Tsuma, Shougakusei ni Naru. - Ch. 111.1 - ANIME ADAPTATION

[T-sama]

Yes, that doesn't mean they all had the change in mind. A lot of plans change halfway through.

Yes, but we can't know which one it is, nothing in the story can be used as proof that it has gone either way.

Implying that "My wife reincarnated, so I'm going to marry her" is less objectionable than "My wife possessed a random child... so I'm going to marry her".

That's only objectionable if the person is a illiterate moron who judges a book by its cover or name, nothing objectionable happened in the story.

I very specifically remember the part where he was talking to her about the abusive, negligent mother, and she snapped at him for talking shit about her. The identities were clearly merged. The idea that they're completely separate entities sharing a single body is only introduced in the second half. Before, we accept that she has memories of her past life, but is also in the body of a child, with its own impulses. Even if I downloaded all my memories to 5-year-old me, he'd probably still love his mom.

No, the identities never merged, she snapped at him because she believe she was her actual mother, your argument falls apart because literally the entire story until she revealed the truth to the mother she had to lie and play the child act exactly because she had  none of the memories, if they merged she would have both memories, she literally had to learn everything she could about the child life to try fool eveyone because the whole time they're separate entities.

And again, who says it's a second half? Your entire argument is based on the premise that the author retconned the story, to which you have zero proof, nothing anywhere implies the author changed how the story would go.

 

[BuyVelomobiles]

Yes, but we can't know which one it is, nothing in the story can be used as proof that it has gone either way.

We have the Null Hypothesis to fall back on. It looks like he changed his mind, the story itself changed its mind, and you have literally nothing to suggest that was the plan all along.

No, the identities never merged, she snapped at him because she believe she was her actual mother, your argument falls apart because literally the entire story until she revealed the truth to the mother she had to lie and play the child act exactly because she had  none of the memories, if they merged she would have both memories, she literally had to learn everything she could about the child life to try fool eveyone because the whole time they're separate entities.

Are your memories your identity? This is getting philosophical fast.

And again, who says it's a second half? Your entire argument is based on the premise that the author retconned the story, to which you have zero proof, nothing anywhere implies the author changed how the story would go.

The first half: "My wife reincarnated/parallel story has FMC remembering"

The second half: "Ghosts/parallel story explicitly changes to have FMC forget"

 

[T-sama]

We have the Null Hypothesis to fall back on. It looks like he changed his mind, the story itself changed its mind, and you have literally nothing to suggest that was the plan all along.

That's your personal opinion, not a fact, like I said it could be either one and neither of us can prove it.

Are your memories your identity? This is getting philosophical fast.

They're part of your identity, she didn't just lose her memories as a child, she literally became an entire different person altogether with her own memories, with the original child personality sleeping, it's for all intents and purpose a Banner / Hulk situation except one is a ghost possessing the other and then she moves on to the afterlife, the entire point of the ending is helping her with her unfinished business so she can rest in peace, no merging ever happened at any point.

The first half: "My wife reincarnated/parallel story has FMC remembering"

The second half: "Ghosts/parallel story explicitly changes to have FMC forget"

Still a single story with no proof the author changed his mind midway, seriously, countless series start with a premise and intentionally changes it halfway, sometimes very early even, example, The Ideal Sponger Life, which very early mc starts working hard instead of actually having easy sponges life.

 

[BuyVelomobiles]

That's your personal opinion, not a fact, like I said it could be either one and neither of us can prove it.

The Null Hypothesis kind of settles it.

They're part of your identity, she didn't just lose her memories as a child, she literally became an entire different person altogether with her own memories, with the original child personality sleeping, it's for all intents and purpose a Banner / Hulk situation except one is a ghost possessing the other and then she moves on to the afterlife, the entire point of the ending is helping her with her unfinished business so she can rest in peace, no merging ever happened at any point.

Right, so his wife just accepted the new woman as her mom all over again?

Still a single story with no proof the author changed his mind midway

If you don't take the story literally changing as the author is saying "Wow, all the problems are solved. There is no more conflict left", as the author changing his mind, then we have nothing to discuss.

 

[T-sama]

The Null Hypothesis kind of settles it.

Still no proof author ran out of material.

Right, so his wife just accepted the new woman as her mom all over again?

His wife is dead, her reality literally is being that woman daughter.

If you don't take the story literally changing as the author is saying "Wow, all the problems are solved. There is no more conflict left", as the author changing his mind, then we have nothing to discuss.

Still no proof author changed his mind, run out of material or anything like that, there was never anything to discuss because you made a bunch of flawed assumptions about what was the author intent.

 

[BuyVelomobiles]

His wife is dead, her reality literally is being that woman daughter.

The kid's reality is being the daughter. The wife's is being the wife. There's no reason to get mad about any amount of shit talking over someone else's mom.

 

[T-sama]

The kid's reality is being the daughter. The wife's is being the wife. There's no reason to get mad about any amount of shit talking over someone else's mom.

There's no wife, she died, it's over, literally, also, who says there's no reason? She believe what he said was wrong because he don't fully know the circumstances + care about the mom, more than enough reason, it's not "someone else mom", it's not some random stranger, it's literally someone with who she lived for months and who she believed to be and accepted as her own mother.

 

[BuyVelomobiles]

There's no wife, she died, it's over, literally, also, who says there's no reason? She believe what he said was wrong because he don't fully know the circumstances + care about the mom, more than enough reason, it's not "someone else mom", it's not some random stranger, it's literally someone with who she lived for months and who she believed to be and accepted as her own mother.

If that's your take on the situation, then that's the last thing covered. You literally don't understand the story, or Human psychology. While "grown woman grows attached to neglectful, abusive stranger as a mother figure in mere months" isn't the dumbest thing I've heard this month, it's only because you're competing with sub-human cretins who literally stare at NTR for two full chapters, and have the author literally tell them it's NTR... before they turn around and deny it's NTR.

 

[T-sama]

If that's your take on the situation, then that's the last thing covered. You literally don't understand the story

Says the person who thinks they merged

, or Human psychology.

Riiight, because mangas sure are guidelines for human psychology

While "grown woman grows attached to neglectful, abusive stranger as a mother figure in mere months" isn't the dumbest thing I've heard this month,

She was more negligent than outright abusive, and she's  not just a grown woman anymore, she's literally restarting her life from childhood, also funny you say "mere months" as if people can't get attached in that time, especially as she got to know the mother and see what was her problems and how she wasn't that bad , so much for accusing others of not understanding the story

, it's only because you're competing with sub-human cretins who literally stare at NTR for two full chapters, and have the author literally tell them it's NTR... before they turn around and deny it's NTR.

Source? Cause you got me curious on the sub-human cretins, which is a funny description since that's valid for vast majority of manga readers

 

[T-sama]

.

 

[BuyVelomobiles]

Riiight, because mangas sure are guidelines for human psychology

Yeah. Especially grounded dramas.

She was more negligent than outright abusive, and she's  not just a grown woman anymore, she's literally restarting her life from childhood, also funny you say "mere months" as if people can't get attached in that time, especially as she got to know the mother and see what was her problems and how she wasn't that bad , so much for accusing others of not understanding the story

Yeah, no. Between being perpetually afraid of the thing, and it being someone else's mother, mere months aren't going to have her develop an inherent familial bond with the abuser.

Source? Cause you got me curious on the sub-human cretins, which is a funny description since that's valid for vast majority of manga readers

(It ended up being a single chapter of NTR. My brain turned one into two). It's ItaiAmai 29. Summary: Manga is NTR bait. Sensei is dating a gravure model, and they're constantly implying NTR is happening. Sometimes at school, sometimes are her job, and sometimes during her gravure work. Chapter 29 hits, and she's filming porn...

Spoiler: I'll take 1,000 of you over a single one of these... things... any day of the fucking year. And twice on Sunday.

Those aren't even all the comments. I just wanted to give you an idea the profound levels of retardation I've been dealing with.