Tensei Shitara Joban de Shinu Chuu-Boss datta: Heroine Kenzokuka de Ikinokoru - Vol. 6 Ch. 16

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
1,587
I had a look and yes, you're right one or other is tagged as oppai loli, but vast majority seemingly isn't since she's an adult and is meant to look like one

Entire point of loli is not being small, but looking young, it's why for example Uzaki is not considered a oppai loli while Tatsumaki is considered a loli, they're intended to look a certain age, virtually all adult characters who are meant to look like a loli are in-universe said to look younger then they are and sometimes that's even a recurring gag because people think they're a child

Loli definition changed slightly over time because there's more adult characters who look young but even then there's always the same consistency, they look younger than their actual age rather than just being short

Just being small is not enough
That you mentioned Uzaki is kinda a surprise to me since she has that tag far more often (probably because she has 275 times the art :p )and the creator even admitted he wanted to draw a "Legal Oppai Loli" with her being the result. Actually thinking about it she probably is the better example but I think Shiori is cuter so she came to mind first. I think she even fits better in context to what you said as she has a notable more round face than for example her Mom which makes her look much younger.
Fun Fact. The Author of my other example mentioned the same but it's a small note on the fanbox which they stopped updating. I'm not subscribed anymore or I could make a screenshot.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 25, 2020
Messages
2,495
That you mentioned Uzaki is kinda a surprise to me since she has that tag far more often (probably because she has 275 times the art :p )and the creator even admitted he wanted to draw a "Legal Oppai Loli" with her being the result. Actually thinking about it she probably is the better example but I think Shiori is cuter so she came to mind first. I think she even fits better in context to what you said as she has a notable more round face than for example her Mom which makes her look much younger.
Fun Fact. The Author of my other example mentioned the same but it's a small note on the fanbox which they stopped updating. I'm not subscribed anymore or I could make a screenshot.
And yet he didn't drew her a loli nor vast majority see her as such lol, for some perspective from pixiv totals:

宇崎花 - Hana Uzaki - 8.108 images
+ ロリ巨乳 which is the main Oppai Loli tag - 278 images

And that is counting both safe and nsfw, basically only 3,42% of all pics

Vast majority of people just don't her as a loli in any way, I think a possible better example of that is Hestia from Is It Wrong to Try to Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon?, pretty sure a lot of artists go out of their way to draw her even younger looking than she already is, though I didn't look at her numbers lol
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
1,587
And yet he didn't drew her a loli nor vast majority see her as such lol, for some perspective from pixiv totals:

宇崎花 - Hana Uzaki - 8.108 images
+ ロリ巨乳 which is the main Oppai Loli tag - 278 images

And that is counting both safe and nsfw, basically only 3,42% of all pics

Vast majority of people just don't her as a loli in any way, I think a possible better example of that is Hestia from Is It Wrong to Try to Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon?, pretty sure a lot of artists go out of their way to draw her even younger looking than she already is, though I didn't look at her numbers lol
Hestia definitely is one. She even gets called one in story. But yeah I guess we have a difference of what the Author wanted and what people see here. Of note the Tags on Pixiv get set by the poster and not the community so if they didn't want the Tags they won't appear. Like Shiori from my first example often only has her Name and the Show as tag, even on the NSFW Images, not even the "Large breast" one for some reason (and I doubt anybody would argue she has a nice set!).

Side note, I reread the Story because I admit I forgot most of it and it seems funny enough our cute Cat Girl maid (and the Demon kings daughter) is at least considered a Loli instory. During the Demon King Meeting our MC got a rep as a "lolicon" due to her. Frankly it doesn't help that the artist is really bad at keeping height consistent. In some scenes Arnold is just roughly a head bigger than the Elf with Alice around 2-3 heads smaller and in others the Elf suddenly shrinks to nearly Alice size and our Catgirl barely goes over his waist.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 25, 2020
Messages
2,495
Hestia definitely is one. She even gets called one in story. But yeah I guess we have a difference of what the Author wanted and what people see here. Of note the Tags on Pixiv get set by the poster and not the community so if they didn't want the Tags they won't appear. Like Shiori from my first example often only has her Name and the Show as tag, even on the NSFW Images, not even the "Large breast" one for some reason (and I doubt anybody would argue she has a nice set!).

Side note, I reread the Story because I admit I forgot most of it and it seems funny enough our cute Cat Girl maid (and the Demon kings daughter) is at least considered a Loli instory. During the Demon King Meeting our MC got a rep as a "lolicon" due to her. Frankly it doesn't help that the artist is really bad at keeping height consistent. In some scenes Arnold is just roughly a head bigger than the Elf with Alice around 2-3 heads smaller and in others the Elf suddenly shrinks to nearly Alice size and our Catgirl barely goes over his waist.
Thing is that some tags are redundant, if the character has large breasts by default there's no reason to add it, it's easier to add when they're draw different, like loli if they're drawn younger

It seems that large breast tag and its variants are more consistently used either when character is drawn bigger or when it's original character, when it's fanart it's not as consistent, you're more likely to find a breast tag related to a specific fetish instead, loli meanwhile seems to be more consistently used cause it's like 99% of the time a main fetish while large breasts would be just a description of the character rather than the fetish in that particular pic

Tatsumaki is a good example of what I mean, a lot of her art doesn't have loli tag but she's clearly drawn a lot more shapely than she really is so the tag doesn't fit, she's one of those rare characters that are basically a loli and even mistaken for younger in-univese but artists drawn her looking older and bigger lol

I think that's main issue and even ignoring height inconsistency he's still freakishly tall so any short girl looks smaller close to him, I felt that the slime girl is closer to being a loli than the cat maid, and due to artist sucking at height new girl is basically toddler sized :v
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
1,587
Yeeeah the Sister definitely feels ...off. She seems nearly half the height of the other Girls in the party and while these aren't shorties they aren't notable large either. If they told us she is actually the classic Anime dwarf I would believe it without a doubt yet she is supposed to be the sister of the Hot mage girl who from the Harem members so far is the closest to Arnold's height
But we are overthinking a soft porn isekai story so maybe we should just roll with it.

On a note on Arnold I went through the Raws and if I start comparing I think he is not some "towering giant" but he do seems to be around 2 metres or 6-7 feet tall so definitely large ... but then again the Author and height stuff so ... yeah :p
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top