The Unrivaled Reincarnated Sage of Another World ~The Strongest in Another World Through Game Knowledge~
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
Member
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2020
- Messages
- 46
My god another one? Srsly?
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Aug 17, 2020
- Messages
- 555
Thought this was a re-upload of another isekai I was following but nope...
*SIGH*
*SIGH*
Member
- Joined
- Jun 26, 2020
- Messages
- 11
Moar pls
- Joined
- Aug 11, 2020
- Messages
- 158
Seems like your average 'i got isekaid into the mmo i was really good at'. Looks decent, except for harem.
I remember reading the novel version of this, I can't say how similar it is going to be because they've already made changes to the plot. For example in the novel his previous life was also set in medieval world, and the game he played was actually from a dream he kept having. It wasn't until he died and reincarnated into the current medieval fantasy world that he became able to take advantage of those dreams. Yeah I know that is a stupid and ridiculous setup, and I'm glad they changed it, gives some hope for this manga.
The biggest issue I had with the novel is how he exploited too many video game mechanics. It has been a while since I read it so my memories kind of fuzzy, but essentially the world started to feel very artificial. I mean things like levels, and skills do strain the laws of reality a bit, but they get a pass if you think of them as a way to better understand the world. For example it is possible to quantify some values like strength, speed, memory, magic power. There was something about this story that went over the line, like I think he was using exploits from the game, and they somehow were working. I'll check back in 7 months, we should have two or three more chapters by then, and it should have gotten to the part that irritated me.
The biggest issue I had with the novel is how he exploited too many video game mechanics. It has been a while since I read it so my memories kind of fuzzy, but essentially the world started to feel very artificial. I mean things like levels, and skills do strain the laws of reality a bit, but they get a pass if you think of them as a way to better understand the world. For example it is possible to quantify some values like strength, speed, memory, magic power. There was something about this story that went over the line, like I think he was using exploits from the game, and they somehow were working. I'll check back in 7 months, we should have two or three more chapters by then, and it should have gotten to the part that irritated me.
- Joined
- Apr 15, 2020
- Messages
- 117
thank you for translating magnos scans like it so far
Double-page supporter
- Joined
- Dec 26, 2019
- Messages
- 1,032
Below average isekai manga. Second chapter and we already see inconsistencies in character behavior and worldbuilding. Usually in average isekai you get to read 10 chapters before it becomes obviously stupid, this one only went till second chapter.
All that ignoring the fact that premise of a game is already stupid beyond doubt.
All that ignoring the fact that premise of a game is already stupid beyond doubt.
@KamiKira00 I havent read it yet but can you tell me what the inconsistencies are? Im wondering if I should read it or not
- Joined
- Jul 25, 2020
- Messages
- 150
same as the comment below, but has the makings of a good anime, 9/10
Member
- Joined
- Jun 6, 2018
- Messages
- 364
He starts to annoy me😂
- Joined
- Jun 10, 2020
- Messages
- 9
Ugggggggggg....
It's ok to have the MC have more knowledge than the average person, or even the average swordfighter. But I mean really!? The natives should have a grasp of basic tactics at least.
Take the wolf for example. He easily dodged the attack and 1 shot it. Lets just assume that a crit is a x10 multiplier. Here's the thing, he has bad equipment and is low level. So someone with decent equipment and a slightly higher level should be able to do significantly more damage than that. So a normal person that doesn't know how to crit could still likely 2 shot the wolf, or even 1 shot it with a skill. So that wolf shouldn't be more than E tier tops (assuming a novice could be expected to beat F tier).
And even if you ignore that, his attack was from dodging on reaction and stabbing it in a specific spot. The specific spot can be chocked up to special knowledge, but his reaction time cannot be. Remember, he explicitly has a bellow average reaction speed. Even with a new body it's not going to be THAT much better than the average person.
So if he could easily reaction dodge the wolf, then someone else with a few battles fought already should be able to do the same. Meaning they could just do that 10 times and kill the wolf with the same equipment, levels ect.
And that sword fight, it's not rocket science that you should exploit openings whenever possible. And a pro swordfighter ought to be in the habit of minimizing time spent vulnerable and maximizing odds of landing a strike. But lets ignore all of that for a second, the MC hit him anyways and crits. 1 shot and he's down already. Isn't that a bit silly? Again, even if we assume 10x crit damage (remember, most games use 2x) levels and equipment in MMO's are a big deal. Even a few levels can make a gigantic difference in damage vs defense. So a swordsman being hit with a level 1 crit, while he might be surprised by the damage, should still be able to tank it no problem.
Is the crit multiplier really just that insane? Is it also true damage or something? Who tf designs a game like that! And if crits are so integral to the game, then it should be obvious that they exist to the natives to the point where all of their martial arts should be warped by them.
It's ok to have the MC have more knowledge than the average person, or even the average swordfighter. But I mean really!? The natives should have a grasp of basic tactics at least.
Take the wolf for example. He easily dodged the attack and 1 shot it. Lets just assume that a crit is a x10 multiplier. Here's the thing, he has bad equipment and is low level. So someone with decent equipment and a slightly higher level should be able to do significantly more damage than that. So a normal person that doesn't know how to crit could still likely 2 shot the wolf, or even 1 shot it with a skill. So that wolf shouldn't be more than E tier tops (assuming a novice could be expected to beat F tier).
And even if you ignore that, his attack was from dodging on reaction and stabbing it in a specific spot. The specific spot can be chocked up to special knowledge, but his reaction time cannot be. Remember, he explicitly has a bellow average reaction speed. Even with a new body it's not going to be THAT much better than the average person.
So if he could easily reaction dodge the wolf, then someone else with a few battles fought already should be able to do the same. Meaning they could just do that 10 times and kill the wolf with the same equipment, levels ect.
And that sword fight, it's not rocket science that you should exploit openings whenever possible. And a pro swordfighter ought to be in the habit of minimizing time spent vulnerable and maximizing odds of landing a strike. But lets ignore all of that for a second, the MC hit him anyways and crits. 1 shot and he's down already. Isn't that a bit silly? Again, even if we assume 10x crit damage (remember, most games use 2x) levels and equipment in MMO's are a big deal. Even a few levels can make a gigantic difference in damage vs defense. So a swordsman being hit with a level 1 crit, while he might be surprised by the damage, should still be able to tank it no problem.
Is the crit multiplier really just that insane? Is it also true damage or something? Who tf designs a game like that! And if crits are so integral to the game, then it should be obvious that they exist to the natives to the point where all of their martial arts should be warped by them.
Similar threads
