The Reason Why Raeliana Ended Up at the Duke's Mansion - Ch. 67
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
- Joined
- May 27, 2019
- Messages
- 65
In... Catholiscism???? I have been catholic my whole life and I have never heard of that (we don't have goddesses!!!), did the author just throw the name of a real religion and put info of a made up one?? It is that or the author really have bad info of what the catholics believe... It is kind of sad they never get it right...
Anyways thanks for the chapter
Anyways thanks for the chapter
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jun 8, 2018
- Messages
- 1,971
@Silvi_Carolin - what's really hilarious is that what is described is actually an extremist version of Protestant belief, the Calvinist idea of predestination: https://infogalactic.com/info/Predestination
Granted, the pre-Lutheran Church investigated the idea, but found it conflicted with the idea that any human can actually discern Divine Will, so I'm just sitting here, rolling my eyes and snickering at yet another non-Christian conflating heresy with the Church.
Granted, the pre-Lutheran Church investigated the idea, but found it conflicted with the idea that any human can actually discern Divine Will, so I'm just sitting here, rolling my eyes and snickering at yet another non-Christian conflating heresy with the Church.
- Joined
- May 27, 2019
- Messages
- 65
@sylvacoer (sorry if my english is bad)
Oh wow, I never knew this was an actual thing, thanks for the info, I learned something new
But really, the author could just change the name or something, they always do that in this type of stories, though I have to give the author some recognition, after all in reincarnation/transmigration stories involving europe they looooove their corrupt churchs arcs and thank God it doesn't seem they are going that way... Unless the author is planing some Protestant church vs Catholic church arc, but since the Grandfather (forgot his name) seems to have some respect for "Catholiscism" I guess I don't need to worry of another story involving religion drama.
Oh wow, I never knew this was an actual thing, thanks for the info, I learned something new
But really, the author could just change the name or something, they always do that in this type of stories, though I have to give the author some recognition, after all in reincarnation/transmigration stories involving europe they looooove their corrupt churchs arcs and thank God it doesn't seem they are going that way... Unless the author is planing some Protestant church vs Catholic church arc, but since the Grandfather (forgot his name) seems to have some respect for "Catholiscism" I guess I don't need to worry of another story involving religion drama.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jun 8, 2018
- Messages
- 1,971
@Silvi_Carolin - Your English is great, no worries. And I agree, I think the author picked the names because they are recognizable.
Double-page supporter
- Joined
- Mar 3, 2018
- Messages
- 588
@Silvi_Carolin As far as I know "Catholic" means Universal.
- Joined
- May 27, 2019
- Messages
- 65
@RandomPasserby Yep, that is what it means. The catholic church was called universal because God came for all of us and not only to the Jew.
The thing we are complaining is that it have inaccurate info of the religion, so we are saying that instead of misinform people about the doctrins and teachings of an specific religion, it would have been better to just change the name, or investigate better the specific religion and then add an explanation that makes sense in there.
The thing we are complaining is that it have inaccurate info of the religion, so we are saying that instead of misinform people about the doctrins and teachings of an specific religion, it would have been better to just change the name, or investigate better the specific religion and then add an explanation that makes sense in there.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2019
- Messages
- 1,168
Why did the author choose to use the name of real religious groups for their fictional religion...? Both nonsensical and a risk of controversy. Odd choice.
Active member
- Joined
- Apr 11, 2019
- Messages
- 367
Is he just not gonna mention how she essentially fell from a roof on her world, fell on another person from another world, and stole their whole life and identity. And why didn't she mention that this world is a novel from her world? Did she just say "I have memories from another world" And left it at that? And he just believed it and gave an uncharacteristic reaction? Okay, sure, fine.
- Joined
- Jan 22, 2019
- Messages
- 112
@RalekTheOne Same. I was hoping for more development. Maybe it will arrive in the future chaps. At least Raeliana finally divulged her story on someone. That's one less of a worry.
Active member
- Joined
- Apr 11, 2019
- Messages
- 367
@curiousrabbit yeah but it's only being used as a way to advance relationship with this one husbando (priest kid)
Double-page supporter
- Joined
- Dec 28, 2019
- Messages
- 2,590
This is a sort of rant that people probably wouldn't like to read so logic to read or not to read is advised.
idk why but the comments on the other website is nonsensical, like how does that remind you of you own grandpa? your grandparents didn't monopolize you and cuss out a good man nor do they (probably) look that young, did they? I think "grandpa" here is an ass and just because you are antisocial and a high priest doesn't mean you have the right to be a hypocrite and a unmannerd bastard.Look I am a very antisocial person but i know my boundaries, yet you do not and rudely boss around others.I can see exactly why Raeliana didn't want to be your assistant, first of all like me she doesn't like to do work (who does?) second you act like a know it all,and third you don't know how to even tone done the rudeness and treat even Raeliana nicely. there i said it, i hate him.
idk why but the comments on the other website is nonsensical, like how does that remind you of you own grandpa? your grandparents didn't monopolize you and cuss out a good man nor do they (probably) look that young, did they? I think "grandpa" here is an ass and just because you are antisocial and a high priest doesn't mean you have the right to be a hypocrite and a unmannerd bastard.Look I am a very antisocial person but i know my boundaries, yet you do not and rudely boss around others.I can see exactly why Raeliana didn't want to be your assistant, first of all like me she doesn't like to do work (who does?) second you act like a know it all,and third you don't know how to even tone done the rudeness and treat even Raeliana nicely. there i said it, i hate him.
Fed-Kun's army
- Joined
- Jun 13, 2018
- Messages
- 1,158
Rereading but... I still wish we knew what exactly Raeliana told him
@SilviScarlet @Sarah2013
It's a error in translation. In the Korean raws, it was called "구교 and 신교" respectively, which have the literal meanings of "Old faith" and "New faith" respectively (and does not necessarily have connotations to a specific religion), which is what the writer was going for(basically that the religion was fundamentally the same but with a difference in era), but is also used to refer to the dynamic between Catholicism and Protestantism.
It's a error in translation. In the Korean raws, it was called "구교 and 신교" respectively, which have the literal meanings of "Old faith" and "New faith" respectively (and does not necessarily have connotations to a specific religion), which is what the writer was going for(basically that the religion was fundamentally the same but with a difference in era), but is also used to refer to the dynamic between Catholicism and Protestantism.
Similar threads
