though like hot shit. Some are bullying or become trash. And etc. Its pretty much of realistic . And Accident like that (you know what i mean not going to spoil) pretty much possible but what happen after is excluded. Its for the plot and a fantasy after all. But the way of the mc just got motivated by a girl. Searching what he will like and a goal in his teens. Doing what he can and wants for the first time. Its enjoyable. For me i want to see how will he develop and grown. You guys are just cant handle the accident . Well its so dumb but really.. dont even get the point of the story. The title there is already pretty much obvious giving you a hint something like this going to happen. Thats why its called like that in the first place. Wth
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top