Taikoku Cheat nara Isekai Seifuku mo Rakushou desu yo?

[DizzyMiko]

@ThisMe Because first. Impressions. Matter. Now, I do understand where you're coming from, and typically try to rate at least through a first book, but if this is brand new, with nothing to go on for a week, 2 weeks, or even a month, then yes, this initial rating being so low is pretty indicative of how people generally feel about this. I get shit for giving novels a low score after reading through the first book, not impressed with it as it is, and telling it how it is as I see it from the impression as a first time reader, even though there are more books in the series. I'm not gonna waste my goddamn time on a shitty piece of work. I'm not a "professional" reviewer. I do this for fun, and if my general insight can save people time and headache, then I'm doing pretty decent as a reader. (As a side note, it is hilarious watching people get fucking butthurt as I tear into their "beloved" series', breaking down why I hate it, and then people say that "I need to get further into the story before it gets good." That's an incredibly poor excuse, especially for someone who just reads for fun, and tends to write rather lengthy reviews on things.)

Though I MUCH prefer written reviews to reviews with scores. You get far more information out of a written review (that's actually half-way thought out) and you can get the feel of something that way.

 

[hazzack]

whoa 5
can it go even lower

 

[mrmm]

Yyyyyyyyep.

Here we go again

 

[ThisMe]

@xyzzy @DizzyMiko
I honestly agree that first impressions do matter a lot, nobody would want to read a story that doesn't pique one's interest. Though I also think that some stories just need some build up to actually be interesting, especially in the isekai genre where there is just so much material that it becomes hard to differentiate the story from others and sometimes one chapter is just not enough.

But I don't think this is one of them as I do also believe that many authors sugarcoat a bad story with fan service or straight up softcore porn and the first chapter has shown enough of it.

In the end, I still think that ratings should reflect the story and with only one single chapter with 30 pages, it's hard to convey a long term story.

 

[Anish_Agarwal]

 

[black1210]

a 90s isekai manga

 

[RandomPasserby]

@ThisMe Usually, first chapters are made to make you hype, but this one was confusing, didn't showed anything new or interesting and the girls design are so generic that they are boring. Even worst, they wasted many pages in that screaming soldier. So, yeah! This tomato is rotten probably all the salad is as well.

 

[whoamiagain]

oh my god I thought people were exaggerating

 

[hazzack]

whoa four

 

[NickieTheFool]

lmao that yep in the title just makes the description so much better

 

[neatio1]

There's also a similar one where its the funniest shit i've ever seen.

The scientist reincarnate and turn into a pickle.

Guess what he was called...


pickle rick.

funniest shit i've seen so far.

 

[Silwith]

This is so bad, i need to follow it

 

[monkey123]

isekai? cheat? rating under 5? Must be a trap.

Fuck! I wish https://mangadex.org/title/22909/guild-no-cheat-na-uketsukejou would get updates.

 

[LordoftheKeep]

if the room were a manga

 

[czarisyn]

@LordoftheKeep I did not hit her, its not true, its not....oh Hi Mark

 

[crunchyspider]

Reads like a fanboy's rewrite of some other manga. So bad.

 

[nellic]

this isn't very good
pretty nice summary though

 

[icam98]

I haven't even read it and it looks generic. And the way summary was written mustve shown the everything it had to offer

 

[Warilized]

This is unreadable lmao

 

[GrimThoughts]

Lmao, this manga is comically bad. There is nothing here except for ironic entertainment in laughing at the author’s incompetency