Tsuihou Sareta S-kyuu Kanteishi wa Saikyou no Guild wo Tsukuru

[MangaDex]

 

[AMetroid]

Not very good. The "villain" is a caricature. The world building is meh. The problems are solved by running into the right person latter in the chapter or the following chapter. It's like every locked door being opened by checking under the mat to find the key. The author seems to want to speed things along, but the extreme rapid pace just kills any interest.
I don't see this as being worth your time.
Rating: 2/5

 

[NiceGhost]

It's a pretty average and rushed story but I really can't ignore this artwork. I've seen worse but this just bothers me.

 

[Icedragon1]

I suggest the Author Slow down the story a bit. let the Character(s) solve their own Problem through their on will and dedication to the Guild and them Self I can be wrong the last part. 🧐

PS: people PLZ Correct me on my Post I love to hear out anyone Opinion and throughs.​

 

[KaisarX]

artwork is too shit.

 

[PrinceMao]

It's a pretty average and rushed story but I really can't ignore this artwork. I've seen worse but this just bothers me.

Somehow the shoddy artwork makes it feel like the dialogue I'm reading is MTL.

 

[NiceGhost]

Somehow the shoddy artwork makes it feel like the dialogue I'm reading is MTL.

I had forgotten this for a while and saw new chapters... Then I only made it half way in before I decided to stop.
Pretty cover art though lol

 

[shironekonya99]

nenennya gede semua njir

 

[WillemTobey]

Whole thing is one plot convenience after another. Everyone subscribing to the "power of friendship will conquer all" trope. Every chapter is "we're going to have to close the shop" but somehow manage to pull in another crew member, all the equipment and tools and materials they need in infinite with a time limit that's always met on the last day, and sell the product for under suggested retail. ON TOP OF who funded this to begin with? Wasn't him. He said he was broke for weeks and was about to sleep on a park bench. Then everyone joins him and just trusts him because he showers them with vomit-inducing praise causing them to unlock some hidden potential they have throbbing boners for and master within a few days to a week instead of years of practice.

The pacing and writing and art is like beginner level. If it is, ok. Go on then. If not, no way this gets more than 15-24 chapters (looks at raws) 32!!! HOW!!!??? ONGOING!!!??? With all due respect, Japan got some brain dead kids reading brain dead manga. This right here is the reason I'm getting more into long strip Korean stories. Yes their isekaiharemstrongestbigtiddywaifuSSSloserkickedoutrevenge stories are all Solo Leveling clones, but there's more that break out of that box and have better stories than this cookie cutter bullshit. No wonder no one wants to pick this up and run it.

 

[0riginal]

It is awful. About a 3/10, maybe lower.

 

[dimitris96]

Whole thing is one plot convenience after another. Everyone subscribing to the "power of friendship will conquer all" trope. Every chapter is "we're going to have to close the shop" but somehow manage to pull in another crew member, all the equipment and tools and materials they need in infinite with a time limit that's always met on the last day, and sell the product for under suggested retail. ON TOP OF who funded this to begin with? Wasn't him. He said he was broke for weeks and was about to sleep on a park bench. Then everyone joins him and just trusts him because he showers them with vomit-inducing praise causing them to unlock some hidden potential they have throbbing boners for and master within a few days to a week instead of years of practice.

The pacing and writing and art is like beginner level. If it is, ok. Go on then. If not, no way this gets more than 15-24 chapters (looks at raws) 32!!! HOW!!!??? ONGOING!!!??? With all due respect, Japan got some brain dead kids reading brain dead manga. This right here is the reason I'm getting more into long strip Korean stories. Yes their isekaiharemstrongestbigtiddywaifuSSSloserkickedoutrevenge stories are all Solo Leveling clones, but there's more that break out of that box and have better stories than this cookie cutter bullshit. No wonder no one wants to pick this up and run it.

It's a mess in Japan but will see in the future more depression I think have you checked even the newest Mangas some of them are the same like the old ones

 

[Opor97]

the art is so bad and the plot is rushed and amateurish written

 

[xedagnam123]

5/10 after reading 8 chapters.

Art is kind of ugly, it looks like the artist has some skill but has only ever drawn peoples faces so he/she doesn't know how to draw human bodies.

Story is ok so this had potential to be good but because of the bad manga adaptation this is just a flop.

 

[Hermann]

I like these kind of stories, and this one has a nice concept.
But the pacing is completely all over the place, with no sense of time or space. Like the chapter where they had to smith weapons in a week, but it was sequenced like it was done in a day. And many other instances where I had a double or triple take to understand what just happened (did that girl just appear there? Why did that guy just go from happy to offended from one panel to another?).The dialogs have almost no flow, leaps from one point to another that it looks like it's MTLed, and I can't tell if that's the case or it's also like that in the raws.

 

[RiasatSenpai]

The cover art is great...
made me want to give it a try despite the low rating
It's okay. -_-
as mentioned above, i agree the pacing feels off
could have been slower
Cant say the same for the manga art; i've seen & read worse.
The usual trope of the most useful person getting kicked out.
My problem with this one is, all the people MC helped, like that girl and the crafter
mainly the retarded girl, keeps on yapping about bringing me back to the guild..
Why the fck don't you leave and join him?

Do I recommend it?
Not really; maybe come back if it gets translated
since for some reason it is still ongoing...
God bless Japan?
It ongoing, (volume 8)
Surely there is something, no??