Tensei Shitara Suterareta ga, Hirowarete Tanoshiku Ikiteimasu - Vol. 3 Ch. 17

[Kireato]

I cannot see at all how the parents shown in the first chapter match the apparent description of the priest and his late wife.

It seems to me that the priest's child truly passed away but that this is a setup for adoption into nobility; the prince will continue investigating her and find out that she indeed is an abandoned child of nobility, who may even be related just not via the priest's late wife, and the priest may adopt her as he has no heir and is free to take her in.

I doubt Millie will leave her current family though. The priest is just a stranger to her and there's no opportunity to built up any affection so adoption, if it does happen, would purely be on paper in order to bring back noble blood into the fold (since she has blonde hair and strong magic powers which are evidence of her noble heritage).

Technically, the father said take the baby to a church. And the maid interpreted that as leave the kid in the middle of a graveyard in winter. I don’t think he was actually trying to kill her.

I mean, the instructions given were "Take her to the church or something", then on the next page, the maid appears to be recalling additional instructions: "We can't let the Nazath merchant guild find out" (which is incredibly strange and specific, and the merchant guild we're introduced to later is "east district") and "Don't let anyone see you". I'm not sure how you can accomplish that without leaving her outside, and that means her fate is likely death.

I'd say the instructions were designed to get rid of her permanently, while avoiding taking any responsibility.

Of course, the maid actually obeyed those commands. I wonder what would have happened if she hadn't? Child gets raised in an orphanage, has blonde hair, church has ties with nobility (see priest) and investigates, parents eventually get suspected because you can't exactly hide 9 months of pregnancy and there can't be too many from around with the exact circumstances. All of this makes me think it to be very unlikely the father actually wanted the baby to ba taken care of by the church.

 

[Kireato]

Based off what we see she probably did cheat on him with the priest. Though I'm not certain.

The priest was happily married, then when he lost his wife and child, he became a priest (which I assume means celibacy). It seems strange for that sort of man to cheat with another woman.

 

[kirby_422]

that’s the entire premise of FFF-Trashero. MC is so disgusted by a fantasy world without flushing toilets and all the typical tropes involved in a fantasy world then he goes a little bit insane

Wasn't it more of people forcing absolute bullshit on him; taking him from his family against his will, calling him morally bankrupt for merely letting psychopaths die on their own, etc. than conveniences? Being forcibly separated from his family becomes a bigger thing as time goes on (whether he truly means it or its just to try to convince them to let him go)

 

[Banana_Splits]

had to reread chapter one again and i forgot she colored her hair

 

[Kinkaiser]

I cannot see at all how the parents shown in the first chapter match the apparent description of the priest and his late wife.

It seems to me that the priest's child truly passed away but that this is a setup for adoption into nobility; the prince will continue investigating her and find out that she indeed is an abandoned child of nobility, who may even be related just not via the priest's late wife, and the priest may adopt her as he has no heir and is free to take her in.

I doubt Millie will leave her current family though. The priest is just a stranger to her and there's no opportunity to built up any affection so adoption, if it does happen, would purely be on paper in order to bring back noble blood into the fold (since she has blonde hair and strong magic powers which are evidence of her noble heritage).


I mean, the instructions given were "Take her to the church or something", then on the next page, the maid appears to be recalling additional instructions: "We can't let the Nazath merchant guild find out" (which is incredibly strange and specific, and the merchant guild we're introduced to later is "east district") and "Don't let anyone see you". I'm not sure how you can accomplish that without leaving her outside, and that means her fate is likely death.

I'd say the instructions were designed to get rid of her permanently, while avoiding taking any responsibility.

Of course, the maid actually obeyed those commands. I wonder what would have happened if she hadn't? Child gets raised in an orphanage, has blonde hair, church has ties with nobility (see priest) and investigates, parents eventually get suspected because you can't exactly hide 9 months of pregnancy and there can't be too many from around with the exact circumstances. All of this makes me think it to be very unlikely the father actually wanted the baby to ba taken care of by the church.

I feel like knocking on the door of the church, and running away before someone begins to open the door (the thing that is shown in every media about leaving a baby with the church I have ever seen) would fulfill the requirements much more closely than dumping her in a graveyard for some reason. And he thought she was bald, not blond, so he wouldn't have expected her to be tied to him later.

 

[windfang]

ugh I hate it when I have so many question right now but remember the web novel is version already removed

 

[14Darius28]

The priest was happily married, then when he lost his wife and child, he became a priest (which I assume means celibacy). It seems strange for that sort of man to cheat with another woman.

No that's not what the chapter said. The chapter said that she got married to a vassal. It never said Maria got married to the priest. Her path could be loved the priest she then got political marriage she cheated passed baby off as older nobel's child then died that night she choked her baby. Her eyes went up to her head so she might have had an aneurysm. Possible path.

 

[Kinkaiser]

No that's not what the chapter said. The chapter said that she got married to a vassal. It never said Maria got married to the priest. Her path could be loved the priest she then got political marriage she cheated passed baby off as older nobel's child then died that night she choked her baby. Her eyes went up to her head so she might have had an aneurysm. Possible path.

The chapter said the vassal, named Sylvain, married his sister. Then it said Sylvain spent the last few years in the church, having lost his will to live.

 

[Elhao]

Gonna be real. Whenever someone asks me if I want to isekai, 99% of the time my answer is "No I like flush toilets"

I wear glasses. Imagine the fun of going through life half-blind, because everything is just a blurry smudge.

 

[Miserys_End]

I got the reference now I feel old.

As a child of the 70s, I feel the back pain too...

 

[DrunkinDonut]

Based on what we are shown, Miriana, is unrelated to anyone introduced in the story so far, aside from her parents from Chapter 1.

She was abandoned as a baby, presumably because her Mom was depressed (Miriana assumes Post Partum, Ch1 page 8) and alienated from her own baby, which caused her father to suspect, that she was the child of an illicit lover. My take on what happens with the maid and the father is, He firmly believes she was an illicit child, with the depressed wife trying to kill her to hide her crimes. So he believes he's been betrayed, and has to get rid of her, and keep the Nazath Merchant Guild from finding out. Presumably because this would harm him personally. If, she was royalty, he wouldn't be concerned about a Merchant Guild finding out, he'd be worried about the King and Queen finding out. That'd be a one way ticket to Lese-majeste, and losing your life.

Miriana's elemental affinity, is probably due to the reincarnation. There are only 5 known people with 3 Elements (as of writing in the book), not her All Elements (Chapter 2 Page 20). If it were a trait of Royalty, the book would probably list it. And the author would foreshadow it.

The Vassal, named in this chapter is Sylvain, the High Priest introduced in Chapter 11. He's a vassal, that was in line to become the Chancellor, which is probably part of why he married Marianne, a literal princess. When she and her child died from some illness, he became distraught and retreated from public life into the Temple. That's been 5 years ago, hence the Prince responding in that fashion.

By all accounts, Sylvain was madly in love with his wife, Marianne. There is no evidence, that there was an illicit affair, nor a baby swap before that. We're all privy to their internal thoughts, and they don't seem to be lying about it. For a Baby Swap, kidnapping royalty is a Big Deal, if the Nazath Merchant Guild was responsible, that's a serious criminal conspiracy. You don't just dump the hostage, you bury them deep in a chasm to hide the body.

 

[ApolloX1209]

Ah, The update was slow that I almost forgot that Mille was adopted @.@

But like, what's going on? Isn't she hated by a different couple?

 

[Goldenzeal]

I got the reference now I feel old.

I'm old and did not get it
Care to elaborate

 

[VersVlees]

Honestly, with the 'real parents' on chapter 1, I'm leaning more and more towards there being a baby swap. Millie can use all flavors of magic- I honestly wonder if Maria's baby was swapped in the womb, so she still gave birth, but obviously didn't look like either one of them.

Especially since Prince Leo started laughing when Will said he snuck in. I'm guessing the priest probably has light/darkness power, Marianne had all the other powers? Moreover, they mentioned the "Nazanth Trading Guild". I wonder if that name will come up again.

Actually, I wonder if Millie remembers being a baby well? At this point the memories will of started fading perhaps, unless she has the 2ndary characteristic of all isekai protags- photographic memories.

I thought she remembers everything her from day one. She remarks about how she could finally practice magic something that she could not do as baby. Pretty sure she would recognize her birth parents in this world too.

Also, it isn't a baby swap. The parents sperged out because she did not have any visible blond hair which are signifiers of nobility/magic power. Hence, why the father suspected foul play and couple started fighting ultimately leading to the mother trying to kill the baby.

Although, they should have looked better because she did have some blond hair. Which the couple who found her saw and later on suspected she was a noble child.

 

[N2O]

oh hell yeah glad you're back, it felt like we left off just before the story really started to get going so I was a bit sad

I'm old and did not get it
Care to elaborate

That's from 1993 sci-fi cop movie Demolition Man, ft. Sylvester Stallone and Wesley Snipes. Sylvester's character was cryogenically frozen and unthawed like.. hundreds of years later, into a pretty dystopian future. And they don't have toilet paper anymore. They use "the three seashells". Not specified how they work.

Very good movie, do watch!

 

[MrHanni]

I thought she remembers everything her from day one. She remarks about how she could finally practice magic something that she could not do as baby. Pretty sure she would recognize her birth parents in this world too.

Also, it isn't a baby swap. The parents sperged out because she did not have any visible blond hair which are signifiers of nobility/magic power. Hence, why the father suspected foul play and couple started fighting ultimately leading to the mother trying to kill the baby.

Although, they should have looked better because she did have some blond hair. Which the couple who found her saw and later on suspected she was a noble child.

She only understood her surroundings after 5 months because her vision was still blurry and she couldn't understand the language. So there is some big time gap where stuff could have happened.

 

[HealthyGuys]

Dude, arent him the one that abandone the child ? Or did i Miss remember it ?

 

[DashDashGo]

Imagine buying a house and half of the cost is just for the toilet.

 

[Justking14]

Wasn't it more of people forcing absolute bullshit on him; taking him from his family against his will, calling him morally bankrupt for merely letting psychopaths die on their own, etc. than conveniences? Being forcibly separated from his family becomes a bigger thing as time goes on (whether he truly means it or its just to try to convince them to let him go)

Yeah but toilets were a big factor And something he complained about endlessly

he even created a toilet revolution after same time travel shenanigans

 

[Justking14]

Based off what we see she probably did cheat on him with the priest. Though I'm not certain.

Wasn’t the priest the princess’s husband?