[Rejected] Return Pornographic rating tag.

[Kendrakirai]

I don't know I'd anyone else is seeing these, but "Pornographic" has been made "Mature" - possibly for the ads? But "Mature" feels like it's a lower rating than "Erotica", when it's very not.

 

[UnnamedPlayer]

Or just name thing 16+, 18+ and so on. Won't work in all countries, i know...

 

[Angry_Panda]

Make it interesting: "The Whole Enchilada".

 

[Mangamoz]

Oh wait, is cursing gonna get banned in the comments cause of the ads like other sites do?

Do I have to start writing in weird youtube talk now?

Man that would be fogged up.

 

[Garett]

In this world, there are only potato or not potato.

 

[Angry_Panda]

In this world, there are only potato or not potato.

Time to do some culture yamming.

 

[Manko-sensei]

Let's return to the V3 and use "hentai", "smut" and "ecchi". English is too inaccurate for categorising anything.

 

[JVick]

Is it to hide the smut from the EU before the end of the year ?

 

[Koneko_Nyaa]

Is it to hide the smut from the EU before the end of the year ?

What about the USA?

I already live in a state where the law requires age verification for internet pornography. Legal XXX sites either require proof of ID, or are unavailable in my area.

I haven't read the full text of the regulation in detail, but if hentai is considered porn, MangaDex could be in legal trouble for serving it to people in my state without checking IDs.

Maybe this is legal pandering for the USA: "It's not pornography, it's mature art."
...but will the judge buy it?

Personally, I agree that "pornography" is a more accurate classification than "mature".

 

[Manko-sensei]

The difference in the end is the artistic value (pornography vs erotica), but that's not anything new.

 

[JVick]

What about the USA?

I already live in a state where the law requires age verification for internet pornography. Legal XXX sites either require proof of ID, or are unavailable in my area.

I haven't read the full text of the regulation in detail, but if hentai is considered porn, MangaDex could be in legal trouble for serving it to people in my state without checking IDs.

Maybe this is legal pandering for the USA: "It's not pornography, it's mature art."
...but will the judge buy it?

Personally, I agree that "pornography" is a more accurate classification than "mature".

Since the scope of this ID verification is for 'Adult contents' as a whole (be it for porn, politics, violent content or even medical matters), the distinction won't matter much. The moment MD receives the email from the UK/EU is the moment we're cooked.

 

[panzerkampfwagyu]

So, I looked through oneshots for the purpose of the contest before and I gotta say, yeah, Mature doesn't really convey it being R18 content.
Like, it comes over as way too tame, which made it harder to instantly disqualify them from the search.
The term should be more explicit.

 

[Drakun_Auger]

I vote to rename it to Lé Spicŷ to trick them so our Pr0n won't be banned

 

[panzerkampfwagyu]

I vote to rename it to Lé Spicŷ to trick them so our Pr0n won't be banned

Would actually be pretty good, only sufferers would be the fans of cooking Mangas, a sacrifice I'm willing to make

 

[Manko-sensei]

Naming things always have issues, some people label Shokugeki no Souma as "food porn" and others as "porn food", who's right and who's wrong here?

 

[panzerkampfwagyu]

Naming things always have issues, some people label Shokugeki no Souma as "food porn" and others as "porn food", who's right and who's wrong here?

I mean, the first one? The second one doesn't really make sense at all

 

[Manko-sensei]

I mean, the first one? The second one doesn't really make sense at all

Ah, how innocent...

 

[booterror]

Oh wait, is cursing gonna get banned in the comments cause of the ads like other sites do?

Do I have to start writing in weird youtube talk now?

Man that would be fogged up.

Late to the thread but the thought of that makes me wanna unalive if we cant say things like Corvid nineteen, sewerslide, [ FILTERED ] or ***holes anymore.