Stravaganza ~ Isai no Hime ~ - Vol. 5 Ch. 29 - United Interspecies Front
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
@kwendy The queen is extremely stupid regardless, yelling at and berating her allies while not being of any use herself. Even in the case that her stupid idea works, that isn't to say a different method wouldn't have been much superior. Also, this is a fictional story so the author can make any dumb idea work if he wants to. That doesn't make a stupid idea not stupid, it just makes the story terrible.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 28, 2018
- Messages
- 4,841
@Gabagu Why though? For conveying her thoughts? So being smart is just to shut up and don't interfere?
And no, "maybe" and "if" are not exactly primary factors to consider. What worked worked, what will work - will work regardless.
And here we came to wonderful word of context. If in context of a story she will do good - then she will do good. But you claim it stupid before anything even started.
And no, "maybe" and "if" are not exactly primary factors to consider. What worked worked, what will work - will work regardless.
And here we came to wonderful word of context. If in context of a story she will do good - then she will do good. But you claim it stupid before anything even started.
@kwendy For conveying her thoughts? Wtf are you talking about? No one said saying something is dumb, what she said itself is dumb, the thoughts themselves are ridiculously dumb. Calling her allies fools in the middle of battle and making enemies with her own allies is dumb. No one forced her to insult her own allies, she could have been more tactful in proposing a plan instead of being a stupid drama queen drawing attention to herself and shitting all over her allies.
There is no 'worked' or 'will work', this is a fictional story. It's made up. It's not real. Anything can work and if you say that it isn't stupid you're the idiot. I could make up a story of smearing poop all over your face and say it worked at convincing you what you've said is stupid so in the context of the story it's smart. But, it's not real, it's imagined. There is no worked worked, will work will work, it's a stupid idea regardless of whether that makes you realize your stupidity in the story because any dumb idea can be forcefully made to work with faulty logic in an imaginary story.
Forget about the future, what she has already done is already incredibly stupid. I'm tired of trying to explain basic logic to you. I don't know if there's something in your water but you need help if you're having trouble with something this simple.
There is no 'worked' or 'will work', this is a fictional story. It's made up. It's not real. Anything can work and if you say that it isn't stupid you're the idiot. I could make up a story of smearing poop all over your face and say it worked at convincing you what you've said is stupid so in the context of the story it's smart. But, it's not real, it's imagined. There is no worked worked, will work will work, it's a stupid idea regardless of whether that makes you realize your stupidity in the story because any dumb idea can be forcefully made to work with faulty logic in an imaginary story.
Forget about the future, what she has already done is already incredibly stupid. I'm tired of trying to explain basic logic to you. I don't know if there's something in your water but you need help if you're having trouble with something this simple.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 28, 2018
- Messages
- 4,841
@Gabagu Why are you so insistent that line of thought not aligning with one of your own is stupid by the way? She has things she can and cannot do, she insists on using her assets as she deems fit and she using words to influence her surrounding. Down to basic structure, why is she stupid?
And there is part I written ad you missed. I'll highlight it for you: CONTEXT. If logic of that world will allow it then so be it, it might define the world, but it won't define certain character or action just because some other perspective regards it as irrational.
And lastly, in this chapter she yet to do anything, she just negotiated (and siccessfully to boot) the possibility of taking action.
And there is part I written ad you missed. I'll highlight it for you: CONTEXT. If logic of that world will allow it then so be it, it might define the world, but it won't define certain character or action just because some other perspective regards it as irrational.
And lastly, in this chapter she yet to do anything, she just negotiated (and siccessfully to boot) the possibility of taking action.
@kwendy
She is stupid because she chose to weaken and undermine her allies without considering the repercussions of her actions. She created division, sowing discord in a highly tense atmosphere where people are fighting with their lives on the line and she called them all stupid, offending her own allies. She could have instead collaborated with her allies to come up with an alternate plan, but she didn't. All she did was go on an emotional tirade, calling that a successful negotiation is a blatant lie.
Are you having difficulty with reading comprehension or something because you don't seem to have understood a single thing that was said. Give me some sort of sign you at least have the capacity of understanding what is being said. Can you repeat for me the reason I told you why I consider her stupid? Because at this point you just seem mentally impaired and seem to skip past everything I say without engaging with any points that I've made.
I described to you actions of hers that have had negative consequences and told you positive alternative actions she could have taken instead, which shows why she is stupid. I'm repeating this just in case you still have difficulty understanding and I want for you to repeat it and demonstrate to me you are capable of rational thought.
She is stupid because she chose to weaken and undermine her allies without considering the repercussions of her actions. She created division, sowing discord in a highly tense atmosphere where people are fighting with their lives on the line and she called them all stupid, offending her own allies. She could have instead collaborated with her allies to come up with an alternate plan, but she didn't. All she did was go on an emotional tirade, calling that a successful negotiation is a blatant lie.
Are you having difficulty with reading comprehension or something because you don't seem to have understood a single thing that was said. Give me some sort of sign you at least have the capacity of understanding what is being said. Can you repeat for me the reason I told you why I consider her stupid? Because at this point you just seem mentally impaired and seem to skip past everything I say without engaging with any points that I've made.
I described to you actions of hers that have had negative consequences and told you positive alternative actions she could have taken instead, which shows why she is stupid. I'm repeating this just in case you still have difficulty understanding and I want for you to repeat it and demonstrate to me you are capable of rational thought.
Similar threads
