The Deer and the Cauldron

[xKaidoh]

@Lynkaster There actually have been a few different manhua adaptions of this. The novel is pretty famous after all, and Jin Yong is considered one of the foremost authors in the wuxia genre.
Here are two other iterations of the same story:
https://www.manhuagui.com/s/%E9%B9%BF%E9%BC%8E%E8%A8%98.html

 

[4V29LN0n]

Wow, so colorful. /s
I prefer the older comics made in HK, like Lee Chi Ching's stuffs.

 

[ayami123]

Damn It I'm going to Follow this ONE OF MY MOST FAVORITE WUXIA,

 

[Lynkaster]

this guy is not OP, he's just witty and lucky as f*ck 😂

 

[exarmatio]

its good. story is just so-so but art is good especially the detail😀

 

[watchsomemangas]

Wonder why there's no harem tag here, i think this counts as one.

 

[OmegaKaiser]

@ashardalon

Spoiler

Is the name of the first girl, the one inside a dead pig, Mu Jianping? I went ahead to check chapter 54 and she looks pretty.

 

[ashardalon]

Can't upload chapter...The upload button says, "Upload disabled due to image transfer". What does that even mean? Maybe I'll try again later.

@OmegaKaiser yes.

 

[OmegaKaiser]

@ashardalon Thanks for your reply and btw looks like your uploading problem is affecting every other manga.

Update: The bug has been fixed as of right now.

 

[ayami123]

@watchsomemangas because not everybody know the story of the royal tramp

 

[xpsox]

This is the best work(and the last) of Jin Yong and the farthest from WuXia tradition(at that time). It will be 1000+ chapter until reaching the end of story at this pace.

 

[Diana232123]

Hello

 

[SnowingSilently]

How good of an adaptation is this? I've never read this particular work, though I have read a bunch of Jin Yong's other stuff. I'm always skeptical of manhwa adaptations, they often don't live up to the original.

 

[OmegaKaiser]

@SnowingSilently On the defense of this manhua, both the art and plot are well balanced in contrast to a lot of adaptations with fugly art and nonsensical storytelling. Having watched the 2014 TV series and the Stephen Chow movies (the latter skipping lots of content btw), I am pretty pleased with the way this is going.

 

[Ophious]

Why are there such low ratings on such a good story?

 

[OmegaKaiser]

People have been tainted by the casual OP manhua story that they cannot take ze time to enjoy one of the classic gems of wuxia storytelling, @Ophious.

 

[4V29LN0n]

This is a bad rushed adaptation. Same people who did the shitty Smiling Proud Wanderer adaptation. Just read the novel. Or watch the tv series/movies.

 

[OmegaKaiser]

@4V29LN0n The 2014 TV series can be found here or at Rakuten Viki.

 

[humbleoverlord]

I remember the Stephen Chow adaptation of this story, the official subtitle translate Oboi name as O'Brien... laughing my ass off....

 

[alaudae]

There's another manhua from the same book published starting in 2007 by HK manhua artists, much better art quality.